I've not seen a huge problem with Natter on Headscratchers pages that's not just left over from when it was called Headscratchers
— that is, old entries that hadn't been deleted when the change was made. Add to that, people who didn't participate in the last rename thread don't know why
it was changed. If you want to change it, maybe add a disclaimer to the top of all the Just Bugs Me pages that "This isn't a place to whine and complain, but raise questions about plot holes, weird moments, and general questions about works."
Re: Why Not Just Forumize It?
— Much like WMG, it can't work as a forum because of the nature of it. We've already got a bit of a problem with multiple entries over the same thing, forumizing it would make it even worse. Someone'll say "It doesn't make sense that Alice died when she got thrown out of that window in season two, considering that pretty much the exact same thing happened in the third episode of season one." One or two people'll say "yeah, you're right" and move on with the thread, then three pages later, someone who was late to the party'll say the same thing and waste everyone's time. In addition to that, you'd have to sort the posts in some way, since the alternative is having
- Post 1: Why'd Alice Die in Season Two?
- Post 2: Because X
- Post 3: Because Y
- Post 4: Why'd Bob Shoot Dave in Season Three Finale?
- Post 5: Reason Alice Died Z
- Post 6: Reason Bob Shot Dave X
- Post 7: Why'd Carol Join Alice in Season One?
- Post 8: Why Didn't Alice Just Kill Carol in Season One
- Post 9: Reason Y Bob Shot Dave
- Post 10: Reason X Alice Didn't Kill Carol and Reason X Alice didn't die again
With no sort of organization. And God help you if the get to four or five pages. As it is now, at least it's somewhat sorted.
They lost me. Forgot me. Made you from parts of me. If you're the One, my father's son, what am I supposed to be?