YMMV / The Dark Tower

The Dark Tower novels:

  • Alternate Character Interpretation: The Filk Song "Terror Train" by Demons & Wizards portrays Blaine as a pathetic Psychopathic Manchild with an Inferiority Superiority Complex, who is still a legitimate threat. The chorus: "No one really knows the pain I'm going through (My final ride is almost done!) / The world has moved on, now it's time to go (My final ride is almost done!) / Come lift my spirit up, I'm BLAINE!". Aww, he's lonely! But he's also batshit insane and suicidal, and misery loves company...
  • Anti-Climax Boss: Just about every important villain gets defeated in a Curb-Stomp Battle, no matter how much they're built up as a threat:
    • It's made to look like the Tick Tock Man will be the first villain to present an actual phsyical threat to the gunslingers, being a mucle-bound badass who might actually be faster than Roland himself. Nope, he's defeated by Jake once, then brought back just to get unceremoniously gunned down a second time without ever putting up a fight.
    • Randall Flagg gets killed by Mordred without putting up any significant resistance. There's even a momentary fake-out where it looks like Flagg might have gained a small advantage, but the narration negates it in the very next sentence.
    • In spite of getting an entire book to herald his introduction and possessing mind-control powers, Mordred doesn't do much after he's set free. For a long time he just follows behind Roland's crew, starving and freezing. By the time he finally attacks, he's dying from poisoned meat and does nothing but charge at Roland. Although he does manage to kill Oy, he's killed by a few well-placed bullets, just like any other mook.
    • The Crimson King is some sort of immortal demi-god whose presence is felt through most of the series. By the time we see him, he's just a crazy old man with nothing in his arsenal but sneetches, which we've seen used several times before and present almost no threat to a gunslinger. He's defeated by Patrick.
  • Broken Base: Several.
    • The ending, where the Crimson King, the main villain, turns out to be just an angry old man with some clever technology and the result of the main characters saving Stephen King is that he writes a boy with magic powers into the story so that that boy can defeat the Crimson King, is extremely controversial. Some fans think it fits in perfectly, others think it ruined the whole series.
    • The publication of The Wind Through the Keyhole: was King just cashing in/flogging a dead horse/attaching an unrelated fantasy novel to the Dark Tower brand to ensure it would sell? Or was it as on-point as the series' other flashback novel Wizard and Glass, and patched up a small Offscreen Teleportation plot hole between the former book and Wolves of the Calla to boot? Or, to Take a Third Option, was it a perfectly fine King novel in the vein of The Eyes of the Dragon that just didn't need to be so heavily interwoven with the DT series to work?
  • The Chris Carter Effect: King mentioned early on in the afterward to The Gunslinger that he had no idea where the series was going. By the end of the series, it gets to the point where numerous plot points are ignored, contradicted or handwaved as Canon Discontinuity.
  • Complete Monster: It is revealed that Randall Flagg has lived for so long and accumulated so much power that he has become the emissary for the Crimson King. Flagg earns Roland Deschain's undying hatred for beating and sleeping with Rolandís mother, and for aiding the revolutionary, John Farson, in causing the destruction of the city of Gilead. Flagg also forces Roland to let his preteen companion, Jake Chambers, die, and drives a girl insane by telling her the trigger phrase which causes a formerly dead man to recount the afterlife to her. Corruptive, treacherous and sadistic, Flagg's ultimate goal was to betray his master and climb to the top of the Dark Tower in order to become God of all.
  • Creator's Pet: Susannah is easily the most disliked character of the Ka-Tet, largely due to her annoying split personalities. She's also the only one other than Roland who gets an entire book dedicated to her, and the only one that gets an (arguably) happy ending.
  • Ending Fatigue: The series ends, then gets an epilogue for Susannah's ending, then gets a Coda for the actual ending. There's also an afterword.
  • Esoteric Happy Ending: Susannah goes into an alternate reality version of New York where Eddie and Jake are still alive and in fact are brothers. She appears in Central Park at Christmas time, alternate-Eddie greets her with a cup of hot chocolate, and it's clearly supposed to be her happy ending... except many readers feel that Susannah abandoned the quest and is now trapped in a world that isn't her own with a couple of Replacement Goldfish who aren't really the people she loved.
  • Everyone Is Jesus in Purgatory: Mocked in The Wastelands.
  • Foe Yay: At the very least, The Gunslinger has a bit of suggestive subtext between Roland and The Man in Black towards the final chapter.
  • Magnificent Bastard: The Man In Black, Marten, Randall Flagg, and Walter. Why, you ask? Because they are the same person.
  • Nightmare Fuel:
    • The Tunnel Demon in The Dark Tower. A giant albino worm chasing after Roland and Susannah through the tunnels between Fedic and the Badlands for God knows how long. They only survive because it is sensitive to light, but their Sterno (artificial fire) gets notably less and less in time. The light at the end of the tunnel comes as a great relief to both Roland and Susannah and the readers.
    • The Charlie the Choo Choo book is an in-universe example; King definitely intends for his own readers to find it creepy.
    • Mordred's birth
  • Replacement Scrappy: After being King's ubervillain since the 70s, King thought it was a good idea to replace Randall Flagg with the newly-introduced Mordred as Roland's main antagonist for the last book.
  • Squick: Rhea examining Susan in Wizard and Glass. In fact, Rhea in general.
  • Surprisingly Improved Sequel: The Drawing of the Three, according to Stephen King. King even went back and republished The Gunslinger with some changes to bring it more in line with the rest of the series.
  • Villain Decay: In the final book, Walter o'Dim/Randall Flagg and the Crimson King, the two main villains up until that point, are reduced to almost non-entities. In particular Flagg, who had once been considered King's 'ubervillain', is easily dispatched in one chapter by a newly introduced character, who finds him pathetic. This is especially troublesome to some fans, since Flagg has been especially troublesome to numerous Stephen King characters over the years, even surviving (or, more accurately, respawning after) a nuclear blast. Having Mordred kill him is obviously to establish Mordred as even more sinister and dangerous than Flagg, but that's a bit hard, if not impossible, after developing the Flagg character for decades and across numerous books. Made worse by the fact that Roland kills him with a single shot.

The Dark Tower comic books:

  • Tear Jerker: Fall of Gilead and Battle of Jericho Hill.

The Dark Tower film:

  • Broken Base:
    • To say that the decision to cast Idris Elba to play Roland Deschain has met some controversy is a major understatement. Some fans are happy with the decision, stating that Elba is an accomplished actor in his own right and carries the correct presence to portray Roland of Gilead. Other fans claim that changing Roland's specified ethnic approximation (not quite European, as he does not hail from Europe, but he still appears Caucasian/"white") goes against the character, as he was designed to look like Clint Eastwood's "Man With No Name".
    • Also, the casting of Idris Elba as Roland in the movies has caused a major split in the fan base, between those who think that Roland has to be portrayed by a white actor in order for his antagonism with Detta to work (or who just believe that Race Lift casting shouldn't ever happen in adaptations), and those who think Elba's talent outweighs his lack of physical resemblance to Novel!Roland and that Detta's problem was always with Roland's authority as leader of the ka-tet (or even just the fact that he exists near her because, y'know, Detta) rather than his race.
    • Ironically, one side-effect of this has been that, while a portion of the fandom was gearing up to hate on Matthew McConaughey being cast as Roland (prior to his Breakout Role on True Detective, anyway), the announcement that McConaughey will be playing The Man in Black, while Elba will be playing Roland, has now got some of the same fans asking for McConaughey to be re-cast as Roland instead. Some are even calling for their roles to be switched, though more seem to want to avoid the suggestion due to its Unfortunate Implications.

http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/YMMV/TheDarkTower