YMMV: Out of Jimmy's Head
- Ensemble Darkhorse: The Appleday toons do seem to have a few fans, if the fanart floating around means anything. Also, comments on TV.com and Youtube state that some viewers only watched the show for the cartoon characters.
- Idiot Plot: You have no idea.
- Retroactive Recognition: In "Bad Fad," one of the kids Craig is babysitting is Brick Heck.
- Snark Bait
- So Bad, It's Good: It is fun to mock. Admit it.
- They Wasted a Perfectly Good Plot: The concept is cool, the execution...not so much.