YMMV / Shakespeare in Love

  • Award Snub:
    • According to some, this was what Saving Private Ryan was snubbed in favor of, allegedly due to a campaign by Miramax. A campaign so effective, in fact, the Academy members are said to have actually booed the latter film. Needless to say, the film gets A LOT of hate for said snub. Rejection, thy name is Ryan.
    • Likewise Gwyneth Paltrow winning the Oscar for Best Actress in favour of (at the time) the relatively unknown Cate Blanchett for Elizabeth.
    • There are (to a lesser extent) some who feel that Ben Affleck should have got a Best Supporting Actor nomination, but it was Geoffrey Rush who was recognised for this.
  • Comedy Ghetto: The last comedy to win Best Picture until the Black Comedy Birdman, which came out in 2014. This film was released in 1998.
  • Genius Bonus:
    • In Ned Alleyn's introductory scene, he enthusiastically rattles off a list of leading roles that he's played in Marlowe's plays, then dismissively adds that he also played King Henry VI when he notices Shakespeare in earshot. If you're familiar with the Henry VI trilogy, you can understand why Ned might not think highly of the role: Henry VI is a glorified side character in the play named for him, as the play is actually about the fracturing of the English nobility in the Wars of the Roses; Henry had almost no notable accomplishments to his name, and he's largely remembered as the incompetent weakling who allowed England to descend into Civil War because he couldn't control his nobles.
    • Other than Romeo and Juliet, the three Shakespeare plays explicitly referenced in this film are Two Gentlemen of Verona (which the actors are shown performing), Henry VI and Titus Andronicus (which are both mentioned in dialogue). If you're familiar with the timeline of Shakespeare's career, this should immediately make it clear that the movie takes place at an early point in his life. Scholars generally agree that those are three of Shakespeare's earliest plays, and that one of them was probably the very first play he ever wrote (though it's almost impossible to know which one). note 
    • Every trope that happens in this movie - Sweet Polly Oliver, King Incognito, etc. - refers to similar tropes that pop up - often repeatedly - in Shakespeare's plays.
  • Hilarious in Hindsight:
    • The Earldom of Wessex hadn't existed for nine hundred years when this movie came out with a fictional Lord Wessex as the villain; a year after the film's release, Prince Edward was created Earl of Wessex on his marriage.
    • Likewise, Geoffrey Rush's eagerness to do a play about pirates.
  • Hype Backlash: Inverted. People seem to forget it's quite a good movie due to anger over the Best Picture win. Among Rotten Tomatoes' Top Critics, its Tomatometer and average review score are nearly identical to Ryan's.
  • Narm: Lampshaded.
    "Gentlemen, good e'en! A woorrrrd with one of you!"
    "...are you going to do it like that?"
  • One-Scene Wonder: Judi Dench as Queen Elizabeth I. Eight minutes of screentime total, and one Oscar for Best Supporting Actress.
  • Overshadowed by Controversy: For years if this film is mentioned, it's for Miramax's infamous Oscar campaign and the eventual perceived Award Snub of this against Saving Private Ryan and Elizabeth.
    • It also doesn't help that Harvey Weinstein was later fired from his own company for sexual harassment, with Gwyneth Paltrow among his victims. Every picture of her awkwardly smiling next to him at the Academy Awards paints this movie's nomination in an even more uncomfortable light.
  • Tear Jerker: Will and Viola parting at the end, never to meet again.
    Will: You will never age for me, nor fade, nor die.
  • They Copied It, So It Sucks: There was some controversy at the time of the film's release due to its alleged similarity to the mid-20th-century novel No Bed For Bacon by Caryl Brahms and S J Simon.
  • Vindicated by History: For years the film got a torrent of hate for the infamous Award Snub. These days the hate has levelled off and people are more appreciative of it.