Two Christmas wormsYes. It's a disqualifier.
Boss DestroyerAlright, so that means I can remove Fire Lord Ozai, because he's motivated to Take Over the World? That was one example that I found very questionable.
Two Christmas wormsYank Ozai then.
Fight It Out!If having a motivation - even a generic one like Take Over the World, is a disqualifier, then most of the examples one the very page are disqualified since they have motivations. Lame onea, but Motivations nonetheless. Doomsday had a motivation: He's a Blood Knight and was looking for a fight Bane wanted to take over Gotham... Etc...
edited 12th Feb '13 4:50:04 AM by Ghilz
Two Christmas wormsYeah, cut these examples when you see them.
What if they really are being evil for the sake of being evil?
Two Christmas wormsI think this trope's definition is no "cited" motivation. If they state explicitly For the Evulz, cite it for that instead of Generic Doomsday Villain.
ZzzzzzzzzzThere's a difference between "goal" and "motivation". A Goal is what you want to do. A Motivation is why you want to do it. "I want to take over Gotham, just 'cause I want to" is a goal without a motivation. "I want to take over Gotham to get revenge on the people who didn't help me when I was homeless" is a goal and a motivation.
edited 12th Feb '13 5:36:06 AM by Madrugada
Half the work on any project is done the week before the deadline. The other half is done the week after.
Sharknado WarningSo Ozai would still be an example then? EDIT: Someone deleted a ton of examples, including some that AFAIK are valid.
edited 12th Feb '13 5:47:49 AM by CobraPrime
Two Christmas wormsCalled them in.
I apologize if I caused a problem, I saw the clean-up thread and thought I might help in my own way. I cut the examples of villains, I felt either didn't fit the criteria as was already point out in this thread or are fairly popular with their respective medium's fanbase in which case, they cannot really be generic as there are people out there that like them or find them interesting.
That's not how we're using the word generic here.
Definitions of GENERIC A : relating to or characteristic of a whole group or class : general B : being or having a nonproprietary name <generic drugs> C : having no particularly distinctive quality or application <generic restaurants> I assumed the page was going with definition C as well as the idea that this character here is boring. If not, than again I apologize for getting involved in a matter I had no real business in.
Boss DestroyerIf we included the part about the character being boring, then we would have to put the YMMV banner on it. This trope doesn't have the YMMV banner for a reason. Now, can we also erase the wiki clean of everything that says that Doomsday is the Trope Namer considering he's not even an example of this trope (anymore, at least).
Boss DestroyerGoing back to what Madrugada said about motivation and goal; the Laconic says that the definition isn't that there is no motivation, it's that the motivation and goal are incoherent. This is where things can get a little messy, since I think the coherence can be a little subjective.
No, the other one.I think it's something like the difference in Show, Don't Tell. If we're just briefly told (lampshade, token nod, or something else that isn't elaborated on), about the villain and who she is, it counts, but if we're actually shown why the villain has the motivations she has, then it doesn't count.
Check out my fanfiction!
Two Christmas wormsRegardless, you should never judge a trope by its name.
Boring Invincible Villain. It was renamed way back when. 
edited 13th Feb '13 10:17:31 AM by troacctid
Rhymes with "Protracted."
Boss DestroyerThe name has to be at least somewhat indicative of the trope definition. Otherwise that's one of the factors that leads to misuse.
Boss DestroyerI'd say you can just delete this thread now, since I think we've made enough progress and it turns out the issue wasn't that big in the first place.
Two Christmas wormsLock you mean.
The system doesn't know you right now, so no post button for you.
You need to Get Known to get one of those.
Total posts: 48
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from email@example.com.