Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / StandStillStaySilent

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misplaced, moving to the correct tab

Added DiffLines:

* IKnewIt:
** Writing [[MuggleMageRomance romance fics between mages and non-mages]] resulted in fans speculating about non-mages having their own safe areas in the dreamscape long before it got confirmed in Chapter 17.
** At least one commenter called Lalli's stay in Emil's dreamscape safe area resulting in SharingABody with him.
** And another correctly guessed that the ghosts [[spoiler:are the spirits of those treated with the failed 'cure']].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
sad


* FanworkOnlyFans: ''City of Hunger'' already has a few fanfics despite being still in production and having had almost nothing of its plot revealed.

to:

* FanworkOnlyFans: ''City of Hunger'' already has a few fanfics despite being still in production cancelled and having had almost nothing of its plot revealed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Renamed trope per Wick Cleaning Projects


--> So judging from the comments yesterday a lot of people were a bit bewildered and/or dismayed by Lalli's reaction last page. An here's the shocking explanation for his behaviour: yes, Lalli is very socially and emotionally maldeveloped, and spending a week with a bunch of strangers [[SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome really isn't enough to fix whatever an extremely unconventional upbringing]] ([[AmbiguousDisorder and perhaps some underlying neural issues]]) [[SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome has shaped. In fact it is only going to force those problems to the surface.]] So if you're hoping for Lalli to just "grow up" as soon as possible I'll have to deliver the tragic news that it might be a lengthy journey towards that.

to:

--> So judging from the comments yesterday a lot of people were a bit bewildered and/or dismayed by Lalli's reaction last page. An here's the shocking explanation for his behaviour: yes, Lalli is very socially and emotionally maldeveloped, and spending a week with a bunch of strangers [[SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome really isn't enough to fix whatever an extremely unconventional upbringing]] ([[AmbiguousDisorder and (and perhaps some underlying neural issues]]) issues) [[SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome has shaped. In fact it is only going to force those problems to the surface.]] So if you're hoping for Lalli to just "grow up" as soon as possible I'll have to deliver the tragic news that it might be a lengthy journey towards that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** InUniverse, Omni can seem excessively hostile and paranoid in his behaviour towards the old pastor spirit when they [[http://www.sssscomic.com/comic.php?page=566 meet in the dreamworld]]. Adventure 2, however, shows us [[TheCorruptor exactly what he was scared of]], and as such [[ProperlyParanoid his suspicion was entirely justified]].

to:

** InUniverse, Omni can seem excessively hostile and paranoid in his behaviour towards the old pastor spirit when they [[http://www.sssscomic.com/comic.php?page=566 meet in the dreamworld]]. Adventure 2, II, however, shows us [[TheCorruptor exactly what he was scared of]], and as such [[ProperlyParanoid his suspicion was entirely justified]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** InUniverse, Omni can seem excessively hostile and paranoid in his behaviour towards the old pastor spirit when they [[http://www.sssscomic.com/comic.php?page=566 meet in the dreamworld]]. Adventure 2, however, shows us [[TheCorruptor exactly what he was scared of]], and as such [[ProperlyParanoid his suspicion was entirely justified]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Kind of needed context.


* NauseaFuel: The makes writhing maggots spontaneously generate on people's arms to intimidate them. When they are first seen, it's easy to mistake the person for starting to mutate into a troll.

to:

* NauseaFuel: The Kade makes writhing maggots spontaneously generate on people's arms to intimidate them. When they are first seen, it's easy to mistake the person for starting to mutate into a troll.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Kind of needed context.


** A lady who asks for help gets punched right in the kisser. It's both tragic and morbidly funny.

to:

** A ([[UndeadAbomination former]]) lady who asks for help gets punched right in the kisser. It's both tragic and morbidly funny.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And, with the comic concluding at the end of Adventure II, there's [[LeftHanging more than a few plot hooks]] for potential ContinuationFic writers to work off of.

to:

** And, with the comic concluding at the end of Adventure II, there's [[LeftHanging more than a few plot hooks]] for potential ContinuationFic writers to work off of.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And, with the comic concluding at the end of Adventure II, there's [[LeftHanging more than a few plot hooks]] for potential ContinuationFic writers to work off of.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CryForTheDevil: It doesn't take long for readers to join the cast in feeling very, very sorry for beasts, trolls, giants and murderghosts, despite their baseline antagonistic behaviour. Even the most enthusiastically murder-minded of them are in various states of horrible pain.

to:

* CryForTheDevil: It doesn't take long for readers to join the cast in feeling very, very sorry for beasts, trolls, giants and murderghosts, despite their baseline antagonistic behaviour. Even the most enthusiastically murder-minded of them are in various states [[TorturedMonster various]] [[AndIMustScream states]] of horrible pain.

Added: 1000

Changed: 498

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HarsherInHindsight: The comic was launched in late 2013, a few months before the European Migrant Crisis began in earnest. The general premise of the prologue, a disease carried by refugees entering southern Europe causing the collapse of Western civilization and that the only way European countries could protect themselves was to close their borders and sink refugee boats, eerily mirrors the rhetoric used by far-right parties and politicians that came to power on platforms of xenophobia and cultural nationalism.

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: HarsherInHindsight:
**
The comic was launched in late 2013, a few months before the European Migrant Crisis began in earnest. The general premise of the prologue, a disease carried by refugees entering southern Europe causing the collapse of Western civilization and that the only way European countries could protect themselves was to close their borders and sink refugee boats, eerily mirrors the rhetoric used by far-right parties and politicians that came to power on platforms of xenophobia and cultural nationalism.nationalism.
** The arguments raised around restricting travel in the face of the spreading Rash Illness (during the talk show scene of the Denmark prologue) become this as well thanks to the UsefulNotes/Covid19Pandemic, with one side arguing that taking drastic acton (Iceland closing its borders entirely) against an unknown illness is clearly rational, and the other highlighting such a decision's impact is a violation of individual rights -- a debate that has permeated discussions of the response to Covid.

Changed: 1881

Removed: 275

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation:
** Reynir's parents being AbusiveParents. At face value, it's easy to read them as having an extreme but justified case of AngerBornOfWorry. However, some aspects of Reynir's interactions with them can ring alarm bells for people who had emotionally abusive parents:
*** The little characterization they get during Adventure I establishes that they lied to Reynir about the extent to which he was allowed to travel internationally to keep him home, even after he had reached adulthood.
*** The phrasing they use to scold Reynir for running off, such as his mother saying "If you loved me you would never have done this." and his father saying "How could you do this to your mother?" and "...my very unintelligent son.". It can be very easily read as them assuming Reynir specifically ran off to hurt his parents, even though that was the farthest from his mind. When combined with the first point, it makes them come across as controlling, oblivious to their own part in the situation and putting all the blame for it on Reynir alongside some emotional guilt.
*** His mother has shown some definite MyBelovedSmother traits -- for instance, when she assumes he's friends with Emil and Lalli, Reynir's reaction is to go along with the assumption in front of her, then apologize to ''them'' about the assumption once she's out of earshot.

to:

* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation:
**
AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: Reynir's parents being AbusiveParents. At face value, it's easy to read them as having an extreme but justified case of AngerBornOfWorry. However, some aspects of Reynir's interactions with them can ring alarm bells for people who had emotionally abusive parents:
*** ** The little characterization they get during Adventure I establishes that they lied to Reynir about the extent to which he was allowed to travel internationally to keep him home, even after he had reached adulthood.
*** ** The phrasing they use to scold Reynir for running off, such as his mother saying "If you loved me you would never have done this." and his father saying "How could you do this to your mother?" and "...my very unintelligent son.". It can be very easily read as them assuming Reynir specifically ran off to hurt his parents, even though that was the farthest from his mind. When combined with the first point, it makes them come across as controlling, oblivious to their own part in the situation and putting all the blame for it on Reynir alongside some emotional guilt.
*** ** His mother has shown some definite MyBelovedSmother traits -- for instance, when she assumes he's friends with Emil and Lalli, Reynir's reaction is to go along with the assumption in front of her, then apologize to ''them'' about the assumption once she's out of earshot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Whoops. Missed that out.


*** His mother has shown some definite MyBelovedSmother traits -- for instance, when his mother assumes he's friends with Emil and Lalli, Reynir's reaction is to go along with the assumption in front of her, then apologize to ''them'' about the assumption once she's out of earshot.

to:

*** His mother has shown some definite MyBelovedSmother traits -- for instance, when his mother she assumes he's friends with Emil and Lalli, Reynir's reaction is to go along with the assumption in front of her, then apologize to ''them'' about the assumption once she's out of earshot.

Changed: 222

Removed: 205

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Consolidating and indenting.


** The little characterization they get during Adventure I establishes that they lied to Reynir about the extent to which he was allowed to travel internationally to keep him home, even after he had reached adulthood.
** The phrasing they use to scold Reynir for running off, such as his mother saying "If you loved me you would never have done this." and his father saying "How could you do this to your mother?" and "...my very unintelligent son.". It can be very easily read as them assuming Reynir specifically ran off to hurt his parents, even though that was the farthest from his mind. When combined with the first point, it makes them come across as controlling, oblivious to their own part in the situation and putting all the blame for it on Reynir alongside some emotional guilt.
** His mother has shown some definite MyBelovedSmother traits.
** When his mother assumes he's friends with Emil and Lalli, Reynir's reaction is to go along with the assumption in front of her, then apologize to ''them'' about the assumption once she's out of earshot.

to:

** *** The little characterization they get during Adventure I establishes that they lied to Reynir about the extent to which he was allowed to travel internationally to keep him home, even after he had reached adulthood.
** *** The phrasing they use to scold Reynir for running off, such as his mother saying "If you loved me you would never have done this." and his father saying "How could you do this to your mother?" and "...my very unintelligent son.". It can be very easily read as them assuming Reynir specifically ran off to hurt his parents, even though that was the farthest from his mind. When combined with the first point, it makes them come across as controlling, oblivious to their own part in the situation and putting all the blame for it on Reynir alongside some emotional guilt.
** *** His mother has shown some definite MyBelovedSmother traits.
** When
traits -- for instance, when his mother assumes he's friends with Emil and Lalli, Reynir's reaction is to go along with the assumption in front of her, then apologize to ''them'' about the assumption once she's out of earshot.

Added: 266

Changed: 263

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: Reynir's parents being AbusiveParents. At face value, it's easy to read them as having an extreme but justified case of AngerBornOfWorry. However, some aspects of Reynir's interactions with them can ring alarm bells for people who had emotionally abusive parents:

to:

* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: AlternativeCharacterInterpretation:
**
Reynir's parents being AbusiveParents. At face value, it's easy to read them as having an extreme but justified case of AngerBornOfWorry. However, some aspects of Reynir's interactions with them can ring alarm bells for people who had emotionally abusive parents:

Changed: 498

Removed: 686

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
COVID shoehorn.


* HarsherInHindsight:
** The comic was launched in late 2013, a few months before the European Migrant Crisis began in earnest. The general premise of the prologue, a disease carried by refugees entering southern Europe causing the collapse of Western civilization and that the only way European countries could protect themselves was to close their borders and sink refugee boats, eerily mirrors the rhetoric used by far-right parties and politicians that came to power on platforms of xenophobia and cultural nationalism.
** Reading about a fictional plague that ravages the world hits harder after the UsefulNotes/COVID19Pandemic ravaged the world, even if that particular plague didn't get to SSSS levels.

to:

* HarsherInHindsight:
**
HarsherInHindsight: The comic was launched in late 2013, a few months before the European Migrant Crisis began in earnest. The general premise of the prologue, a disease carried by refugees entering southern Europe causing the collapse of Western civilization and that the only way European countries could protect themselves was to close their borders and sink refugee boats, eerily mirrors the rhetoric used by far-right parties and politicians that came to power on platforms of xenophobia and cultural nationalism.
** Reading about a fictional plague that ravages the world hits harder after the UsefulNotes/COVID19Pandemic ravaged the world, even if that particular plague didn't get to SSSS levels.
nationalism.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DiagnosedByTheAudience: In Lalli's case, signs of a possible disorder include NoSocialSkills, {{Cloudcuckoolander}} moments, a generally introverted personality, a tendency to withdraw or lash out when overwhelmed, and some degree of HatesBeingTouched and cat-oriented DelusionsOfDoghood. He's otherwise able to do a job that entails being outside safe areas while the trolls are the most active on his own. It can't be entirely [[NeurodiversityIsSupernatural chalked up to his mage powers]], as Onni and Reynir act quite normally in comparison to him. The author has attributed his behavior to "an extremely unconventional upbringing (and perhaps some underlying neural issues)" but also mentioned having no intent to put a name on it due to wanting to keep liberty both on how she writes him and how readers interpret him. The fandom generally agrees that he's somewhere on the autistic spectrum. The second adventure gives the reader more clues : [[spoiler:he witnessed his grandmother get possessed by a ''Kade'' and knows the exact reason his hometown was lost, and then spent the following years with this mental scar festering and never healing properly.]] It should be noted that the relative roles of nature and nuture are made even more unclear by an overlap between the skills required to resist being enthralled by trolls and the coping mechanisms that can naturally develop in someone with Lalli's life experience.

Added: 485

Removed: 480

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* PlatonicWritingRomanticReading: According to Minna, all on-panel interactions between the main characters are supposed to be platonic. However, a couple of the pairs of closer friends are gaining LikeAnOldMarriedCouple dynamics and given several scenes in which they are doing stuff alone together. When the story gets close to a point where the main group would have every reason to split up, those pairs plan to stay together either by choice or because someone else wants them to.



* RelationshipWritingFumble: According to Minna, all on-panel interactions between the main characters are supposed to be platonic. However, a couple of the pairs of closer friends are gaining LikeAnOldMarriedCouple dynamics and given several scenes in which they are doing stuff alone together. When the story gets close to a point where the main group would have every reason to split up, those pairs plan to stay together either by choice or because someone else wants them to.

Added: 1167

Changed: 2

Removed: 1175

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DarknessInducedAudienceApathy: The story has a character die at the end of Chapter 15, and manages to go downhill from there. It eventually reaches a point where the crew is separated in two groups travelling on foot, both containing someone unfit to travel on their own who could be in mortal danger if they don't get proper help soon. In addition to this, the situation seems to have made most of the characters prone to fixing problems the efficient way over the way that won't risk making their travel companion(s) hate them forever, which causes their less likable sides to become quite conspicuous. One of the storylines containing a few bonding moments was probably meant to keep this trope from happening to an extent. Unfortunately, that very same storyline also contains what is considered the worst case of someone choosing efficency in fixing a problem over someone else's well-being, causing the happier parts that came after it to have mixed results in lightening the mood. Things start getting a little better in Chapter 19, but only after several months of things consistently getting worse from the viewpoint of those following the story as it's published.



* ShipMates: Emil/Lalli shows up quite a lot as a pairing, and without them the generally agreed upon pool of pairable characters consists of five people, two of whom only have one frequently-seen option. Fanfics going the SlashFic route will almost universally have the Sigrun/Tuuri and Onni/Reynir combination. Tuuri/Reynir makes Sigrun/Mikkel the most plausible third pairing, as neither of the two latter have any regular interaction with Onni.

to:

* ShipMates: Emil/Lalli shows up quite a lot as a pairing, and without them the generally agreed upon pool of pairable characters consists of five people, two of whom only have one frequently-seen frequently seen option. Fanfics going the SlashFic route will almost universally have the Sigrun/Tuuri and Onni/Reynir combination. Tuuri/Reynir makes Sigrun/Mikkel the most plausible third pairing, as neither of the two latter have any regular interaction with Onni.


Added DiffLines:

* TooBleakStoppedCaring: The story has a character die at the end of Chapter 15, and manages to go downhill from there. It eventually reaches a point where the crew is separated in two groups travelling on foot, both containing someone unfit to travel on their own who could be in mortal danger if they don't get proper help soon. In addition to this, the situation seems to have made most of the characters prone to fixing problems the efficient way over the way that won't risk making their travel companion(s) hate them forever, which causes their less likable sides to become quite conspicuous. One of the storylines containing a few bonding moments was probably meant to keep this trope from happening to an extent. Unfortunately, that very same storyline also contains what is considered the worst case of someone choosing efficency in fixing a problem over someone else's well-being, causing the happier parts that came after it to have mixed results in lightening the mood. Things start getting a little better in Chapter 19, but only after several months of things consistently getting worse from the viewpoint of those following the story as it's published.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Chapter 6: Running out of food, and then finding a untrained, vulnerable kid in the next food crate. Double points for getting TheLoad and a side case of AdultFear at the same time.

to:

** Chapter 6: Running out of food, and then finding a untrained, vulnerable kid in the next food crate. Double points for getting TheLoad and a side case of AdultFear parental fears at the same time.
Tabs MOD

Added: 2461

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FanNickname: Fans of the webcomic have come up with names for many of the characters who weren't named in the story world at the time.
** Braidy: The man on the title page with the big red braid. His real name is Reynir Árnason.
** Captain Lady: The woman with the cropped red hair. Her real name is Sigrun Eide.
** Medic: The man with the needle. His real name is Mikkel Madsen.
** Derp Kitty: The cat on the cover and the latest addition to the team. Real name unspecified as yet. Also: "the purrito", for when she's towel-wrapped and cute with it.
** Unflappable Train Lady and Unflappable Train Guy: Crewmembers of the Dalahästen. The woman's name was later revealed to be Agneta.
** Hippo Shrimp: [[http://sssscomic.com/comic.php?page=158 This fellow]].
** Miss Hearty Undead: The lovely woman that Emil punches in the face on page [[http://sssscomic.com/comic.php?page=170 170]].
** [[http://www.sssscomic.com/comic.php?page=186 The Cat-tank, Cattank or Catmobile]].
** Handsy Moose: The creature that attacked Lalli in the dream world - the name references Hiisi Moose, a MonsterOfTheWeek from Minna's [[Webcomic/ARedtailsDream previous webcomic]].
** Mama Cat. Because she is a MamaBear in feline shape.
** And, we have the infected wolfhound most often nicknamed Cthulhund or Spiderdog with the possible Good Doggy persona locked inside that nightmare horror.
** [[Myth/NorseMythology Sleip]][[NightmareFuel nope]] for the tentacle horse ghost thing leading the pursuit of our heroes, and its many, many friends are the murderghosts.
** Reynir's mohawk-sporting brother was generally referred to as "Punkbruddir" until the family tree revealed his real name is Bjarni.
** Notoro: The name for this weird vaguely adorable troll which Emil and Lalli encounter [[http://www.sssscomic.com/comic.php?page=910 here]]
** Sentinel mage [[http://www.sssscomic.com/comic2.php?page=177 Väinö Väänänen]] went unnamed for the first few pages of his appearance, and so was promptly nicknamed 'Seagull Santa'.


Added DiffLines:

* FriendlyFandoms:
** With ''Webcomic/ShotgunShuffle'', due to a WorthyOpponent scenario in the finals of the 2014 Top Web Comic vote.
** A one-way case has developed with ''Webcomic/ScandinaviaAndTheWorld'', due to the webcomic being a Nordic-centered version of ''Webcomic/HetaliaAxisPowers'' and hence one of the less boring ways of getting a crash-course on those countries for readers who came to ''Stand Still, Stay Silent'' without knowing much of them beforehand.

Top