The 11th GroverI've probably been guilty of misusing this one in the past - bottom line is, I think it's much more narrow than it first appears. The trope description says that it isn't just about a certain word or phrase that gets repeated. It's specifically when said word or phrase without context that is likely explained near the end. The trope description even notes that it is not a Catch Phrase or Running Gag. The problem is that much of the examples on the page itself are drifting from that. We have the obligatory uses of catchphrases (yes, Gurren Lagann and the standard quote of indignation is listed), a repeated word that is not at all mysterious as to what it means ("Rise" from Blackest Night, which is blatantly obvious as to its meaning almost immediately), and even vague blanket statements that are only tangentially related (the note about Bokononist statements in Cat's Cradle). I admittedly haven't gone into detail about how it's used on other pages, but my anecdotal experience is that it's just as misused outside of the page itself. I'm not sure what would be the appropriate action, to be honest. Is this too broad of a name for what is actually a more narrow trope? Is this just simple misuse that ought to be cleaned up? Is the definition too narrow for what the concept should be? I'm kind of at a loss as to this page.
Unexplained Arc Words or Enigmatic Arc Words would work better?
Small, viciousI concur. A rename could only help, and I think Enigmatic Arc Words is the stronger of the two suggestions. There's going to need to be quite a bit of cleanup on works pages for this one, too. I've seen this misused to death by people who've probably never even read the core page.
"Pale Ebenezer thought it wrong to fight, but Roaring Bill (who killed him) thought it right." - Hillaire Belloc, The Pacifist
The 11th GroverEnigmatic Arc Words would be better of the two, since they are generally explained eventually... just not until the end of the arc in question. The reason I subtly suggested a Trope Transplant is because I think the problem is that folks see the phrase "Arc Words" and think it simply means a word or phrase that appear in an overaching fashion that present a thematic element to the piece in question. I don't know if we have such a trope (I know, take that to Lost and Found), and such a trope would probably cover all of the misuse this current one has. If said trope doesn't exist, I think the logical move would be to use Arc Words for the name of the trope covering said overaching thematic phrase and use Enigmatic Arc Words for what the current description describes. That said, I'm not totally certain that'd be the best option in this case.
edited 20th Jun '12 11:35:37 AM by 32_Footsteps
Wow, I had no idea that's what Arc Words meant. I've seen misuse all over the place.
Arc Catch Phrase trope, which is what Arc Words is often being misused as, would create a supertrope to Enigmatic Arc Words. I don't see an inherent problem with that. I also checked out Arc Number and Arc Symbol to see if they have the same problem. Arc Number does, but not Arc Symbol, which seems to be more correctly used.
Considering the massive levels of misuse, it would probably be far easier to transplant the narrower definition over to a new name, and keep the old name as the supertrope.
Isn't that just encouraging misuse? And many of the examples aren't even catchphrases, e.g.:
The point of such a transplant is to turn the incorrect use into correct use, so we don't have to go and manually fix several thousand wicks, not to mention the near-impossibility of changing the way the troper hive mind views the trope.
A girl and her demon catI think a trope transplant is the way to go. The current description doesn't align at all with the way it's used.
Sometimes seen with a "526" after my name.
The 11th GroverWell, so far, nobody in Lost and Found seems to have come up with a trope with the broad meaning that people have been using Arc Words for - I do believe that Missing Supertrope Syndrome has struck again. This thread seems to be moving a bit slowly - I wonder if it's because it seems pretty cut-and-dried. Regardless, would a Page Action Crowner be appropriate at this time?
So the proposal is that Arc Words stays, but is redefined as simply "a recurring phrase used many times during the story arc, possibly with shifting meaning or context" (like "RISE" or "Who the hell do you think I am?!"), and then Enigmatic Arc Words takes over the "you keep hearing it but it doesn't mean anything until the end" (like "Bad Wolf" or "Rosebud")?
Three StepsSounds fine to me, but how do we distinguish the supertrope Arc Words from a mere Catch Phrase? Personally I feel there is a distinction, but we need to put it words to prevent future misuse (or is it already misused for this?).
To borrow the meaning of leitwort (mentioned in the description): "The repeated use of a phrase in order to highlight a theme within a text." Catch-phrases, on the other hand, are usually said by a single character, and used either as a gag or for the sake of characterization.
The 11th Grover@14 nails it, I believe. Also, I think a Catch Phrase is a subtrope, since it does generally present a thematic element for the piece. It's just usually specific to a single character or group.
Catch Phrase is a pre-existing term with a slightly different meaning. (It's probably in the dictionary, although I haven't checked.)
edited 22nd Jun '12 4:57:16 PM by troacctid
Rhymes with "Protracted."
Ecce Homo SuperiorI support a trope transplant. I don't think I've ever seen this trope used correctly according to the current definition.
(it's David Bowie)
A girl and her demon catAs was alluded to in Lost And Found, the new supertrope would be similar to Meaningful Echo, the difference seeming to be that the supertrope covers phrases that are used more than twice.
Sometimes seen with a "526" after my name.
The 11th GroverIt also would cover cases where the phrase in question always was meaningful. If you note Meaningful Echo, the first version of the phrase is specifically not meaningful.
Ravenous SophovoreGiven the amount of misuse here, I'm going to bump rather than clock this. This really could use action. I concur with a trope transplant. Let's get a crowner and make it official.
Waiting on a TRS slot? Finishing off one of these cleaning efforts will usually open one up.
Puʻu ʻŌʻōWould Chekhov's Phrase make a good name for the transplanted trope?
A professional at being ignored.I think the difference between Arc Words and a Catchphrase is that a Catchphrase is something that one person likes to say, while Arc Words appear all throughout the story. They don't have to be ambiguous or enigmatic or even have a single definable source. Personally, I like the page just the way it is, without all the nitpicking or pointless overorganization.
Dragon WriterYes, a Catch Phrase is generally unique to one character and that is not lumpable with a word/phrase that has particular meaning to a given Story Arc.
That trope is called Sharephrase.
World's Toughest MilkmanHmm, so as long as we're discussing this trope, I have a question about a possible example. Can it be really long? As long as it meets all the other criteria? In Creatures of Light and Darkness, there are three short paragraphs that are repeated several times throughout the book (at least six, maybe more). At one point, there is even a full chapter that consists of nothing but these three paragraphs. You have no idea what they mean until near the end. "...An eunuch priest of the highest caste sets tapers before a pair of old shoes. "...The dog worries the dirty glove which hath seen many better centuries. "...The blind Norns strike a tiny silver anvil with fingers that are mallets. Upon the metal lies a length of blue light." Now, that seems really long for what the trope describes (a word or phrase), but as I say, it meet every other criterion. Is it an example?
edited 4th Sep '12 1:21:54 AM by Xtifr
"Existential Despair" is an oxymoron.
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from email@example.com.