Just a question: Is the rest of the winning options in the crowner going to be implemented as well?

Bumping for answering.

Fair enough.

edited 6th Mar '12 9:14:45 AM by SeptimusHeap

This is something that is going to take Eddie time to code. Things will be dealt with as they can be.

Yarp: I'm in no rush. Guy needs to remember to eat, you know?

Just spotted a niggle-like issue thingy: if you go straight to a YKTTW's discussion page, you can't see hats 'n stuff. You have to go through the actual YKTTW page and go longhand. It's not that big a deal, but just highlighting it.

^ I've noticed that for a long time, and it is a big deal in certain cases (such as TRS dealing with poorly launched tropes). A YKTTW's permanent URL must display everything that it does on the main listing.

edited 6th Mar '12 7:57:49 PM by Stratadrake

I don't remember if it was brought up, but in a YKTTW I'm curently working on, I noticed something. With my draft closed, it shows four hats, but when I open the draft and go below the comments, it only displays three hats.

Bug?

Yeah, bug. I've seen it as well and even discussed it here.

I'm not sure if it's just me, but I've found that YKTTW aren't opening. Clicking on the button gives the same ~1 sec pause as I'd expect just before the OP and replies appear and the "read" marker disappears, but nothing else happens.

Yes, it's happening to others as well.

Fast Eddie is aware of it.

For now, to read a YKTTW, use the permanent history link (upper right corner of the header, the chain with a green arrow).

Yes, that's what I've been using myself.

New version YKTTW is up.

Thread Hop: someone familiar with the changes should edit YKTTW Guidelines to reflect them.

The "show flags only" button doesn't seem to work for me at all. It just shows all the YKTTWs again. Is anyone else having this problem?

edited 13th Mar '12 10:07:12 AM by girlyboy

Yup.

Yeah, the flag-view button doesn't work so far.

By the way, how do the filters work? Do they screen for keywords?

Flag view is back.

Would it be possible to re-implement the "comments added since you last opened the draft have a green check next to them" feature? Scanning down the list of comments (particularly if it's one of the ones with 50+ comments) trying to find the first comment you haven't read yet is less-than-ideal.

The tagging system doesn't seem to be working. I've tagged Band Of Heroes with "Needs examples" and and "Description needs help", but neither it nor any other YKTTW draft shows up when I use the "filter by tag" feature.

I dunno about you, but the new layout won't let me "open" the entries like draws anymore, instead, it links to the permament page.

I think that's deliberate.

However, the new layout isn't causing the green "updates" check to go away, even after the draft has been opened (in the new window) and everything has been read.

@689: I changed the one sentence that needed changing. Something about the tag system should probably be drafted and added at some point, but only the bit about how to reply needed changing on the current page. This is an interface change, not a process or policy change; the YKTTW Guidelines deal almost exclusively with the process and policy.

I agree the green arrow-thing should be back. It's a very useful feature.

It is intentional. That way people can open the proposals up in different tabs just like if you were going through the wiki.

edited 13th Mar '12 11:02:41 AM by Belian

Green checkmarks are back.