YMMV / The Thing (1982)

  • Adaptation Displacement: Not many are likely to have read John W. Campbell's original story and thanks to the Even Better Sequel reactions the film gets, The Thing from Another World, while not totally displaced, is not as prominent as Carpenter's film.
  • Alternative Character Interpretation:
    • Some interpret the Norwegians killed at the beginning as brave men killed by idiots, especially those familiar with Norwegian. However, this also ignores that the violent behavior of the men would be enough to frighten the Americans and even if they did understand, it would be very hard to believe a dog was an alien in disguise considering its behavior at that point.
    • The movie is ripe with this after watching, as you know who has been assimilated, but not always when they were. For example, did Blair destroy all that equipment in a desperate attempt to keep the Thing contained, or had he already been assimilated and was out to prevent the others calling for help? Also, Norris turning down taking a leadership role. Was it because of his heart condition as initially implied, or was he already a Thing at this point and knew being leader would inevitably focus a lot of unwanted attention/suspicion on himself?
    • The Thing itself is heavily subjected to this since we aren't told anything about where it came from or what its motivation is. See the WMG page for more, but put simply, one could interpret it as being malevolent, or simply acting in self-preservation, or it's a life form seeking to spread its species.
    • Forms the basis for this short story.
  • Awesome Music: The original score by Ennio Morricone. It may be shocking to learn that it actually got nominated for a RAZZIE, though like the rest of the film, it was originally slated by critics (who accused Morricone of being lazy and just copying John Carpenter's score for Halloween), and has been Vindicated by History. Equal credit goes to Carpenter as well, for he provided the uncredited electronic part of the score, including the "heartbeat" cue.
  • Broken Base: As evidenced by many of the sticky posts on the Outpost 31 forums dedicated to the movie. The lack of solid information on the Things and other unanswered questions have led to some rifts amongst the fandom. Some have 2 main points of contention. Others have hardly anyone at all agreeing with anyone else's ideas.
  • Creepy Awesome: With emphasis on the creepy, The Thing is a remarkable creature with nightmarish transformations and surprising intelligence that makes it quite memorable.
  • Critical Research Failure:
    • MacReady proclaims that winter has just begun in the opening scene. Yet the sun is shining brightly.note 
    • In a lesser-known example, the UN agreed that no weapons should be used in Antarctica (as pointed out by Linkara) — that means no guns or flamethrowers.
  • Even Better Sequel: Carpenter's The Thing is often regarded as one of the greatest remakes ever made, with many even feeling it surpasses the original.
  • Germans Love David Hasselhoff: The movie initially didn't do so well in the U.S., but, according to Guillermo del Toro, it was very successful in Mexico.
  • Harsher in Hindsight: Though not commonly known at the time, it's since become a serious concern in the scientific community that thawing polar icecaps could unleash hellish diseases.
  • Hell Is That Noise: The Thing is an undisputed master of this. It doesn't speak in the Voice of the Legion, it screams with it.
    • A particularly eerie example is when the Dog-Thing goes into the kennel, where it makes an unearthly sounding hiss as it sits still before transforming and emitting an unsettling buzzing noise. Also doubles as Uncanny Valley with the Vocal Dissonance.
    • The scream unleashed by the Bennings-Thing when the group corners and incinerates it. This one is prominent enough in its scare factor that IMDB lists it as a content warning for its rating advisory for the film.
    • The howling and moaning that Norris-Thing creates when it's head erupts and it gets incinerated.
  • Hilarious in Hindsight:
  • Idiot Plot: Defied. Normally, in a monster film, the monster is so successful because the cast makes stupid mistakes. After the first human victim, they figure out more or less what it's capable of, and go out of their way to burn not just the bodies of its two known incarnations of the creature, but all of its targets. It still isn't enough...
    • And because nobody trusts anybody, everybody is wary of taking some decisions. What's worse is that the The Thing can influence a group into making decisions it wants. It comes dangerously close to the group killing MacReady after planting very good evidence.
  • Jerkass Woobie: Most of the characters, as while they may be arguing and trying to kill each other, considering they are trapped with the Thing taking them over, one can't blame them. Clarke in particular warrants mention, as while he comes across as rather creepy, one can't help but sympathize with his grief over his dogs being killed by The Thing and Blair.
  • Magnificent Bastard: For an alien parasite, The Thing is dangerously intelligent and is very capable at outwitting our heroes, who are not idiots themselves. Hell, it kills off most of the cast and we still don't know if it got to MacReady or Childs or what.
  • Memetic Mutation:
    • Anyone talking about the Norwegians on a forum will purposefully misidentify them as Swedish.
    • Windows' death has prompted many jokes regarding Mac Vs. PC.
  • Narm: "Maybe we at war with Norway."
  • Narm Charm: The cartoon-standard sound effects utilized a few times (such as the *goop* sound when Copper gets his arms torn off) really don't detract from the horror at all, and often work exactly as intended even when contemporary films could never hope to get away with half of them.
  • Nausea Fuel: And plenty of it.
  • Nightmare Retardant: While many incarnations of the Thing are frightening, some of'em are less scary than the others 'cause them being too grotesque or even goofy looking. For example: Norris- Thing with that fat angry face, look almost as if it's on drugs or drunken.
  • Paranoia Fuel: This film is made of it, runs on it, and will take you over with it.
  • Signature Scene: Three. The blood test scene, the attack in the dog kennel and the scene with the defibrillator.
  • Special Effects Failure:
    • While the majority of the effects have held up magnificently, it's a little sad that during the otherwise flawless blood-testing scene that when Windows is being ragdolled by the Palmer-Thing he is obviously, well... a ragdoll.
    • In the defibrillator scene, when the Thing bites Copper's arms off, his arms just sort of break off above where the Thing's teeth are sunk into them, rather than being cut through by the teeth.
    • When Palmer-thing leaps onto the ceiling, you can see a part of the tile fly off the ceiling, and then stick back up onto it. This was because that part was filmed with him on the ground, and the film was simply transposed to make it look like he was attaching himself to the ceiling.
    • Anytime tentacles sprout up, it's easy to see that they were being pulled through their props and just played back in reverse.
  • Uncanny Valley:
    • A unique example. In the kennel scene and some of its scenes in the camp before-hand, the Dog-Thing, before it transforms, it just...sits there. That doesn't sound bad at first, but it's literally motionless. No tail-wagging, no nothing. It just sits there and perplexes, making it really, really off-putting. The sound it makes before it transforms only adds to it. On a production level, the dog caused this for the cast and crew in an unintentional case of this, as the dog was part wolf and really just nervous.
    • Inevitably, some of the human transformations fall into this (which was likely intentional), with Palmer-Thing's face swelling up and the infamous Spider Head being the most unsettling.
  • Vindicated by History: A huge flop when it was released, and initially received mixed to negative reviews. Then The '90s rolled along, and people started picking it up on VHS and DVD. It's now considered to be one of the greatest horror films in history.
  • Visual Effects of Awesome: The film is packed with terrific animatronic and makeup effects which have held up magnificently.
  • What an Idiot: The Norwegian pilot at the beginning drops an active grenade and ends up obliterating himself along with his helicopter just because he decided to try digging through the deep snow for an explosive device that would detonate in mere seconds instead of running like Hell away from it. Either it was the wrong time to panic, or it's a classic case of Too Dumb to Live.
  • The Woobie:
    • Norris. Fat unassuming guy who is among the least argumentative team members and has a heart condition. He ends up getting assimilated and depending on how you interpret it, may have been infected first and was thus really an alien imitation for most of the movie.
    • Doctor Copper, who is polite to the rest and gives adamant health care. He gets tied down with Garry when The Thing plants evidence that implicates them both as potentially being assimilated. Not is he human, he suffers a cruel death when trying to revive Norris, who reveals himself as an imitation and bites his arms off, killing him. And to top it off, it turns out in the blood test scene he was human all along.
    • Gary, who is a Reasonable Authority Figure shaken by the deaths that happen around him during the film. He suffers the above situation with Norris, and while he turns out to be human, he ends up killed by Blair in a painful death when he shoves his hand into his mouth and absorbs him.
    • The sled dogs, who suffer a horrifying attack as The Thing's first on-screen victims. The two that survive end up getting killed by Blair for their trouble.


http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/YMMV/TheThing1982