YMMV / Phantasy Star

  • Awesome Music: Many examples peppered throughout the series. Proof that yes, the Sega Master System and Genesis were capable of producing epic and emotional tunes suitable for an RPG. Naturally, it has its own page.
  • Broken Base: There's one between fans of the original tetralogy and fans of the Online and Universe series. The fact that it's almost a completely different storyline that goes for an Action RPG approach compared with the turn based RPG of the original, and that Online has easily eclipsed the original games in popularity doesn't help. There's virtually zero crossover fans between the two franchises save for the truly diehard.
  • Contested Sequel: Phantasy Star III doesn't even look much like a Phantasy Star game given its radically different art style and its storyline separation from Phantasy Star II. It does however have its fair share of fans for it's branching mechanics that were perhaps a bit too far ahead of its time, the excellent music, and the ending of the game revealing some ties to the main story after all.
  • Cut-and-Paste Translation: In this case, overlaps with Pragmatic Adaptation and Macekre. Due to differences in language, a name in Japanese that easily fit in a short space can't when translated to a Western alphabet... and due to the hardware limitations of the era, simply making more room for "proper" English wasn't in the cards. As a result, localization teams often had to make new names for characters and items, but they often went out of their way to change the names into something entirely different—even for names that didn't need to be changed. They weren't consistent about the replacement names used, either. And then there's the mistranslation of Dark Force into "Dark Falz"... which ended up becoming the canonical name for the godlike cosmic horror that would debut in Online and have final boss roles in multiple games after that. Whether the name was the result of the mistranslation or just a coincidence is unknown, though it's still amusing in hindsight.
  • Fanon: Go ahead, ask some of the fans if Lutz and Noah are the same person. Then read some of the long, long justifying fan-fiction. May also qualify as Alternate Character Interpretation. In the original Japanese and Fan Translation hacks, this is indeed the case.
    • For that matter you might as well ask if Rika and Nei are the same character, due to a case of What Could Have Been.
  • Fandom Rivalry: Unsurprisingly, with Final Fantasy, with some added heat of the famous Genesis vs. SNES rivalry.
  • Just Here for Godzilla: Nei from II is one of the most recognizable characters (if not the most recognizable) from the series as a whole. She has a lot of fans in part because of her Moe appeal and being most well known for her death, one of the earliest examples of a Player Punch. She was even considered to represent the series in Sonic And SEGA All Stars Racing over characters like Alis! However, she didn't make the final cut.
  • Surprisingly Improved Sequel: PSIV is generally regarded as the best game in the original series. PSIII is... mixed.
  • They Changed It, Now It Sucks: Many fans of the original tetralogy do not like the Genre Shift from a single-player JRPG series to an action-based MMORPG series.