Eh, the Japanese School Club
page doesn't seem to be much focused on fiction, no. Yeah, a single line in the in the first paragraph as well as two other short paragraphs. The most descriptive parts, however, seems to generic, real life talking.
Which isn't how a Useful Note
should be, anyway? Although these pages talk about Real Life
, they also try to tie it to their usage in midia, doesn't it? We are a media wiki, after all. The current page doesn't seem to be about a trope. It is too generic and devoid of meaning. It is just about any (Japanese) work which have school clubs at some point.
A proper trope would be when a school club are commonly used in a namer that differ vastly from reality or for more specific recurrent types. Which is why I proposed creating the "School Club Story
" and "Wacky School Club
" tropes early.
Also, yeah, Noaqiyeum, an Useful Note
can be for all kinds of School Clubs
all around the world. Probably with specific sections for US school clubs and Japanese ones, since they are more prevalent in this wiki, but no need to restrict ourselves here. It can also become an Index for proper School Club
tropes. Can an Useful Note
be a Index?
I also would support a Useful Note
about school systems. Japanese school system is surprisingly similar to Brazilian one, so I never got lost, but the American one confuses me sometimes. Not to mention the British houses thing which is apparently not restricted to Harry Potter*
edited 19th Oct '12 5:57:04 AM by Heatth