History YMMV / SpoonysCampaign

** Juliet's imaginary companion [[Franchise/PiratesOfTheCaribbean Captain]] [[{{IncrediblyLamePun}} Bearbossa]] who only exists in [[http://www.lordkat.com/wiki/images/0/0b/Julietcyben27.png one particular fanart.]]

* CrazyAwesome:

* TheScrappy: Some of the viewers '''really''' hate Iron Liz for all her punning. It's gotten to the point where people call for Lilea to get [[DudeNotFunny killed and/or raped in "revenge"]], which leads to Spoony [[PapaWolf dropping the banhammer]].

* MissingEpisode: LordKat did not record the first few sessions, so they are lost to people coming into the campaign late.

* HarsherInHindsight: Right before the infamous Chris Benoit black comedy moment:
--> '''Spoony''': (jokingly) No offense Jason, but I fucking hate you.
** Even earlier, the first fully recorded session starts with some of the guys discussing [[BlackComedyRape rape jokes]][[note]]In context, Rollo mentioned WebVideo/{{Benzaie}} was running material by him to make sure it wasn't crossing a line, and Rollo pointed out that he was reviewing a game called ''Rapelay'', so that line was already crossed to begin with and he shouldn't sweat it[[/note]], which becomes a bit uncomfortable when viewed through the lens of Spoony's departure from Channel Awesome years later.

** Juliet's imaginary companion [[{{Pirates Of The Caribbean}} Captain]] [[{{IncrediblyLamePun}} Bearbossa]] who only exists in [[http://www.lordkat.com/wiki/images/0/0b/Julietcyben27.png one particular fanart.]]

--> '''Spoony''': (jokingly) No offense, Jason, but I fucking hate you.

--> '''Colonel Vane II:''' But I'm so lovable!

* FanDumb: Some fans seem to believe that Spoony is a KillerGameMaster and gripe whenever he does anything seen as detrimental to the party, such as having enemies react to being marked (the Player's Handbook outright '''says''' you are aware of marks) or even [[RandomNumberGod rolling well for attack and damage rolls]]. This completely clashes with the way he's run the game, doing things like letting Joe play Vane's son despite the fact that it harmed SuspensionOfDisbelief, or fudging the dice to prevent Garret's death in order to make up for an earlier math error. In response to the accusations, Noah has outright said that he doesn't want to kill the party because that would end the game before the story was done, but he's not going to make things easy on them.
** In his own remarks and the WebVideo/CounterMonkey videos, Noah has said that he tries to be tough but fair because he wants the players to feel like they've earned their victories rather than [[MontyHaul having everything handed to them on a silver platter]].

** In his own remarks and the [[WebVideo/CounterMonkey]] videos, Noah has said that he tries to be tough but fair because he wants the players to feel like they've earned their victories rather than [[MontyHaul having everything handed to them on a silver platter]].

* FanDumb: Some fans seem to believe that Spoony is a KillerGameMaster and gripe whenever he does anything seen as detrimental to the party, such as having enemies react to being marked (the Player's Handbook outright '''says''' you are aware of marks) or even [[WhatAnIdiot rolling well for attack and damage rolls]]. This completely clashes with the way he's run the game, doing things like letting Joe play Vane II despite the fact that it harmed SuspensionOfDisbelief, or fudging the dice to prevent Garret's death in order to make up for an earlier math error. In response to the accusations, Noah has outright said that he doesn't want to kill the party because that would end the game before the story was done, but he's not going to make things easy on them.

* HarsherInHindsight: Right before the infamous Chris Benoit black comedy moment.

* {{YMMV}}: On Spoony's [=DMing=]. All in all it tends to be semi-forgiving, and very [[SceneryPorn intricate]]. He still has people accuse him of being an asshole when things start going badly for the players (whether or not he intended it).
** Liz's puns are divided as well. Some chat members love them, but a great majority of the viewers and the players only seem to groan when she makes one.