YMMV: Team StarKid

  • Actor Shipping: Julia Albain was thought by fans for a while to be dating or used to date Darren Criss. Turns out they're Just Friends.
    • Darren Criss and Chris Colfer Slash Fic is popular probably due to their roles on "Glee"
    • A few of the other actors have gotten this treatment due to the amounts of Ho Yay amoung the group even in real life.
    • Breredith (Brian Holden x Meredith Stepien) is also very popular.
  • Broken Base:
    • After Bonnie 'left' the team, she unfollowed all the other members on Twitter and posted a few conservative viewpoints. This has caused many fans to call her out on it and say she 'isn't a true Starkid anymore.' There are still many fans who respect her choices though, and even some who were angered when Meredith Stepien replaced her in the reading of "A Very Potter Senior Year".
    • There are disputes on whether or not StarKid members who appeared in StarKid musicals outside of college are still considered StarKids, however the consensus seems to be yes.
    • Some fans haven't forgiven Darren Criss for "selling out" by joining the cast of Glee.
  • Crowning Moment of Funny: Let's just say their strong point is humor.
  • Crowning Music of Awesome: Several of their songs are regarded as this.
  • Ear Worm: Most of their music counts.
  • Hollywood Homely: Several of their female characters.
  • Hollywood Pudgy: Joey Richter
  • Ho Yay: In both the shows and the Announcement Videos.
  • The Woobie: Jaime Lyn Beatty has this down to an art form.