troperville

tools

toys


main index

Narrative

Genre

Media

Topical Tropes

Other Categories

TV Tropes Org
random
YMMV: Tintin

Books

  • Animation Age Ghetto:
    • These books are often placed in the children's section in the library, and Nick Jr used to air the Tintin cartoons (which were clearly intended for children). Granted; this is a very mild example seeing as the books are probably "PG" rated at most, a rarity given their original target audience. However, this is a bit more of an instance where it's not "Too violent", "too gory", or "Too sexy" for children, as it is "Too complex" for children. Several of the books (Namely the first few and the last one) are actually political satire, something most kids actually wouldn't really understand. However, children could still enjoy many of them for the adventures, later (mis)interpreting the political satire and history nods as a Parental Bonus.
    • However, Tintin and the Congo and Tintin in the Land of the Soviets were almost never stocked period, and when bookstores did carry them, they most definitely didn't place them in the kids' section. Some didn't think they were missing much from the Congo at least.
  • Badass Decay: General Alcazar could fit in this category. He seems pretty badass until you learn who wears the brightly colored pants in his marriage.
  • Broken Base: Is The Castafiore Emerald an entertaining diversion, a deliberately silly chamber piece that trades in the high stakes and tension of the rest of the series for humor and character work? Or is it a pointless exercise in wheel-spinning, a waste of the heroes' and the readers' time? You can find both views expressed very eloquently here and here.
  • Bizarro Episode: Flight 714. With the most explicitly supernatural third act since The Shooting Star, an unprecedented comic bent to the villains, and a healthy dose of Laser-Guided Amnesia for all involved at the story's resolution, this is often considered the strangest story in the series. It's been ventured that this is meant to be more an Affectionate Parody on Hergé's own part than a tale to be taken completely seriously.
  • Fanon Discontinuity: The first book, Land of the Soviets, usually isn't counted as part of the series continuity by most fans. Tintin in the Congo is also not acknowledged by some, owing to the rather embarrassing elements of its storyline - although others grudgingly accept it as canon due to the fact that Tintin in America is actually a direct follow-up to the events of Tintin in the Congo.
  • Fashion-Victim Villain: Rastapopoulos in Flight 714 is dressed in fancy pink-shirted cowboy garb. Hergé himself said that he wanted to ridicule him and make him a "luxury cowboy" (sic).
  • Freud Was Right: Any scholarly or academic analysis of the series draws heavily on Freud and psychoanalysis in general...and will claim that just about everything is a sexual metaphor.
  • "Funny Aneurysm" Moment: Most of Tintin in the Land of the Soviets are laughably crude anti-communist propaganda, with Soviet agents planning to blow up all the capitals of Europe and red soldiers trying to drown Snowy For the Lulz. Some scenes of the oppression in Stalinist Russia, however, rings painfully true, for instance when Tintin helps a kulak hide his grain from the bolscheviks. It has been estimated that half a million kulaks were killed and 1.8 million people starved to death due to forced collectivization and confiscations of grain in the early thirties.
  • Genius Bonus:
    • Llamas are even-toed ungulates.
    • While under the influence of truth serum, jerkass billionaire Carreidas in Flight 714 goes on at tedious length about his first evil act - stealing a pear as a child. Stealing pears was also St. Augustine's (354-430) first step on the path of sin, according to his famous Confessions.
  • Germans Love David Hasselhoff/Americans Hate Tingle: Once the colonialist propaganda was excised from later editions of Tintin in the Congo, it actually became popular in parts of Francophone Africa. (Those caricatured natives? Obviously they represent that other tribe; Tribe A is often perfectly fine with mocking Tribe B, vice versa, and they're both often fine with mocking Tribe C.) However, others don't see the editing as enough.
  • Growing the Beard: After the first two books, the series picked up in terms of story quality. Cigars of the Pharaoh was the first story that attempted to be a cohesive storyline rather than just being a loose collection of set pieces based around a particular country, although Hergé himself considered the following story, The Blue Lotus to be the point where the stories really started to get good.
  • Harsher in Hindsight:
    • Tintin's hunting of an elephant and a rhinoceros in the original, black-and-white version of Tintin in the Congo, not least because of how the populations of both animals have dwindled in the years since the release of that version.
    • The plane hijacking in Flight 714 and the real life hijacking of Flight 370 are so similar it's speculated the latter was inspired by the former.
  • Hilarious in Hindsight:
    • The references to "coke" in The Red Sea Sharks. At the time it was widely used to refer to as a derivative of coal, but nowadays "coke" usually refers to either Coca-Cola or cocaine. The latter interpretation makes Haddock's shocked reaction to Tintin's question if their ship is carrying any coke look particularly hilarious.
    • In The Castafiore Emerald, Bianca Castafiore gives Haddock a violent and ill-tempered pet parrot named Iago.
    • Also in The Castafiore Emerald, Captain Haddock, a character with black scruffy hair and beard, falling down the stairs...
    • In The Blue Lotus the Japanese are depicted as being an oppressive and militaristic force of evil, while the Chinese are portrayed in a generally very positive and wholesome manner. Nowadays, most writers would likely have the two swapped around.
  • Ho Yay: Tintin and the Captain, and less obviously, Tintin and Chang from The Blue Lotus and Tintin in Tibet.
  • Inferred Holocaust: Happens at the start of the first Tintin story, Land of the Soviets, as the train that Tintin is taking to the USSR gets blown up by a bomb, and all the passengers and crew are apparently killed (except for Tintin and Snowy, who survive... just because, really).
  • Internet Backdraft: Has your heater conked out on a winter day? Praise or denounce Tintin in the Congo.
  • It Was His Sled: Everybody knows that Roberto Rastapopoulos is little more than a movie director...
  • Not So Crazy Anymore: In "Destination Moon", Captain Haddock spends a lot of time mocking Professor Calculus for saying that travel to the moon is possible. When the book was published, in 1953, this was understandable, but after 1969, HADDOCK seems like the crazy one...
  • Memetic Mutation: "HA HA HA, OH WOW"
    • "Caramba! Encore raté!" from Broken Ear, whenever a plan fails or a target is missed.
    • The catchphrase "Je dirais même plus..." (To be precise...).
  • The Scrappy: Jolyon Wagg is considered annoying by both the in-universe characters and the readers.
  • Seinfeld Is Unfunny: Young readers who have seen many adventure comics/cartoons find Tintin to be cliché.
  • Shipping: In the draft of Alph-Art that Hergé left incomplete upon his death, Tintin investigates the murder of an art expert and initially accuses the victim's assistant, Martine Vandezande, of being in league with the killers. In Yves Rodier's unauthorized ending, Martine invites Tintin to meet her parents over dinner. Fortunately for the sanity of Tintin fans everywhere, Rodier didn't show whether Tintin accepted or rejected the invitation.
  • Values Dissonance and Unfortunate Implications:
    • Usually trying to be averted, but if there is some, it is there BIG TIME. For instance, Tintin in the Congo. Where he does everything dissonant known to 21st century man: Blowing up a rhino by drilling dynamite holes into it, shooting an ape to use his skin as camouflage, all the way down to teaching native children imperialist Belgian ideology. Fabulous, eh?
    • Or portraying Japanese as many a big-toothed Jerkass in The Blue Lotus.
      • Note that The Blue Lotus came out during the Japanese invasion and occupation of China. As such, that unflattering depiction is a scathing indictment of Japanese imperialism of the times and no different from similar depictions of Nazi Germany. For comparison, in the The Crab with the Golden Claws, there is a sympathetic Japanese character, who appears in the very beginning and the very end, who is not caricatured and is not a Jerk Ass of any sort.
    • Or about everything in Tintin in the Land of the Soviets.
    • Or in The Shooting Star (published during WWII, when Belgium was occupied by Germany), where Tintin's expedition's nemesis is a certain American industrialist called Blumenstein. In the later versions, the country was renamed Sao Rico and Blumenstein was renamed Bohlwinkel (which actually doesn't make it any better).
    • Or (apparently) Tintin landing in the British Mandate of Palestine in Land of Black Gold, as it was replaced with a Qurac-esque nation in later editions.
    • Or when the world was allegedly going to end, and two stereotypical Jews are seen talking about it, one of them saying that would spare him paying a debt to another Jew.
  • Villain Decay: Rastapopoulos to a tee. In his earlier appearances, he is a powerful, deceptive and menacing chessmaster. Flight 714 sees him reduced to a pathetically short-tempered pink cowboy who can't think even one step ahead (he's still pretty evil though, as he is quick to tell us). His dragon Allan falls prey to this too, becoming nothing more than a dumb and cowardly henchman. Note that this was done on purpose; Hergé deliberately decided to ridicule his villains at this point.
  • The Woobie: Has its own page.

Nelvana animated series

  • Badass Decay: Emir Ben Kalish Ezab suffered from this in the Nelvana series. The comic version of the Emir did sometimes get emotional about things regarding his son, but was otherwise a guy who you definitely wouldn't want to mess with. The animated version on the other hand was such a simpering crybaby that it was frankly amazing that Bab El Ehr hadn't managed to overthrow him already.
  • Crowning Music of Awesome: The main theme.
  • Brazilians Love Tintin

Film

  • Americans Hate Tintin/Everybody Else Loves Tintin: Can be viewed either way depending on how you look at it. As a European comic book, the film can be interpreted as a case of Americans Hate Tingle, as the box office in North America left a lot to be desired. As an American adaptation of a European comic book, on the other hand, the film can be interpreted as a case of Germans Love David Hasselhoff, since most of the film's gross came from overseas.
  • Animation Age Ghetto: The movie had outcries over it being "too violent for children".
    • In the artbook, Jamie Bell (who plays Tintin) actually praised the cartoon for talking about more mature subject matter and getting him into the series in the first place.
  • Award Snub: The Oscars ceremony that year included a rare five nominees for Best Animated Feature, but none of them include this movie.
  • Crazy Awesome: Climbing out of a plane to refuel it without it landing by belching alcohol fumes into it? A pirate ship getting its mast tangled with that of the Unicorn and getting lifted straight out of the water and over the deck of the Unicorn as pirates leap off of it? A single-shot chase scene during which a tank pushes a hotel to the side of a beach, Captain Haddock ends up in a dress and Tintin's motorcycle turns into a unicycle balanced on a clothesline (and all this just to catch a single bird!)? Swordfighting with loading cranes? Yep. It can be safely said that this film pretty much runs on Crazy Awesome, considering all the batshit insane stunts the main characters pull, and most importantly the fact that said batshit insane stunts actually work.
  • Crowning Music of Awesome: From the trailers, there's Sands Of Time and Sword of Omens by Audiomachine. From the soundtrack itself, there are many - the soundtrack emphasizes themes and motifs that run throughout the entire score, making the whole thing even more awesome when listened to as a set. Individually, there's "Sir Francis and the Unicorn," "Red Rackham's Curse and the Treasure," and "The Pursuit of the Falcon."
  • Evil Is Sexy: Sakharine as he's voiced by Daniel Craig.
  • Ho Yay: When Tintin trusts the Captain with their piece of the poem, the scene could be interpreted as nothing less than "You can't trust me with that!" "I'm sure I can. Just take it, and make me the happiest boy in Bagghar!"
  • One-Scene Wonder: Bianca Castafiore.
  • They Changed It, Now It Sucks: This pretty much defines the reaction of the hardcore fans who got upset over the modifications of the books' storylines.
  • Tough Act to Follow: John Williams' orchestral score, while excellent, gets flak from fans of older works, particularly the Nelvana series - whose main theme is particularly iconic. Also overlaps with They Changed It, Now It Sucks.
  • Uncanny Valley: Mostly averted, but Tintin looks off in some scenes and Snowy's fur doesn't move like it should.
  • What an Idiot: Played for Laughs. Thomson and Thompson don't realize that Aristides Silk is the pickpocket, even when they're inside his apartment surrounded by his wallet collection. (This is in contrast to the comic, where after Tintin clues them in on the cleaner's mark sewn into the pickpocket's coat, the detectives track down Silk using good old-fashioned legwork.)

Other adaptations


random
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy
30101
23