YMMV / PB&J Otter

  • Ear Worm: The theme song. As well as every other song featured in the series, especially the "Noodle Dance". They might be annoying, but they're still memorable.
  • Fridge Logic: In "Kid Court," Peanut, Butter and Jelly miss an obvious potential solution to their problem - why don't they at least ask their friends if they can watch their shows at their houses, while Baby Butter stays home and watches Baby Lovey? Do none of them have television?
    • Word of God says Lake Hoohaw is a poor place, so maybe not.
  • Harsher in Hindsight: The Quote Mine incident with the Snootie kids is much less funny now that there's a potential scam built around the trope (while there's no evidence that the scam would actually work, the thought is still unnerving).
  • Tastes Like Diabetes: Rivaled only by cartoons such as Baby Looney Tunes and the post-season 3 episodes of Rugrats.
  • Viewer Gender Confusion: Butter is a girl. However, due to looking similar to her older brother "Peanut", people would tend to mistake her for a boy. Astute viewers, however, might have been able to figure out her gender from a line in the show's theme song - "Ooh, mother, father, sisters and brother," though unfortunately the closed-captioning is inconsistent in correctly transcribing this line, and it can also be difficult to distinguish by hearing. Of course, it didn't help that she was One of the Boys - fond of playing in mud and enjoying boyish pursuits, preferring to spend her time with Peanut and his friends, rather than Jelly and her best friend Pinch.
  • The Woobie: Munchie Beaver.