Misused: Menstrual Menace get usage counts
Deadlock Clock: 28th Feb 2014 11:59:00 PM

Total posts: [72]
1 2
3
Wow. This trope needs fixin'
Crazy rabid squirrel
Okay, now that we know it needs fixing, how are we going to fix it?

My suggestion is to rename Menstrual Menace into Supernatural Period.
Get out of my mind, idea! I already have an idea in there!
Crazy rabid squirrel
I've created a new YKTTW for Supernatural Period here. May I also suggest red-linking the Menstrual Menace page as a disambiguation page if/when Supernatural Period gets approved.

Edit: This expands Menstrual Menace to encompass entries other than "Period does bad supernatural things," to "Period does supernatural things."

edited 28th Nov '13 11:14:56 AM by maddthesane

Get out of my mind, idea! I already have an idea in there!
Crazy rabid squirrel
Has this gone stale? It looks like it's gone stale.

Will mark it as so on Monday if someone else doesn't reply sad
Get out of my mind, idea! I already have an idea in there!
Crazy rabid squirrel
I have edited a lot of the misuses and zero context examples that are on the second page of this thread. Most of them have the following as the edit reason: Menstrual Menace is about supernatural horrors caused by a woman's period. All Periods Are PMS is about women being cranky that time of the month. See this Trope Repair Shop thread for more info.

edited 8th Dec '13 1:36:38 PM by maddthesane

Get out of my mind, idea! I already have an idea in there!
56 shimaspawn8th Dec 2013 08:51:53 PM from Here and Now , Relationship Status: In your bunk
Thank you for all your hard clean up work. Is there anything else that still needs to be done?
Reality is that, which when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away.

-Philip K. Dick
Crazy rabid squirrel
I only fixed the ones from my second usage count, so only up to "p". I'll finish the rest of the mentions later, probably tomorrow if I don't get distracted.
Get out of my mind, idea! I already have an idea in there!
Crazy rabid squirrel
There, most of the misuses should be fixed now.

Also, sorry if I was a little overzealous and changed a few that were Menstrual Menace: they might not have been explained properly.

Also sorry for not alphabetizing the change of tropes: it's kinda hard to do so if you want to keep something in the pasteboard with a tablet.

edited 8th Dec '13 11:45:10 PM by maddthesane

Get out of my mind, idea! I already have an idea in there!
Crazy rabid squirrel
[up][up]As for what needs to be done: rename of Menstrual Menace. I currently have a YKTTW entry for a rename here. It itself has gone through a rename due to an ambiguous name.
Get out of my mind, idea! I already have an idea in there!
60 SeptimusHeap9th Dec 2013 08:21:05 AM from Zurich, Switzerland , Relationship Status: Mu
Another Wizard boy
Is that a rename? To me, it looks like you want to draw a new trope to move some of the misuse in.
61 shimaspawn9th Dec 2013 01:14:24 PM from Here and Now , Relationship Status: In your bunk
Yeah, that looks like a supertrope, not a simple rename.
Reality is that, which when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away.

-Philip K. Dick
Crazy rabid squirrel
Menstrual Menace is about supernatural horrors caused by a woman's period. My proposed "rename" removes the "horrors" part. If you don't think this is the right course of action, we could do just a rename and not a replacement trope.
Get out of my mind, idea! I already have an idea in there!
63 shimaspawn10th Dec 2013 08:40:58 AM from Here and Now , Relationship Status: In your bunk
I think a supertrope is valid, but a redefinition is not a rename. And a supertrope will help with the misuse. I just think that the general implication of it being evil deserves it's own subtrope.
Reality is that, which when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away.

-Philip K. Dick
Crazy rabid squirrel
Fair enough.

Although the renames that come to my mind are Supernatural Menstrual Menace and Magical Menstruation Gone Bad. There's probably a better name than those that can be used.

edited 10th Dec '13 9:13:28 AM by maddthesane

Get out of my mind, idea! I already have an idea in there!
Crazy rabid squirrel
I'd appreciate some feedback or discussion about renaming Menstrual Menace.
Get out of my mind, idea! I already have an idea in there!
With Mod Hat On
Clocking for inactivity. There's stuff in the posts right above this one which can be discussed.
67 Willbyr19th Jan 2014 05:04:54 AM from North Little Rock, AR , Relationship Status: Pining for the fjords
With Mod Hat On
Re-clocked.
Crazy rabid squirrel
I think I'd use Magical Menstruation Gone Bad for the rename, due to the confusion the "base" trope was having with the other name.
Get out of my mind, idea! I already have an idea in there!
Crazy rabid squirrel
My YKTTW for Supernatural Period, now named Magical Menstruation, has been changed a bit:

->This expands Menstrual Menace to encompass entries of "Period does supernatural things." Menstrual Menace will not be deleted. Instead. It would be a subtrope of this one, covering specifically the "Period does bad supernatural things."
Get out of my mind, idea! I already have an idea in there!
Crazy rabid squirrel
Also trimmed down the explanation to be more generic and less of a copy of Menstrual Menace.
Get out of my mind, idea! I already have an idea in there!
71 Willbyr25th Feb 2014 04:04:04 AM from North Little Rock, AR , Relationship Status: Pining for the fjords
With Mod Hat On
Re-clocking this one.
With Mod Hat On
Never went anywhere. Locking.
The system doesn't know you right now, so no post button for you.
You need to Get Known to get one of those.

Total posts: 72
1 2
3