These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
What Do You Mean, It Wasn't Made on Drugs?: In the first movie, you have evil shark gangs and magic moonbeams. The sequel takes this up to 11. There's a scene where the talking dog is riding in a seahorse-driven chariot and shooting a magical flintlock pistol at some evil sharks. It's either the most awesome thing every filmed, or the crackiest thing this side of Katamari Damacy.
Dude, Not Funny!: It's been getting this reaction because it features the the Titanic not sinking, along with everyone getting saved (yes, even the band and the Captain), which many consider an insult to those who died in the real tragedy.
However, it could be interpreted as a happier alternative where things work out for the better. Of course, it doesn't mean that the suspense wasn't there for dramatic build-up, with the possibilities of Heroic Sacrifice and Redemption Equals Death, as the film made sure that the viewers though everyone (or at least certain notable characters) were going to bite the big one. Makes some viewers happy and quite relieved that everyone lives in the end.
Ho Yay: The two young male mice, Connors and Ronnie, are quite touchy-feely throughout the film. Makes more sense than when Connors ended up with the chick he shared A line with.
Unfortunate Implications: Denying that the Titanic was terrible accident in which anyone died just for a trite anti-whaling screed. It's enough to make you wonder if the people behind the film were even aware that Cameron's film was based on a real event where hundreds senselessly died.
The fact that the "Prince" constantly sniffs the heroine's glove can be very creepy.
Angst? What Angst?: Our heroes seem to care very little about the fact that they're stuck in Atlantis forever, even though on the surface Don Juan has his gypsy brothers, Elizabeth has her father, Connors has a wife, and Ronnie has a sister and family.
Fridge Horror: Where did Razor-Tooth get that captain's uniform he wears?
"Funny Aneurysm" Moment: "This liquid looks pretty! Let's drink it.". The said liquid is colored green. In these days, one of the more well-known drug detectors will turn the drink green when it discovers a date rape drug.
If something bad happens to my friends, I'll rip every tooth out of that shark and I'll make them into the most beautiful necklace you've ever seen!
Nightmare Fuel: The scene at the end, when the escaped rats are all seen in an insane asylum. Especially the nurse giggling madly while the doctor talks about how there's no hope of them recovering and makes a horrifying face. The protagonists all laugh when they see this.