YMMV / Tosca


  • Adaptation Displacement: Puccini's opera has displaced the play (by Victorien Sardou) that it was based on.
  • Alternative Character Interpretation: When Tosca appears in act 3 claiming that Cavaradossi's been pardoned, does he believe her or not?
    • The Sacristan can be portrayed as either a malicious and cowardly informer or a kindly if strict priest (in some productions he is visibly shielding the chorus boys so that Scarpia's anger would only fall on him).
  • Complete Monster: Baron Vitellio Scarpia is the head of the police who relentlessly hunts down those deemed as "traitors" and subjects them to torture and execution. When he captures the painter Mario Cavaradossi, he decides to use the man as leverage to possess his sweetheart Floria Tosca. He has Mario brutally tortured, and convinces Mario that Tosca betrayed him to drive a wedge between the lovers. He then proceeds to offer Tosca Mario's safety if she sleeps with him, horrifying her. He promises to spare Mario if she does so, seemingly arranging a fake execution. However, even after Scarpia's death it is revealed he had no intention of honoring his word: the execution is real and Mario dies anyways. A venal hypocrite hiding behind his sanctimony, Scarpia glories in the fear he spreads over Rome and believes the best way to possess a woman is by force.
  • Crowning Music of Awesome: the whole opera, especially the last ten minutes.
  • Evil Is Sexy: Many portrayals of Scarpia.
  • Foe Yay: Happens sometimes between Tosca and Scarpia, especially if the latter is a tall, handsome Badass Baritone. In fact, Maria Callas, one of the most famous Toscas, talked about how her character is attracted to Scarpia despite herself.
    • Franco Zefirelli came to the same conclusion, as shown in his 1985 interview concerning the MET Tosca.
  • What an Idiot: This being an opera, logic sometimes slips away from the characters.
    • Cavaradossi hasn't said anything in the torture room but when he's brought back, he gets cocky after hearing news of Napoleon's victory and sings something like: "Down with the tyrants!" right into Scarpia's face. Nice job, Mario, now Scarpia has all evidence he needs to have you executed for treason!
    • Villains Never Lie. In the first act Scarpia shows Tosca the Marchesa's fan, and she immediately jumps to the conclusion that Cavaradossi's cheating on her. Of course, she's not yet aware of Scarpia's full intentions regarding her, but really, she trusts the feared police chief more than her lover! Especially strange since in most productions Scarpia is obviously drooling at the sight of her already, and still it doesn't occur to her for a moment he might be using her to set a trap.
    • It's understandable that Tosca REALLY doesn't want to sleep with Scarpia, but her stabbing him doesn't help the situation in the slightest. If Scarpia had kept his word and Cavaradossi was spared, how far do you want to bet they'd get before Tosca was hunted down for murder?
    • Scarpia also qualifies. Blackmail and rape are always solid motives for murder (a fact which Scarpia, the chief of police should be aware of), and he combines them in one neat package, painting a nice solid target on his own back. He might also have realized that if he does want to go through with his plan he should at least make sure there are no potential weapons around for Tosca to grab. Like sharp dinner knives.


http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/YMMV/Tosca