Needs Help: Loudness War

In order to really get it, you must read the note of the caption. Does Not Illustrate if the caption is gone. Needs a better image.

Keep Until Better Image Suggested

I'm going to vote Pull. Even reading the caption tells me nothing.

Some suggestions: By years, Comparison◊ between original "Head Like a Hole" and remastered version, generic comparison◊, G n' R vs. Green Day

Wow, that's bad. Pull it.

I like your #4, Wilbyr. The song titles give the missing context.

The current, while it does illutrate the trope, is hard to see since you only see a green field, and not the small variations you see even in extremely loud sounds.

I like 1 and 4 in #4.

Keep Until Better Image Suggested on the current. Thankfully, 4.1 and 4.4 are better suggestions.

Bump; other thoughts?

Re-bump...should this be crownered between the two options that people like, or can we come to a consensus?

Some of the people who expressed a preference liked 1. Everybody who expressed a preference liked 4. Sounds like a consensus to me.

Would it be even better to add the years of the songs to #4?

They can be added in the caption, unless someone with time and opportunity wants to do it...I have neither right now.

The pic's up. How's the caption?

Works for me. I went through the page and removed three references to "the page image shows"

Caption's good. I kinda agree the years should be present, though.

The problem with showing the years is that "Better" was actually released after "American Idiot", which undermines the "newer albums are louder than older" theme of the war.

edited 8th Nov '12 7:42:23 PM by Willbyr

The band's somewhat older, though.

I added a note to the caption pointing out the songs' ages, or rather, the albums they're one. Locking up.