YMMV / The Gallagher Girls

  • Even Better Sequel: according to a poll on the Gallagher Girl wiki (taken when there were only five books), the fifth book is by far the voters' favorite book. The second one is the runner-up, followed by the fourth and third. The first book is the voters' least favorite.
  • Les Yay: Cammie really likes to point out how hot her roommates are.
    "She (Macey) was running toward me. So strong. So fast. So beautiful."
  • Nightmare Fuel: Cammie gets brainwashed and forgets an entire summer. Later, the same person hypnotises her and orders her to kill herself. If she hadn't been stopped, she would have done it.
    • In the sixth book: the song that Zach remembers his mother singing to him when he was a child. Hearing Catherine sing the song herself after she's captured is rather chilling.
    Above the plains up on the hill there stood a castle bold. A gleaming palace made of white, a pillar to behold. The horsemen lived in service to the castle and the crown. But the knights rose up and killed the kings. And it all burned down.
    • The Circle of Cavan's master plan: Liz's hypothetical plan to start World War Three. Poor Liz is horrified when she finds out that they're actually using it.
  • Tear Jerker:
    Cam: "Do you hear the music, Mom?"
    Mom, holding back tears: "No."
    Cam: "Me neither."