YMMV / Ruddigore

  • Cut Song: Several:
    • There are two versions of Robin's second-act patter song (not the trio); neither commonly used.
    • A few D'Oyly Carte revivals in the 20th century also used to cut Rose's part in "Happily coupled are we."
    • The Melodrame instrumental is sometime cut as well.
    • Additional verses exist for "I once was as meek" that rename Old Adam to Gideon Crawle.
    • There are several sections in the middle of "Painted Emblems of a Race" that are sometimes reinstated: additional entry music for the ghosts and a section of singing between the ancestors and Sir Roderic.
  • Painful Rhyme: "Oh, innocents, listen in time" which rhymes "time/I'm" and "do/so." Also, "Mounseer" is just "Monsieur" warped and mangled in order to rhyme with "Cape Finistere" (the northwest corner of Spain).
  • Tough Act to Follow: As suggested above, the fact that Ruddigore came directly after The Mikado, Gilbert and Sullivan's greatest hit (in their own time, at least) meant that to many it seemed like a failure in comparison.
  • True Art Is Angsty: Though many early critics and Gilbert himself thought Sullivan's ghost music in Act II too heavy and serious for a comic opera, modern musicologists have come to regard it as some of the finest Sir Arthur ever composed.
  • Vindicated by History: Ruddigore didn't do too well at its initial run but this was mostly because The Mikado was a very tough act to follow. However the work did enjoy some success later in the run. Unfortunately it was either never or else hardly ever revived during Gilbert's life time. It was however restored to the canon in the 1920s where it has remained ever since, and if anything it has grown in popularity since the close of the D'Oyly Carte company.
  • "Weird Al" Effect: Ruddigore has long outlasted the kind of melodrama it parodied.