Page Restoration Petitions:
edited 26th Sep '12 11:08:01 PM by Sabbo
- Manga and anime should be considered independently due to their different treatment of the material. (Opinions differ. Shima and I thought the anime was cleaner; Hydronix / Irene thinks the manga's cleaner. Regardless, both require review.)
- Original vote was 3-2 to cut, with Martello, Fast Eddie and Meeble voting to cut while Discar and Komodin voted to keep.
- Original appeal is based on the grounds that decisions were made based on an insufficiently-large sample size of the content to be representative of the tone of the work as a whole, if the content was reviewed at all.
- Last appeal was submitted during a period when there were only 3 active members of the 5P and many other works in the worklist. In view of the risk of getting caught in a deadlock, motioned to suspend further discussion until a full 5P could be convened.
edited 27th Sep '12 9:20:00 AM by Pyrite
edited 27th Sep '12 3:00:28 PM by Komodin
edited 28th Sep '12 5:08:52 AM by Catbert
edited 28th Sep '12 7:26:00 AM by tdgoodrich1
edited 9th Oct '12 9:57:04 PM by JHM
edited 10th Oct '12 8:37:06 PM by InsanityPrelude