These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
YMMV: Spoony's Campaign
Badass Decay: Bayban's backstory painted him as a savage holy warrior, but since joining the party he's more remembered for his botches.
Even if it was just theoretical, imagine Viktor riding into shore on the back of a shark waving his Axe in the air, shouting. This was so awesome that Spoony told them to take a +10 to stealth because no one would be expecting it.
Viktor, very much so. During the TGWTG panel at one Magfest, the audience started up a chant of "Vik-TOR! Vik-TOR!" when Nik/YRoT introduced himself.
Epileptic Trees: No one ever checked to make sure Bob the Minion was dead....
Fan Dumb: Some fans seem to believe that Spoony is a Killer Game Master and gripe whenever he does anything seen as detrimental to the party, such as having enemies react to being marked (the Player's Handbook outright says you are aware of marks) or even rolling well for attack and damage rolls. This completely clashes with the way he's run the game, doing things like letting Joe play Vane's son despite the fact that it harmed Suspension of Disbelief, or fudging the dice to prevent Garret's death in order to make up for an earlier math error. In response to the accusations, Noah has outright said that he doesn't want to kill the party because that would end the game before the story was done, but he's not going to make things easy on them.
Spoony: (jokingly) No offense, Jason, but I fucking hate you.
Hilarious in Hindsight: When the group fought Morgana and Sean chose to open the Word, LordKaT remarked, "Why do I get the feeling the situation just got ten times worse?" The very next session, they learn that the Word is a phylactery, and that it's slowly infecting Darstine with Morgana's spirit and will.
In the first recorded session, RolloT remarks "Good old King Donovan. It's gonna be a shame when he dies", qualifying the statement by adding "It's gonna be a shame when he gets killed for being religious." Soon after, Donovan is imprisoned in magical amber specifically because the Witch Queen considered his attempts to revive worship in the old gods to be an insult.
This group is all in all very good at making this kind of statement; given that they review movies, comic books and video games for a living, this should come as no surprise.