I still haven't voted on this one yet and looking through a volume, I'm inclined to call this porn. However, I did want to get the disposition squared away before voting since it's at 2-2. What do you guys think?

Going by what I've seen of it, it appears rather pornographic. Personally, I'm inclined to cut it.

OK, that's what I was leaning, but I would still like to hear from Discar and Meeble before we do anything. And Cat, although I doubt Cat's gonna show at this point.

From what I could see I'm more inclined to trust Shimaspawn's judgment on this (that there's a greater focus on the story than on the sex), since she seems to be familiar with the work, and my trawling for images came up with a pretty good amount of non-pornographic material.

This is one that's pretty hard to judge without having the full body of the work to review, so it comes down to a question of "Is this wank material with an Excuse Plot or a fantasy story with explicit sex elements like Oglaf?" Based on Shima's commentary, I went with the latter.

I've sent a PM to Shima asking her to expand on her original comment if possible.

edited 25th Jul '12 6:57:08 AM by Meeble

I was going off what shima said as well. Unfortunately, since it's an old comic, it will be hard for anyone to get a hold of, so that's really all we can go off of.

Despite what I said previously, voting angel. Would "Keep and clean" be OK?

Sure.

OK. Resolved. Posted a note in the Special Efforts thread. Hollering for thread closure.