- Broken Base: Some like their pony-related vidoes. Others, don't, and wish they'd concentrate more of their anime reviews.
- Hilarious in Hindsight: They both expressed disappointment that The Nostalgia Critic never reviewed Felix the Cat: The Movie. Lo and behold, a few months later, he did.
- Hype Backlash: They're one of the only reviewers to say anything negative about Rescue from Midnight Castle, because they weren't fond of Tirac being a Flat Character of a villain who acts For the Evulz.
- Love It or Hate It: reactions to their reviewing style and their commentaries can be...divided. We'll leave it at that.
- The Scrappy: After season 3 of Friendship Is Magic, they now consider Chad Rocco to be the embodiment of everything wrong with the current brony fandom, with his continuing to watch a show he hates just so he can whine about it, and stooping to personal insults about people who still like the show.
- So Bad, It's Good: How some view them. To quote one user comment on Equestria Daily:
"They are awful... no chemistry, no timing... and yet, I find this absolutely hilarious! Keep it coming!!!!"