Total posts:  1 2 3 5
I think we have a clear path to go here.
Puʻu ʻŌʻōI've moved the page text and the indexes, as well as made the notifications, but I won't take the wicks right now. Also, seems like the topic is already starred; you can ignore the request then. I took it off the Scrappy Index because it does not seem to me that its inclusion is justified by anything other than "People don't like this trope", which seems a tad little for an index.
So... the discussion page is full of people dissatisfied with the name change. And some of them bring up good points; the new name (while a vast improvement) does nothing to really clarify what the trope is (An ineffectual Gimmick Class). It does, at least, make it much less likely for it to be misused for The Bard, which is a huge improvement.
Puʻu ʻŌʻōSo ... considering what was said above, do we continue with the rename process?
edited 5th Dec '13 11:07:32 AM by Larkmarn
Puʻu ʻŌʻōBumping this for more input.
Puʻu ʻŌʻōAnd again requesting more commentary.
For (Food) Science!Well, to be honest, the description of the Quirky Bard is too long-winded for me to really understand what the class actually means, but if the Laconic are accurate, they appear to be very similar to Mechanically Unusual Class, with a touch of Joke Character or Lethal Joke Character. Some of the posts in the discussion page suggested a merge... The former has more wicks and inbounds, but the latter seems much clearer in its name and description... maybe turn this page into a subtrope of Gimmick Class (since it's apparently limited to bards)?
edited 6th Feb '14 7:51:39 PM by theAdeptrogue
Bard" archetype—the most typical features being a jack-of-all-trades skillset, Magic Music that tends to grant Status Effects, and generally filling a Support role of some kind—and thwack it with the Tropes Are Not Bad stick so it's not restricted to Bards Done Poorly? It's a tropable trope and this page is already very close to it.
edited 12th Feb '14 6:05:39 PM by troacctid
Rhymes with "Protracted."
For (Food) Science!Isn't that what this trope is already about?
Quirky Bard doesn't work as a title.
Rhymes with "Protracted."
YKTTW that tackles "a gimmick unit made useless by gameplay mechanics", But More Specific. evidence of this definition in the description:
The class doesn't need to be called "bard" to count: any character class that specializes in messing with status effects in a game where status effects are useless or giving ability point bonuses or penalties that are too minor to make up for not simply making another fighter can count. Keep in mind that simply having a "Bard" type class is not sufficient - they have to be spoony bards: characters with useless abilities that typically nobody will want to use a party slot on.do these characterstics fit Spoony Bard by virtue of the snippet? Grave Buster. it has the following characteristics: it's purpose is to remove obstacles which block your artillery units' fire.
here is my suggestion on how to fix this: dewick everything, remove all examples, make a new one with a revamped description to remove any references to "spoony" or "bard". the name is solely a Fandom In Joke (and Trope-Namer Syndrome at it's finest) that cluttered the description with pointless references to the bard (which isn't what it's about in the first place) that doesn't clear up the trope meaning that doesn't work anymore due to how big TV Tropes is now. Spoony Bard itself as a Take That on bards in general seems tropable, so Spoony Bard should come back with that definition. that way, we get a "fun trope" and a proper trope. and yes, I'm suggesting this precisely because I'm willing to make the page if no one else steps up. beware Engrish though. as for Mechanically Unusual Class, it doesn't need references to the bard or any entertainment profession, it promotes shoehorning (A class called Blade Dancer? Mystical Minstrel? it must be MUC! except they're a regular DPS class and Black Mage with tacked on gimmicks that don't really change the core gameplay of the class). it must concentrate on establishing the fact that the class works and not what stuff we can shoehorn to it.
For (Food) Science!Indeed.
Rhymes with "Protracted."
The Plan, it will be called Spoony Bard. what is now known as Quirky Bard will be the game trope, which will not mention bards at all.
... isn't The Bard a trope about bards?
For (Food) Science!Unless he's talking about Bard-Class characters in RPGs?
edited 28th Feb '14 11:31:13 PM by theAdeptrogue
Not impressed with the new title- it's not really better in terms of clarity, and is considerably more boring. Plus, as others have noted, there's way too many references to the old title all over.
edited 10th Mar '14 10:00:00 AM by DrVillainous
This entire situation is kind of a mess. As written, the Quirky Bard page is torn between whether it refers to quirky characters who are bards (as the bulk of the main description implies) or classes that are simply unusual (as most of the examples and the Laconic description indicate). I am for delegating unusual classes to Mechanically Unusual Class like they really should be in the first place (since as-is this seems like flat-out redundancy without a meaningful distinction) and re-purposing Quirky Bard to be the intuitive and much-needed character trope. As far as Quirky versus Spoony, I feel like Spoony has more character to it and is definitely far more ingrained in this wiki's culture, but Quirky is probably more self-evident. Someone really just needs to make a command decision at this point.
Changing the name to 'Quirky Bard' does nothing to fix the problems that this trope has acquired, nor does it mesh well with the page itself. The definition (dictionary definition) of the words Spoony Bard are right under the thread title! The page itself, from the definition to the examples presented, are what needs to be fixed. The title itself? Nothing big at all. I feel this site has gotten a tad too trigger happy with the name changes, but I exaggerate. Changing names should be one of our last resorts, especially when we have had it for so long. P.S.: If we do make a name change, it damn well better be clever. A name that blatantly describes the trope in question is bland.
Quirky Bard". I guess I'll holler for a new crowner, so we can get this over with.
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from email@example.com.