These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
Arc Fatigue: Pig Island, in the Tekkit series. It became the main focus of the series for a very long time, and despite being funny, fans steadily grew increasingly annoyed that Simon had apparently completely forgotten the Jaffa Factory, which was supposed to be the main goal of the series. They eventually lampshaded that the plotline went on a bit too long.
Broken Base: The series is mostly beloved, but in general the fandom is known to occasionally have rather mixed and vocal opinions on certain things. See below:
Episode 25 of Sjin's Feed the World series has left the fans a bit torn on multiple fronts. On one hand you have people torn on Kim becoming Sjin's apprentice; Some think she's an annoyance who doesn't add anything, while others think that she and Sjin would make a cute couple, or that she adds to a plot that sometimes became dull with only one person who has nobody to bounce off of. On the other hand, The Strawfingers plot is starting to evolve into something somewhat reminiscent of the earlier Shadow of Israphel episodes; The fans can't agree whether or not this is a good thing.
Similarly, the new Feed the World episodes with Lewis and Sjin have been a bit divisive. Fans are either happy that Sjin has someone to bounce off regularly, or worried that Strawfingers and the Sjindig will be dropped. (This last part has been confirmed not to be true).
Episode 96 of the main channel Galacticraft series has the fandom split to an extent, albeit not as much as the above cases. You're either happy that the Jaffa Factory is getting the spotlight again, or you feel that it distracts from the main purpose of the show.
If Episode 96 of Galacticraft wasn't enough, Episode 105 really caused a serious divide. Simon's destruction of the factory via launching a rocket from inside is agreed to be funny due to how stupid it is, but it's caused many people to get seriously angry since they wanted to see the place repaired. The following arc has Simon buy a new plot of land from Hat Films so the guys move location, which has caused a similar divide between those who like the change and those that think it's scripted.
The delay in the release of Blackrock episodes is starting to cause this. There seem to be two groups - people constantly harassing Rythian (and telling him his channel will "die" unless he releases it) and people who accept Rythian's apologies and explanations, and are perfectly happy to wait for the next episode.
The animated Israphel videos have caused a broken base in just about every way, to the point that it would be quicker to list how they haven't.
Shadow Of Israphel in general. It was, depending on your POV, the best thing since sliced bread that should come back, something interesting that ultimately isn't missed too much, or "the only reasonfans cameto the channel in the first place", with comments such as "SHADOWOFISRAPHELNOWHURRYUP" popping up annoyingly frequently.
Monster Hunters with Simon, Hannah and Kim. A funny, entertaining show that makes a nice change from Hole Diggers, or an annoying distraction? As usual, Kim seems to get a lot of the flack, for some bizarre reason.
The finale of Hole Diggers has split some in many respects.
There are those that think the series ended at the right time and didn't drag on for too long, as is the consensus with "Site Bee" from Tekkit. Others wanted to see what the crew could create with more time, viewing the series as a little too short.
The end of the final episode, where a black hole suddenly gets set off in the middle of the Dwarf Star, was divisive since it appeared to be scripted. Some felt it was funny in spite of this, others felt that it being scripted automatically made it not funny, and a third group found the ending to be a little unimaginative, having seen similar results towards the end of Voltz and JaffaQuest.
Israphel started the show as something of a Troll and prankster, but as the series went along he became far darker and much less amusing. Before the show even started, he is revealed via flashback to have murdered Peculier's mother, forcing his father to make a Heroic Sacrifice to seal him away, then continued to stalk him and make his life a living hell, largely by murdering people he was getting to know and driving him paranoid. In the present, he orders Jock_Fireblast to burn down Mistral City and BBQ Bay (which works on the first count and narrowly fails on the second), zombified Granny_Bacon and then tried blowing up the church in which her funeral was taking place, and would happily turn on Minecraftia to release the Sand God. It goes to show that in a series full of strange creatures and Laughably Evil foes, Israphel has set the standard for sheer vileness.
Jock Fireblast, one of Israphel's henchmen, is a nasty piece of work who burns down Mistral City, framing Skylord_Lysander for this and nearly getting him killed as a result. He then tried to do the same (and was visibly viewed doing so) to Barbecue Bay, a settlement full of people that thought him their friend, if Simon and Lewis hadn't stopped him. Even then, he almost succeeded.
Critical Research Failure: Let's just say the fandom doesn't do its research on certain things, such as claiming that this show was the reason the main channel was first created.
The death of Enoch in Shadow of Israphel is disgusting, as is the discovery of all his body parts. This is immediately rendered darkly funny when Simon and Lewis begin picking up the body parts and hitting each other with them.
Simon's attempt to build a Santa on top of the Jaffa Factory is already brilliant, simply because it's so badly done. When Simon decides to make a pimp Santa and gives it red shades and a cigar, Duncan says it looks like posthumously exposed paedophile Jimmy Saville. Simon reacts in horror, which adds to the humour.
In Episode 21 of Hole Diggers, Duncan asks if the giant statue-building they're making is going to be a giant version of Gary Glitter (exposed paedophile, now released and being charged again). Simon hurriedly shouts "NO" repeatedly.
Israphel and Strawfingers both get this for being a BadassKnight of Cerebus for their respective series (Shadow of Israphel and Feed the World /Sjin's Farm).
Skylord_Vitali is regarded as being one of SOI's creepier villains, and has fans for it.
Fridge Brilliance: Simon and Lewis ignoring what everyone else is saying, even while they are answering questions they just asked, is kind of annoying. Then you go back and watch some of their old World of Warcraft videos, and you realize that they're used to ignoring quest text and NPC dialogue. They're just acting like they normally would while playing an RPG!
"We start off quite simple, but then, as you go, things get more complicated." Spoken by Simon very early on, back when the series was just a simple Let's Play, and now it's become a complicated adventure.
In the earlier Minecraft videos, Simon has to delete his Mo' Creatures modded world because the bunnies are breeding like, well, bunnies and overpopulating his world. Come 2014 when rabbits were introduced in the actual game, and the developers actually had to stop this from happening, since the game would lag out if nature took its course.
Skylord_Jasper is hinted to be lovers with Skylord_Lysander, if Shadow of Israphel Part 26 is any indication.
From Deep Space Turtle Chase:
Lewis: Were we sharing this chamber? Tere's not a lot of room in here, how long have we been in here together for?
Simon: We've been in suspended animation, so, you know, there's no funny business.
Lewis: Oh okay. So it only passed in like a second for us, so in fact we didn't have time to...I see.
Later, while they're looking through doors they can't get into, Lewis complains because he wants to go in there and touch things, because he likes touching things. Simon complains that that line's going to encourage the slashers. They start to wonder if there actually is any Honeydew/Xephos slash and laugh, and Simon says "Come 'ere!"
Part 4 of "The Tree Of Life:
Simon: So yeah, just two men, swimming together under a starry night sky. Nothing wei- Lewis: Well, technically, you're a dwarf. Simon: Right, right. A man and a dwarf, swimming under the night sky. Nothing weird about this at all. Lewis: Right. Simon: ...Lewis, I'm not wearing any pants. (Beat) Lewis:What.
Simon and Duncan in Survival Games Part 1.
Lewis and Sjin in the Tekkit maps eat the last Lesser Spotted Derpy Pig together during the sunset, and apparently form a "forbidden friendship" as a result on their work on the oil rig.
Rythian spends a significant time obsessing over Duncan and Sjin. Duncan also once tried to keep Rythian prisoner as his lawn ornament.
Then there's the famous outtake of the Diablo III unboxing where Lewis walks into a wall and splits his lip open. Simon's reaction is to kiss it better.
There have been several more kissing incidents, some of them stemming from request on the livestreams.
When Simon meets JesseCox and Dodger, it becomes this when Simon and Jesse hug and rub their beards together.
Sips and Sjin play up this trope as much as possible, and pretty much encourage people to ship them.
Discussed by Duncan and Sjin in their Skyblocks series, when they name their house. Unable to compromise on a name, they agree to each choose the nicest word that comes into their head. Duncan chooses "pillow", while Sjin chooses blowjobs, much to Duncan's amused surprise.
Duncan: You know we'll be two men living in this house?
Sjin: (hurriedly changes the sign to read "clouds" instead)///
The fandom NEVER shuts up about Shadow of Israphel taking some time. Their refusal to do so has caused members of the Yogscast to express outright annoyance at this, with Lewis outright saying it doesn't motivate him to get back to production. Any jokes about it from the crew cause a smaller scale backdraft, particularly Sjin and Duncan trolling the audience in their Gravity-themed adventure map. It got to the point where people started posing as group members claiming Simon had died and that they needed funding to finish it.
Episode 105 of Jaffaquest caused one after Simon blew up the factory, with some fans feeling even more annoyed that the following arc seemed to be scripted. This caused a counter-backdraft.
The fact that Daisy_Duke and Granny_Bacon get captured, and in Granny_Bacon's case killed is pretty much universally known among the fanbase.
The fact that Episode 38 has been out for a while, and the fact that idiots don't use spoilers on forums/make spoilerish comments which get thumbed up, means that most people knew that Knight_Peculier died.
Most everyone watching the series regularly is at this point almost inevitably aware that the "NPC's" appearing in the main series as well as the other content are acted out by members of the Yogscast and their friends. Lewis even specifically states at one point that Fumblemore is, in fact, Duncan, a.k.a. Yogscast's Lalna/Livid Coffee, with a comment that everyone knows.
The Evil_Honeydew clones, given that they do respect Lewis despite their Axe Crazy and Mad Bomber tendencies and had no choice in existing the way they did.
Sips in the Tekkit series. He's a psychopathic Bad Boss, however, he's apparently very lonely.
Memetic Badass: Simon is always portrayed as the most Badass of the heroes, with Peculier often being ignored and Lewis made out as a Lovable Coward. Especially in fan art, where Simon's dual wielding diamond weapons and slaughtering mobs while Lewis is in the background. Likely influenced by the camera set-up; Simon essentially has to play the stronger role, since for over a year, Lewis was the sole camera man who couldn't do many "action sequences" in the Israphel series and has to take a clean shot of Simon being a hero. But Lewis does tend to hide in the back when he sees monsters...
The delays for SOI are in part due to the original team moving on to other projects, as well as some mods no longer working with newer versions of Minecraft.
Sjin's Farm didn't reboot simply because Sjin was bored- as it was, he was rather annoyed to have lost all his progress. However, the Heartbleed patch essentially corrupted the FTB world, meaning that he had to.
Israphel crossed this either by burning down the Yogcave, or zombifying Granny_Bacon and then setting off TNT under the church where her funeral was taking place. Most of his minions cross it at some stage, to the point it seems to be an entry requirement. ** Jock_Fireblast burning down part of Barbecue Bay and the whole of Mistral City is a big example.
Skylord_Vitali murdering most of his comrades in incredibly gruesome and nightmarish ways also counts.
King_Finbar infecting most of his own settlement and turning them into zombies, even the loyal ones.
Strawfingers crossed this when it was revealed that he murdered Abel's parents. On that note, the Wizard also qualifies as he sold Strawfingers to Abel's family.
In Yoglabs, Gozencrantz and Rildenstern cross the line when they murder Simon's master clone in an effort to take over Yoglabs.
As of the "Block Gun Mod" episode of Yoglabs, Lewis crosses the line from Simon's perspective when he orders him to destroy a village full of real, innocent Testificates (that for once weren't part of a simulation), causing him to rebel and Mercy Kill most of the commandos (when he was trying to free them), destroy equipment and get himself killed in the process. However, due to the cloning system he doesn't remember this.
It's hard to take maps such as Calmere Nightmare seriously when Simon and Lewis keep laughing over mis-spellings in the notes and Simon's "creepy" over the top Grizwald voice. Taken Up to Eleven in "The Infected", which has very bad level design and an Anticlimax Boss.
Episode 38: They find the bloody remains of Enoch after reading a series of increasingly scary notes. Simon is so disgusted he "barfs" out a ton of porkchops...and then Lewis starts complaining about Simon having more porkchops than him. And then they pick up the guy's remains, including his arms and legs and start hitting each other with them. And then there's the whole fiasco with the minecart...which leads to a Mood WhiplashDowner Ending.
Some of the more dire situations (mobs rushing them en masse) are made slightly less creepy by the slightly hammy reactions of the crew.
Paranoia Fuel: So, who actually built those Stonehenges and that pyramid trial when Simon and Lewis weren't looking?
Their feeling about the adventure map "The Swarm".
It's taken Up to Eleven in "The Infected", in which the grammar is even worse and the climax is just laughable.
Win Back the Crowd: It's generally agreed by many that the new Cornerstone series, which introduces mass collaboration and everyone working together and tasks being delegated out, is a good series, partly due to it stirring up old memories of the Tekkit series, where collabs were frequent enough.
In the Tekkit series, Duncan decides to force Rythian to give up his plans of revenge by planting three nukes protected by a forcefield underneath Rythians castle. A perfect plan, considering that nothing can breach a forcefield... except for the various magical weapons that Rythian carries around.
Later, Duncan traps Rythian in a forcefield powered by a solar panel...which is located inside the forcefield. Rythian simply uses some spare dirt to block it to free himself.
Duncan isn't exactly known for his brilliant tactical planning. At one point, he builds a fully-functioning railgun that fires TNT, capable of adjusting its range and firing direction to eliminate any target he aims it towards... so long as the enemy has the courtesy to attack the front of the castle, where the railgun is actually installed. Any flank attacks, and he's screwed.
Sjin and a red matter bomb in Voltz, just for the purposes of mining copper.
Sjin and Sips also did not learn their lesson because they immediately followed right after the red matter explosion, and are in the process of building another red matter bomb.
"That's a very nice X you have there" didn't actually come from them, but rather from somebody else. Nevertheless, it's been adopted by the fandom as one of their personal favourite memes.
Similarly, "HONEYDEWYEAYEA" is a parody of a parody of a real song, but there's no link to either the original parody or the song it was based off. Mercifully, Google helped with this a bit.
Overlapping with the Yogscast as a whole, Sjin's saying "What an asshole" in a whiny voice is not his idea. It's taken from an infamous episode (#59, to be exact) of a Polaris podcast once known as The Gaming Station, now simply known as the Co-Optional Podcast.
Old/Knight_Peculier may just be the poster boy for this trope. Especially so in Episode 35... Man, oh man...
Isabel might also count.
Prof_Webley, who was held captive in a cloning facility for months and was barely alive when the duo rescued him. He also gets hurt by a creeper. In episode 41, his shelter is blown up twice, forcing him to retreat into the robot head—his prison—for safety.
Sjin in the Tekkit series. He is constantly harassed by Sips, his employer, and then he is eventually fired from the group by Sips in favour of Lewis. He then begs for a job at Honeydew Industries, during which he is beaten, insulted, and fired on his first day at work.
Lewis gets a lot of crap around the same time too. Simon eventually goes mad with power and starting kicking him around, ruining his work efforts and eventually causing him to quit Honeydew Industries. He only applied for a part time job at Sips Co because it was the only feasible action left; getting Sjin fired and becoming his replacement was entirely accidental.
The world seems to be out to screw Zoey as much as possible in Rythian's series. Thus far, she had been separated from Rythian for quite a while under unfortunate terms, was continually humiliated by a king of a race she adores, had temporarily been effectively backstabbed by Teep, and, to top it all off, almost died from a nuke she was confident she could defuse. Despite this, she remains quiteoptimistic.
Abel only appears for a few minutes as a Posthumous Character (seemingly) but easily qualifies for this. He grew up on a farm where he had no way to escape the boredom or poverty his family endured because he wanted to make sure they'd survive. Then the Wizard (not Fumblemore) sells him Strawfingers, and as a result his parents are murdered by the time he returns home.