Japan seriously considers building real-life Gundam mechas for Defense:

Total posts: [272]
1
2 3 4 5 6 ... 11
1 SgtRicko27th Jun 2012 06:16:18 AM from Guam, USA , Relationship Status: Hounds of love are hunting
Japanese political party may build giant anime robots

Yes, you read that right: some folks in the Japanese government have expressed interest in building an actual Gundam-like mechs to be used for combat purposes. Seriously!

The first thought I had when seeing this article was "it's going to flop even before it gets any funding or support". It's too big of a target, would require an impressive engine to keep running, can easily be disabled simply by attacking the legs, and would likely be a bitch to maintain in the field. Yet... they must be aware of that too, right? So why would they want to even go through with such a costly idea?

I'm thinking that they're trying to use the whole "HEY GUYS WERE GONNA START BUILDING FREAKING GUNDAMS!!!!1111" simply as a means of generating interest into their plans. Once they do have an audience, they'll tone down the scope of it into something more reasonable: say something along the lines of the Gekko mechs from Metal Gear Solid 4: small, nimble and fast mechs capable of taking on light armor and infantry while being expendable.

So, what do you guys think?
Would you believe I never fully watched the original Indiana Jones trilogy? I gotta correct that someday.
2 Gabrael27th Jun 2012 08:10:39 AM from My musings , Relationship Status: Is that a kind of food?
I think it's brilliant! The oppertunities of new technology and what other real life problems they can work out with it are so worth it! For example, figuring out the best technology to work out the joints and movements to be safe and strong could also help advancements in human prosthetics.

Besides, why not make one? The first generations of this probably won't be very battle worthy, but you have to start somewhere.
"Psssh. Even if you could catch a miracle on a picture any person would probably delete it to make space for more porn." - Aszur
Oh My
...

Japan despite all the horrible shit you do that makes me question why I love you you manage to do things like this.

Does this sound stupid? Yes. Quite. It's awesome though and as Gab there said it could provide us with uses and technological advances in the civilian level.
If someone wants to accuse us of eating coconut shells, then that's their business. We know what we're doing. - Achaan Chah
4 lordGacek27th Jun 2012 08:15:28 AM from Kansas of Europe
KVLFON
@OP: You mean, Japan finally admitted to it?
"Atheism is the religion whose followers are easiest to troll"
5 Rationalinsanity27th Jun 2012 08:39:25 AM from Nova Scotia, Canada , Relationship Status: [TOP SECRET]
Earth Over All
From a Civilization mod:

"Military traditionalists have repeatedly pointed out that the Assault Mechs are very poorly designed weapons - farcically bad, some have even said. They're extremely tall and are almost impossible to camouflage, making them easy targets. Their two-legged gait is more complicated, more expensive, more vulnerable and less efficient than are treaded wheels. And if one of the blasted things fall over, it can't get up again without the assistance of massive cranes or helicopters. Yank off the legs and mount the chassis on treads, the experts say, and you'll get a better weapon at lower cost.

All this is true. However, the units have one thing going for them that more than compensates for all of their weaknesses: they're massively, enormously cool. Military planners have long noted that national governments often confuse coolness with effectiveness and are willing to pay a lot more for flashy armaments than they are for effective but dull systems. In other words, a military with Mech Assault units has an easier time getting its bloated budget approved than does one without them. As long as this continues, the Mech's future is assured."

Maybe this is their reasoning? At least them falling into the same trap?
Maybe they are just exagerating.

Wouldn't surprise me if the final product is only about a foot tall.

A small infiltration style robot would have more utility than something the size of a building.

Easier to make, less costly to mass produce given Japan's hirtory with Robot Products like the Aimo and similar knock offs.
7 Ekuran27th Jun 2012 08:48:42 AM from somewhere. , Relationship Status: watch?v=dQw4w9WgXcQ
Hi.
I think I'll just get this out of the way.

"OMFG ROFL LMAO LOL HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA."

On an incidental note, this is the first time I've actually used internet acronyms.

Seriously though, this sounds cool but it'll never happen.

edited 27th Jun '12 8:52:13 AM by Ekuran

[Insert seemingly profound or amusing phrase here.]
8 Fawriel27th Jun 2012 09:03:59 AM from the bottom of my heart , Relationship Status: If it's you, it's okay
THE MEEK
It might have some psychological advantages to have an iron giant staring down your enemies. But I guess if anything's going to come out of this, it'll be heavily modified to work more effectively. Like treaded wheels under their legs or so. And smaller, definitely. Their actual size is physically downright impossible. It'd be hard enough to stop it from collapsing into itself, let alone getting it to move, let alone by moving its legs.
SHALL INHERIT THE EARTH
9 entropy1327th Jun 2012 09:04:22 AM from Somewhere only we know. , Relationship Status: Drift compatible
わからない
[up][up][up][up]They specifically said "Gundam", meaning, all those weaknesses listed does not exist.

Now the problem for Japan is to finding the real-world Minovsky reactors, Gundamium, GN Drive, etc.

edited 27th Jun '12 9:04:51 AM by entropy13

I'm reading this because it's interesting. I think.
Whiskey, Tango, Foxtrot, over.
Oh My
Japan needs to make a real God Gundam to represent its country and military might now.

I demand it.

They will burning finger sword people into oblivion.

If someone wants to accuse us of eating coconut shells, then that's their business. We know what we're doing. - Achaan Chah
Eh I don't know. It's been shown that mechs are not as efficient as conventional wheeled/tracked vehicles.
Now using Trivialis handle.
Oh My
They aren't nearly as cool as the karate wielding doom bot that can ride a horse mecha(piloted by a horse in spandex) though.
If someone wants to accuse us of eating coconut shells, then that's their business. We know what we're doing. - Achaan Chah
13 lordGacek27th Jun 2012 09:31:04 AM from Kansas of Europe
KVLFON
Japan needs to make a real God Gundam

Poland already has one.
"Atheism is the religion whose followers are easiest to troll"
Maybe it will just be Power Armor first?

Military Giant Robots seem a bit ambitious. (perhaps for remote deep sea opeartion?)
Oh My
...I am now picturing Jesus using the Erupting Burning Finger and all other moves available to the God Gundam and its weaker Shining Gundam form.

...this is okay. GO JESUS GO!!!
If someone wants to accuse us of eating coconut shells, then that's their business. We know what we're doing. - Achaan Chah
Long Live the King
I think people are missing the real point behind building Gundam mechs.

While it would probably be a mediocre or outright bad idea for national defense, it would give them an edge in space. The Mark 1 could enter and exit Earth's atmosphere with relative ease, after all...
17 FFShinra27th Jun 2012 11:12:33 AM from Ivalice, apparently , Relationship Status: Too sexy for my shirt
Beware the Crazy Man.
I say to this, "meh".

....if only because I'd want them to build Metal Gear Rex first. grin
Final Fantasy, Foreign Policy, and Bollywood. Helluva combo, that...
Flying Dutchman
Last I heard the party that announced this is the official crazy party. Either way, humanoid robotic combat vehicles would be worse than useless and power armor is a pipe dream for the foreseeable future, so this is basically tantamount to saying "we want to make a large pile of money and then set it on fire!"

They probably would be better off just buying tanks with the R&D money and forgetting this silliness. Well, actually, they'd be better off using this money for something productive, like infrastructure or healthcare, since Japan isn't going to need ground vehicles in the near future.
"Can ye fathom the ocean, dark and deep, where the mighty waves and the grandeur sweep?"

19 lordGacek27th Jun 2012 12:43:36 PM from Kansas of Europe
KVLFON
Plus, even if they ever have a problem that would warrant the construction of Humongous Mecha, they can deal with it just as fine sticking to mundane solutions, like summoning Godzilla.
"Atheism is the religion whose followers are easiest to troll"
20 InverurieJones27th Jun 2012 12:49:02 PM from North of the Wall. , Relationship Status: And they all lived happily ever after <3
'80s TV Action Hero
Ooooh. Mechs. Like a Figure 11 for tanks.
The owls are not what they seem.
21 pagad27th Jun 2012 01:03:49 PM from perfidious Albion , Relationship Status: Having tea with Cthulhu
Sneering Imperialist
Eh, real-life mechs would just entail real-life Shadowswords to kill them with. tongue

edited 27th Jun '12 1:04:39 PM by pagad

Typhoid and swans - it all comes from the same place.
22 Greenmantle27th Jun 2012 01:09:45 PM from Greater Wessex , Relationship Status: Hiding
Land of Confusion
@ Derelict:

They probably would be better off just buying tanks with the R&D money and forgetting this silliness.

Funny you should say that: Type 10.

Anyhow, would a Macross-type Mecha be more practical?
"It's been a long, hard road but you must carry on"
Flying Dutchman
Don't Macross mecha transform? That's even worse, because now you have conservation of mass issues.

Literally any "mecha" is utterly worthless for warfare. Industrial applications? Maybe. But mecha on a battlefield are a moving "kick me" sign and you'd be better off and more tactically, strategically, and scientifically sound with tanks as it is.
"Can ye fathom the ocean, dark and deep, where the mighty waves and the grandeur sweep?"

24 RocketDude27th Jun 2012 01:20:28 PM from AZ, United States
I'm an Irene!
And combining mecha. They are the home of Sentai after all. wink

Total posts: 272
1
2 3 4 5 6 ... 11