Everything above the examples is a mess. I think it's supposed to be about fandoms gaining a large LGBT fandom, but the description just repeats that it doesn't have to be unintentional and is not written in good English. The laconic version actually contradicts the main definition. It says that something is beloved by gays, suggesting that it's something within the work, not the work itself. The image is of David and Jonathan with a caption, which doesn't illustrate the trope well. It seems to be Just a Face and a Caption. The ambiguous name is a problem as well. It's not a Relationship Writing Fumble and doesn't have to be unintentional, so it doesn't fit into the X Yay Snowclone family. Together with the unclear description, it sounds like people think the fans are gay than that they actually are. I suggest alternate titles of Homosexual Demographic and LGBT Demographic, and a rewrite of the description so that it keeps the notes of intentionality to the very end of the description. The speculation can be moved to the Analysis page.
edited 4th Jun '13 6:41:41 AM by MikuruFan
A Wizard boyThis seems like it's snowcloned off Ho Yay, but without a thought for the actual description. The image also illustrates Ho Yay and nothing else. Rename this, pronto.
I'd support the rename, and some improvement of the description as well.
Gentleman Troper!I concur.
Special trousers. Very heroic.
SF-81A Black KnightThis seems like Periphery Demographic But More Specific, actually. My vote would be to merge it.
I think I disagree there with you. I think eager interest from LGBT communities is distinct enough and might deserve its own audience-reaction page.
Well, he's definitely not wrong about what it is. The question is whether it's significant enough to deserve its own spin-off. Honestly, I think it's fine to keep it. Just rename it and clean up the description some.
A Wizard boyI am neutral on a merge.
A Wizard boyBumping for votes. The tally is:
In its current state, this is about a work that develops a definitive LGBT demographic. This does not have to be unintentional, as bolded text emphasizes. So this is not a subtrope of Periphery Demographic.
A Wizard boyAlt Names. I have found only one name here, so far.
Added two. One of which was in the first post.
edited 29th Jun '13 5:18:59 PM by AmyGdala
A Wizard boyBump for votes. Right now, LGBT Fanbase is the only one in the green but only 5-3.
This is Rain. Isn't she pretty? :)I want to say Gay Yay, but that's already a redirect to Ho Yay. I put it on the list anyway.
edited 9th Jul '13 12:20:44 PM by PancticeSquadCutterback
A Wizard boyThumbed it down, since a) it's unclear and b) the Audience Reaction covers the whole LGBT spectrum, not just male homosexuality.
This is Rain. Isn't she pretty? :)I had half a mind to put "Rainbow Brigade" on there, but that's even less clear.
The more I look at this, the more I'm not sure if it's really tropeworthy.
Total posts: 36
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from firstname.lastname@example.org.