YMMV / Silent Night, Deadly Night 5: The Toy Maker

  • Squick: Pino's little episode near the end , when he starts frantically dry humping Sarah while screaming "I love you, mommy!"
    • Noah was also giving off pedophilic vibes before its revealed the reason he's so interested in Derek is because he's his biological father.
  • Surprisingly Improved Sequel: Though it's not really saying much, many regard this as the best of the sequels. Not necessarily the most entertaining one, mind (Part 2 easily takes that title), but the most competently written and made of them, at least.
  • Unfortunate Names: As The Cinema Snob points out, the name Petto sounds an awful lot like Pedo, short for pedophile.