Continued from here, the current image doesn't show anything at all. The background could be read as a storm (?) and the figure in the middle could be seen as someone (or two or three people) looking at one menacingly, but I can't see anything even close to Complete Monster. Current:

edited 6th Oct '12 3:35:47 PM by SeptimusHeap

It looks like there's something crashing in the background, and that the middle figure had something to do with it.

I've given my thought on it, and it still stands.

Motion to pull

edited 6th Oct '12 4:16:14 PM by EarlOfSandvich

^^ Even if the caption clarified that the figure in the foreground is causing the crashing/storm in the background, that might say "monster", but not "complete monster". Should look irredeemably evil. I think that image is worse than nothing because it suggests JAFAAC is okay for subpages, and it's not.

It's bad. I'm getting the wrong feeling. She looks angry, but nothing says irredeemeable act of villainy. Worse than nothing, indeed.

^It's a she?

Anyway, to make it explicit:

Motion to remove

It's not JAFAAC. Whether it's a good enough image for the strict requirements of the trope is another matter, though.

edited 6th Oct '12 4:25:13 PM by AnotherDuck

It is if given context the character is legitimately a CM. That is not evident from the image.

edited 6th Oct '12 4:42:22 PM by rodneyAnonymous

The main issue I have is that the image is really ambiguous.

Is there a good image of Mr. Plinkett we could use?

+1 to pull for the aforementioned ambiguity.

Plus 1 to remove.

The page actually even says that the character is not an example.

• Note: Despite the page image, Xandra doesn't qualify. She's a Well-Intentioned Extremist who wanted to create a new world without the rule of the Faeries, because she viewed them as lazy and greedy. To do so, however, she unleashed Wraiths that suck the life out of other Neopets, turned the Faeries and some of her own allies to stone, and caused the destruction of Faerieland. If anything, Xandra set the stage for a real Complete Monster to make her return...

edited 6th Oct '12 10:07:07 PM by Scardoll

Wow, it's not even an example? Definitely remove.

Seven and gone:

Removed the useless non-example that admits it's a non-example.

I would be fine with the page being imageless for probable lack of a good picture.

That'd suit me just fine.

Either imageless or a good substitute (which I can't see so far).

How about providing an image with Malachite from Suburban Knights ripping the man's heart out?

What's that look like, and is it too gory for a TV Tropes image?

That is possible. However, I did try looking for a good picture of Malachite on GIS with little luck. Taking a screenshot from viewing the special may be your best bet there.

edited 23rd Oct '12 8:02:59 AM by EarlOfSandvich

I'd propose one which shows Sigma or Omega from RVB. God knows they've earned this trope.

The CM thread voted to cut everyone from Red vs. Blue.

How about Carl from Llamas with Hats with the body of a man whose hands he just ate?

Nah. We deemed him a non-example a while ago.