Needs Help (titles crowner 6/2/14): Medieval Japan

Total posts: [55]
1 2 3
1 Larkmarn8th Jul 2013 10:20:02 AM , Relationship Status: Hello, I love you
From the title, it really sounds like it's a Useful Note or just for settings set in Medieval Japan but the description makes it out to be a Western interpretation of Japan as a Theme Park Version or Hollywood History version of Japan (which is completely not indicated by its title).

Then of the six examples, only one of them isn't a ZCE and it's specifically saying that they did do the research. I'm not familiar with any of the other works so I'm not certain if they're just Western works set in Medieval Japan, or if they're Hollywood History versions.

I feel like the lack of definition is part of the reason this is so underused, since I daresay there's a lot more than six examples of Western fiction set during then.
2 StarSword8th Jul 2013 11:22:30 AM from somewhere in deep space , Relationship Status: In denial
You are of Bajor.
Works set during this period seem to be covered by Jidai Geki, which also has a bit of historical stuff on it. Thoughts?
Dragon Writer
Jidai Geki is ... in need of an English name. Oh, wait, it already has Feudal Japan as a redirect.

Feudal vs. Medieval ... wait, what?

In-page examples are definitely zero context. Approx. 30 articles linking to it — how do they fare?

edited 8th Jul '13 3:09:16 PM by Stratadrake

4 Larkmarn8th Jul 2013 03:23:12 PM , Relationship Status: Hello, I love you
First ten real examples:

Age of Empires II: Mentions historic battles in Medieval Japan... take from that what you will.

Video Game/Alteil: Says it's a fantasy counterpart culture to Medieval Japan... which means it's misuse since A: It should be Feudal Japan and B: That's called Wutai

Characters/Dominions: Ditto

Fighting Fantasy: ... ditto.

Flavor And Story Tropes: Says it uses a mixture of the two... but again, I'm pretty sure that is just Wutai.

Friendly Enemy: Real life example, so it should be Feudal Japan.

Gilbert and Sullivan: Unambiguously correct.

Hollywood History; Live-Action TV: Administrative, so they don't count.

No Peripheral Vision: Correct.

Occidental Otaku: Um, tough to say. The example uses both Jidai Geki and Medieval Japan, but it seems to use Jidai Geki for the Hollywood History example and Medieval Japan for the "guy who teaches Japanese history" one, which seems backwards.

Oddly Named Sequel 2: Electric Boogaloo: Refers to a fictional nation that's a "clone of Medieval Japan" so... wouldn't this be Wutai?

Okay, my conclusion is that either I am vastly misunderstanding Wutai, or other people are. Also note that most examples were potholes, not its own example.

edited 8th Jul '13 3:28:07 PM by Larkmarn

I'd merge with Wutai. The correct use looks Too Rare to Trope.
6 SeptimusHeap9th Jul 2013 01:24:46 AM from Laniakea , Relationship Status: Mu
Seems like this needs to be a disambig between Wutai and Jidai Geki.
7 Larkmarn9th Jul 2013 05:44:14 AM , Relationship Status: Hello, I love you
[up] That makes sense.

That said, as Stratadrake pointed out, would it make sense to reverse the redirect and change Jidai Geki's name to Feudal Japan?
8 SeptimusHeap9th Jul 2013 05:48:49 AM from Laniakea , Relationship Status: Mu
With 358 wicks, the default response is "No, why?".
Jidaigeki (時代劇) refers to a genre. It's not a trope about Feudal Japan in general.
EDIT: I no longer support making this a disambiguation. See my post below to see why.

"Feudal vs. Medieval ... wait, what?"

Technically, Feudal refers to a social/political structure, and Medieval refers to a time period. One can have a medieval society that is not feudal, and vice versa.

edited 24th Jul '13 4:58:55 PM by Catbert

11 SmytheOrdo14th Jul 2013 04:25:55 PM from In The Mountains , Relationship Status: watch?v=dQw4w9WgXcQ
Wide Eyed Wonderman
Speaking of this, who wants to help me with a possible Pre Imperial Japan useful notes?
David Bowie 1947-2016
12 Larkmarn14th Jul 2013 06:42:02 PM , Relationship Status: Hello, I love you
[up][up] Feudal vs. medieval have different definitions, but Medieval Japan and Feudal Japan are one in the same.
13 SeptimusHeap15th Jul 2013 12:41:06 AM from Laniakea , Relationship Status: Mu
^^Ask on YKTTW.

Crowner for the disambig?

I'm not opposed to it.
15 SeptimusHeap19th Jul 2013 11:24:50 AM from Laniakea , Relationship Status: Mu
Looks like the crowner's been attached.
16 Spark920th Jul 2013 10:59:48 AM from Castle Wulfenbach , Relationship Status: Too sexy for my shirt
Gentleman Troper!
I thought Eddie was opposed to Japanese names for pages here?
Special trousers. Very heroic.
17 SeptimusHeap20th Jul 2013 11:02:49 AM from Laniakea , Relationship Status: Mu
Probably. That said, if you want to rename either trope, you should make a thread for these.
18 StarSword20th Jul 2013 11:26:38 AM from somewhere in deep space , Relationship Status: In denial
You are of Bajor.
[up][up]We're not making any new ones, but we're only changing the existing ones when they turn out to be confusing.
Wutai, at least, is not a Japanese name. Its Trope Namer is a location in Final Fantasy. If you look closely at the definition, it should only apply to a Fantasy Counterpart Culture that is based on Japan but is not in fact Japan.

Jidai Geki is the name of a genre of Japanese period drama. It is a preexisting term. Properly speaking, it should only be used for Japanese Media set during the Edo period (1603 to 1868) or earlier.

So actually, our approach was mistaken.

If we get rid of Medieval Japan, there will be no category for Western depictions of Japanese historical pieces.

I now withdraw my previous agreement with the suggestion to merge. I think that merging it would be a mistake, and the desire to merge it has risen from people not reading the trope definitions closely enough to catch the distinctions.

Medieval Japan says "But in Hollywood, Japanese history is pretty much one long indistinct period filled with..." and "For a look at native Japanese anime and live action film depictions of this era, see Jidai Geki."

Clearly "Hollywood" is meant here to mean Western Media. It is contrasted with Japanese Media, which is Jidai Geki.

Medieval Japan also says "The fantasy equivalent is Wutai."

That is backed up by the description on the Wutai page, which says "The village/country/continent in a Medieval European Fantasy world which has inexplicably (and suspiciously) fashioned itself off Jidai Geki."

edited 24th Jul '13 5:00:50 PM by Catbert

If so, Medieval Japan may need a new name.
[up]That might be a good idea. The first thing that comes to mind is Hollywood Medieval Japan, but I'm not sure if making more Hollywood Style trope names is still considered permissable, or if that would be regarded as snowcloning.

Also, based on a quick look, Jidai Geki needs cleanup for misuse. It might also be a good idea to custom title it as a Jidai Geki (Genre) to address concerns about using Japanese terms which are not well known to your average American.

edited 25th Jul '13 5:12:22 AM by Catbert

22 SeptimusHeap25th Jul 2013 05:15:19 AM from Laniakea , Relationship Status: Mu
I would support the latter notion, but as a separate discussion.
Good catch, catbert!
Bump for votes.
25 StarSword21st Aug 2013 08:36:47 AM from somewhere in deep space , Relationship Status: In denial
You are of Bajor.
Bump again.

Alternative Titles: Medieval Japan
2nd Jun '14 4:51:19 AM
Vote up names you like, vote down names you don't. Whether or not the title will actually be changed is determined with a different kind of crowner (the Single Proposition crowner). This one just collects and ranks alternative titles.
At issue:
Previous crowners decided to define Medieval Japan as "Western depictions of Japan." and rename it accordingly.

Total posts: 55
1 2 3