- Broken Base: The Incredible Machine is proving to be a very divisive album. Critics and fans alike are pretty much split between saying that the album's awesome or horrible, with very few in-betweens. Most of the haters dislike the more pop-oriented sound and lightweight lyrics.
- Ear Worm: Good luck getting "All I Want to Do" or "Stuck Like Glue" out of your head. Especially the former.
- 8.8: The 9513, a country music blog, gave Love on the Inside two-and-a-half stars, with the review criticizing it for sounding too homogenous. Keep in mind that this is the album that generally got praise for its musical variety. (The same blog also gave a "thumbs down" to three of the four singles.)