The problem, as I understand it, is that if the trope is about simply "looks which combine short skirts/pants with thigh-high stockings/boots", then you can safely rename it and rewrite the description to effectively say just that *

with maybe a paragraph on how this trope eventually became almost inescapable in Japan

, since the look in no way originated in Japan or is particularly Japan-exclusive. On the other hand, if the look has some secondary significance—say, if the look is sometimes tied to some particular personality types—then every example that follows that correlation needs to be separated into a different, specific trope, while those who don't are either discarded or kept as a different super-trope.

edited 8th Sep '12 11:26:26 AM by DoKnowButchie

Hard splitting the grades is off the table. The crowner resoundingly rejected the idea.

The name is horrible in my opinion, even if it's a out-the-wiki term.

Bumping this and the associated YKTTW.

From my reading of this trope, there is a sufficient gulf between the YKTTW and Zettai Ryouiki that both of these can exist as separate pages. Also, as we mentioned before, there does seem to be a meaning of the grades, so we can just continue at implementing the crowner's solution.

That said, we need to address the concerns against the name Golden Thigh Ratio. Are there alternatives?

Sock Gap. :D

I like Sock Gap. Anybody for/against that? Do we need a crowner?

Which trope would that be for?

The YKTTW.

Some people are wondering if the Sock Gap supertrope is tropeworthy. It already has three "Tropeworthy?" tags in YKTTW.

A tropeworthy tag alone is a bad argument. Why isn't it tropeworthy?

Looks like the YKTTW examples need quite a bit of cleanup. Should get that done before launching.

So, where are we at right now?

The decision here is what amount of context is sufficient for Zettai Ryouiki.