YMMV / Secret Six

    open/close all folders 

    Volume 1 
  • Bizarro Episode: Issue 24 randomly diverges from the main Six continuity to deliver a one shot Elseworlds tale that casts the Six and some of their opponents as heroes and villains in a wild west setting. It is a very well done, well written and entertaining example of a BLAM though. It also foreshadows the ending of the comic, with the alternate Six falling in a Last Stand just like the main Six do against an army of superheroes in the finale.
  • Character Rerailment: After years of degrading into the Dumb Muscle of Batman's Rogues Gallery, Gail Simone reset Bane as the Genius Bruiser he was originally introduced as.
  • Crosses the Line Twice:
    • Vandal Savage force feeding Cheshire and Dr. Psycho steaks cut from Solomon Grundy. Starts off disgusting, but Savage's matter of fact remarks about it and Dr. Psycho not really minding ("I don't mean to be rude, but mine's a bit chewy.") bring it around to funny.
  • Ensemble Dark Horse: Deadshot in his Suicide Squad days.
  • Jerkass Woobie: Pretty much all of the Six but especially Bane, Catman, Deadshot, and Scandal.
  • Moral Event Horizon: If Cheshire destroying Qurac with a nuke and laughing about it didn't send her over the line, conceiving a replacement baby and forsaking Lian's life to get out of the team during Villains United probably did the trick.
  • Take That, Scrappy!: Tarantula's death. The character is not popular due to the epic Double Standard involving her actual raping of DC Comics fan favourite Nightwing, and the fact that she was accepted into his team, the Batfamily, afterwards. Suffice to say, many cheers were had when she finally got her comeuppance and died.
  • Tearjerker: Issue #36, featuring the last stand of the Secret Six.
    • From #13, Jeannette briefly hallucinates that it's her birthday, before she was executed and became a banshee. Artemis and Bane are debating whether to leave the addled woman behind, but Scandal won't have it. Then reality begins to hit Jeannette.
      Jeannette: Oh, and there'll be roast capon and figs and cakes and the most interesting of restraints... wait. Wait. He's cut off my head, hasn't he? My husband. He's cut off my head.
      Scandal: Yes. I'm sorry.
      (Jeannette falls into Scandal's arms and both begin to cry')
      Scandal: You were... you were betrayed.
    • From #34, the Six return from hell just in time to save Liana from the psychotic Randall. As the other members make Randall run a gauntlet, Scandal rescues Liana, who, despite everything, doesn't want them to kill Randall and asks Scandal to swear not to kill him. Scandal does, and hands Liana to Jeannette... and then she kills Randall. And then immediately after:
      Scandal: Would someone... would you one of you three men I love... the only men I love... please hold me for a moment? <Bane holds her and Catman puts a hand on her shoulder> I think I'm going to cry.
  • Unpopular Popular Character:Ragdoll is regarded as one of the series' highlights by many fans, but his teammates (especially Scandal and Deadshot) are far from shy in telling him that he freaks them right the hell out.

    Volume 2 
  • Ass Pull: The resolution to Sue being brainwashed is her memory simply comes back. Off-panel. It's apparent that Gail Simone didn't have enough time to address this subplot with the imminent cancellation of the book.
  • Broken Base: Fans of the original series were unhappy with the amount of queer characters in the cast being cut down, even with Catman now being openly bisexual and Porcelain being gender-fluid. There are also those who just weren't happy with Ragdoll, Jeannette, and Scandal Savage becoming supporting characters and Deadshot not appearing at all.
  • Complete Monster:
    • Junior, daughter of the first Ragdoll, is a crime boss so depraved and ruthless even Intergang gives her a wide berth. Famed for her cruelty and monstrousness, Junior routinely offers her victim a choice of dying horribly or letting Junior kill their families. When most choose the second choice, Junior records it, along with the victim's horrible death, and sends it to the families. Having obtained a card that is literally a pass out of hell, Junior kills and tortures countless people, raping men and women alike. When the card is stolen, Junior attempts to have her sins absolved by a priest, only to painfully kill the man when he refuses. Junior captures Bane of the Secret Six, who has the card, and tortures him with scissors and bricks to gain the location of the others. At the end, Junior loses control and attempts to slaughter every villain present when they see her mutilated true appearance, even her own brother Peter/Ragdoll II. Despite her backstory of her father having molested her, Junior is afforded no sympathy, knowing what a depraved monster she truly is and committing countless evil deeds because she loves it and feels she can get away with anything due to the card in her possession.
    • Mr. Smyth from the the "Depths" arc is a man with a radical plan to "better" the world: Bring back the institution of slavery, as it is what "great nations" are built upon. Smyth takes in the slaves and forces them to work in horrible conditions, leading to their deaths from overwork, cave-ins or gas. When a slave named Maria refuses to work any more, Smyth has his assistant begin slaughtering innocent slaves en masse until a broken Maria promises to keep working. Smyth later tricks Deadshot into murdering Maria by offering her "freedom" if she can run to safety before telling Deadshot she is an escaping dangerous prisoner. Smyth also keeps Amazons as slaves with the intent to force them into servitude or death as well, and shows no concern over anything but the restoration of the institution of slavery.
  • Squick: Shauna seems to be this in general due to her lack of hygiene, to the point where Catman throws up after an accidental glimpse at her privates. Etrigan also causes this on Catman when the former casually mention that he once had sex with Wonder Woman.