YMMV / Team StarKid

  • Actor Shipping:
    • Julia Albain was thought by fans for a while to be dating or used to date Darren Criss. Turns out they're Just Friends.
    • Darren Criss and Chris Colfer Slash Fic is popular due to their roles on Glee.
    • A few of the other actors have gotten this treatment due to the amounts of Ho Yay amoung the group even in real life.
    • Breredith (Brian Holden x Meredith Stepien) is also very popular.
  • Broken Base:
    • After Bonnie "left" the team, she unfollowed all the other members on Twitter and posted a few conservative viewpoints. This has caused many fans to call her out on it and say she "isn't a true Starkid anymore." There are still many fans who respect her choices though, and even some who were angered when Meredith Stepien replaced her in the reading of A Very Potter Senior Year.
    • There are disputes on whether or not StarKid members who appeared in StarKid musicals outside of college are still considered StarKids, however the consensus seems to be yes.
    • Some fans haven't forgiven Darren Criss for "selling out" by joining the cast of Glee.
  • Crowning Moment of Funny: Let's just say their strong point is humor.
  • Crowning Music of Awesome: Several of their songs are regarded as this.
  • Ear Worm: Most of their music counts.
  • Hollywood Homely: Several of their female characters.
  • Hollywood Pudgy: Joey Richter
  • Ho Yay: In both the shows and the Announcement Videos.
  • The Woobie: Jaime Lyn Beatty has this down to an art form.