likes the cheeses.
This thread will be used to gather links to posts which provide relevant information on works that are up for review by the P5. The rules of this thread are as follows.
- Provide direct links to posts in the About Content Violations Discussions
or Page Restoration Petitions threads that are relevant to individual works that the P5 is reviewing.
- DO NOT make arguments for or against a work in this thread. That should be done in the above mentioned threads.
- Providing links for works that have a specific thread already are ok, however don't add links to posts in the work-specific thread (since that would be redundant.) Links should once again only come from the threads mentioned above.
- Please provide the name of the work that is being referenced, as well as a direct link to the post in question. To get a direct link, click on the time-stamp above the post you want to link to, then copy the url from your browser address bar.
- Links to arguments for or against cutting a work are fine, as long as they contain meaningful content about the work in question. "I think this should stay", and "This seems like paedo-shit to me!" without further elaboration are not useful here, nor are arguments over the P5 guidelines in general.
- Arha will be reading this thread and editing the provided links into the post(s) immediately below this one. Please follow any additional instructions Arha may give you.
- Before providing a link, please check to make sure that the link isn't already listed in one of Arha's posts below.
- Questions, corrections, and suggestions about how this thread is run are ok, but keep the discussions as concise as possible. Any posts that don't involve this thread's maintenance or provide the types of links we are looking for will be hollered for being off-topic.
- Thanks in advance!
edited 30th May '12 11:24:24 AM by Meeble
Post reserved for future use.
edited 30th May '12 11:05:55 AM by Arha
Post reserved for future use.
edited 30th May '12 11:05:59 AM by Arha
Post reserved for future use.
edited 30th May '12 11:06:02 AM by Arha
likes the cheeses.
Ok, now that Arha has reserved the space he needs to maintain the list, I am officially opening the flood gates for everyone else to respond with links related to P5 efforts.
As mentioned in the OP, please limit discussion in this thread to providing links to posts we need, or questions/suggestions relating to how this thread is operated.
I checked the first 25 pages of the Content Violation Discussions page. It was mostly just debating over how we were going to do things and thus easily passed through, but I did put in some updates. I have the time to keep this all updated, but that's not the same as going through every page of the relevant threads myself. This thread needs more people to find any objectionable material: I can't do it all alone. If you are willing to search a particular section of the thread or have a specific post to link to now is a good time to come forward or PM me or Meeble.
edited 31st May '12 12:26:48 PM by Arha
Fumblin' With The Blues
Re:
Koibana Onsen
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=13349331300A11026600&page=156#3877 Verdict ctsy. Pyrite
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=13349331300A11026600&page=156#3889 Elaboration on above
Re:
Sky Girls
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=13349331300A11026600&page=166#4130 * post contains links to other posts that may be helpful as well, linking here would be redundant
Final verdict in latter half, top half is thoughts during act of reviewing, which may be helpful
edited 31st May '12 5:07:56 PM by tdgoodrich1
![[up]](http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/smiles/arrow_up.png "[up]")
Thanks for putting the posts related to
Esper Mami (I was going to recover them). Here I have two posts related to my flagging and re-review for
Sankaku Complex.
edited 1st Jun '12 3:11:13 AM by GendoIkari
likes the cheeses.
Good job so far everyone. Since there are only so many works that I can review at any given time, I felt that a lot of good analysis by the people participating in these Content Violations threads was being missed.
This will make things a lot easier for me once I begin reviewing the works that are listed, since I can go to one location and easily find the scattered discussion points related to those works.
Keep up the good work! Your effort is greatly appreciated.
edited 1st Jun '12 4:44:06 AM by Meeble
Everyone's Grudge
Try not to pothole: unlike on the main page, there's no "source" button, so leaving it in a form more amenable to copy-pasting would be preferable.
Under Grand Hotel (cut pre-P5 because it was indexed on
Hentai)
edited 1st Jun '12 10:15:08 AM by lebrel
Calling someone a pedant is an automatic
Insult Backfire. Real pedants will be flattered.
Seeking for Light
Shiniez evaluation:
edited 1st Jun '12 10:46:48 PM by Nocturna
Hammer of the Pervs
I don't want to shit this thread up with conversation, but why are we listing arguments for works that we've already voted to keep? Berserk has been reviewed and isn't going anywhere, for instance.
"Did anybody invent this stuff on purpose?" - Phillip Marlowe on tequila, Finger Man by Raymond Chandler.
likes the cheeses.
I figured it couldn't hurt if it gets brought up again, say, six months down the road. It could save us from re-treading the same ground.
![[down]](http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/smiles/arrow_down.png "[down]"){kind=icon}
Arha said in a PM to include them in case they come up for re-review.
