YMMV / Nightwish

Everything from Nightwish is so over-the-top that it dances on the edge of narm, and what one person finds to be Crowning Music of Awesome can easily fall flat for someone else.

The reasoning behind Tarja's dismissal as well as Anette's departure from the band is up for debate, too. Of course, many fans on either side of the argument just read one letter or the other.

Also, whether the creator breakdown songs are Tear Jerker material or Wangst / Deus Angst Machina material is dependent on the listener.

YMMV entries related to Tarja go to her YMMV page.
  • Awesome Moments:
    • Those animal noises in "The Greatest Show on Earth", before the "The Toolmaker" section? They were made by Troy Donockley himself. And he performs them live!
    • Managing to score Floor Jansen as their singer. Even hardcore Tarja enthusiasts have admitted that's one hell of an achievement.
    • September 28, 2012, Denver, Colorado. Anette is stricken with the flu and is rushed to the hospital. Time to cancel the show, right? Wrong! Using Elize Ryd and Alissa White-Gluz, who had sung backup with opening act Kamelot as vocalists, they pull together a set list in less than an hour and put on a very memorable show. Even the promoter had never seen anything like it!
  • Anvilicious:
    • In a song that is quite atypical of their cryptic and indirect lyrical style, "Master Passion Greed" is six solid minutes of the band laying it out on Tarja's husband Marcelo Cabuli.
    • "Bye Bye Beautiful," just in case you didn't get that the male band members "hate" Tarja. Amusingly though, only Marco's lines are this, so maybe the band realised how mean spirited it would sound coming from Tarja's replacement.
    • "Yours Is An Empty Hope" is about how people who argue on the internet suck and need to get a life.
      Tear me to bits enjoy the scene
      Of screen name verbal vanity
      Churning the words imbued in filth
      Your tongue oily water under my bridge
  • Big-Lipped Alligator Moment: In the form of a keyboard homage to "Moskau" during the instrumental break of "Sacrament of Wilderness."
  • Base Breaker:
    • Any vocalist that isn't named Tarja Turunen will be considered this by fans.
    • The whole departure/removal of Tarja is a very ahem... polarizing thing for fans, whether which side is right (the band saying Tarja became more about the money and her husband was a Yoko Oh No, and Tarja saying the other members didn't treat her well) and in general affecting the outcome of later vocalists Anette and Floor. Their treatment of Anette doesn't help make the latter more polarizing.
  • Broken Base:
    • Tarja Turunen, Anette Olzon, or Floor Jansen? You pick.
    • This goes at least as far back as 2002, when Century Child was released. A lot of people didn't like the change in the band's style, and Tarja's less "operatic" vocals on that album.
    • With the firing of Anette, debates have begun over whether the band was justified in letting Anette go or not, with things becoming even more thorny after Anette made some controversial statements (about performing in Greece and about her replacement, Floor), resulting in a massive backlash against her.
  • Covered Up: "Over the Hills and Far Away" was originally performed by Gary Moore.
  • Crack Pairing: Tarja/Anette is a pretty popular pairing among members of Team Switzerland.
  • Crowning Moment of Funny: End of an Era, when the pyrotechnics attempted to assassinate Marco.
  • Die for Our Ship: Tarja/Tuomas supporters can be... weird. Also comes in Ho Yay flavor, but it's far harder to find. Somewhat fueled by the recurring Beauty and the Beast theme in Nightwish's own lyrics. In this regard, the following lines of "Bye Bye Beautiful" did not really help.
    Did you ever hear what I told you?
    Did you ever read what I wrote you?
    Did you ever listen to what we played?
    Did you ever let in what the world said?
    • And then there's these lyrics from "Ever Dream":
    Ever felt away without me
    My love it lies so deep
  • Ear Worm: The band mostly goes for completely over-the-top Epic Rocking, so a few of their songs will manage to worm their way into your head and not let go:
    • From "Bye Bye Beautiful:"
      How blind can you be?
      Don't you see?
      You chose the long road
      But we'll be waiting.
    • The chorus to Erämaan Viimeinen.
    • "Wishmaster," which has the honor of being the most misinterpreted song ever:
      Master! Apprentice!
      Heart born, seventh seeker!
      Warrior! Disciple!
      In me, the Wishmaster!
    • From "Wish I Had an Angel:"
    • "Amaranth" and "Escapist" are MAJOR earworms.
      "A nightingale in a golden cage, that's me locked inside reality's maze..."
    • There's also "End of All Hope" and "Nemo."
    • Storytime. I am the voice of Never-never-land...
    • And also from Imaginaerum: "Rest Calm" and "The Crow, the Owl and the Dove."
    • The opening riff to "Astral Romance" is insanely catchy.
    • "Cadence of Her Last Breath" is particularly memorable.
    • "Whoever Brings the Night." Appearing in LittleBigPlanet 2 may have something to do with this.
  • Ending Fatigue: A few of the Epic Rocking songs have points that they could've ended at much sooner.
    • Almost every YouTube video for "The Poet and the Pendulum" cuts it off at the ten-minute mark, at the point where most would assume the song would end, since the singer has just been sliced in half by a giant pendulum blade. There's one more slow verse after it's over.
    • And the "misheard lyrics" spoofs sometimes have a pic of a dude looking at his watch during some of the especially drawn-out bouts of epic rocking.
    • "Slow, Love, Slow," from Imaginaerum has an ending consisting of a ticking clock/metronome that goes on for over thirty seconds. Though it sort of makes up for it by having the clock/metronome setting the tempo for the following song, "I Want My Tears Back".
    • The Greatest Show On Earth is an even bigger offender than the previous songs to the tune of being 10 minutes longer than Poet (in fact, the longest song the band has ever recorded clocking in at an impressive 24 minutes) and it being a mostly instrumental track with some narration. The band don't even come into it until past the 5 minute mark and the song could have easily ended with them but instead goes on for a further 7 and a half minutes.
  • Estrogen Brigade: All of the boys have one, but most ladies gravitate towards Tuomas, leading to the Yoko Oh No situation below whenever word spreads that he has a girlfriend. Tuomas' case is arguably made more difficult by the fact both Marco and Jukka are married with children, and Emppu has a long-term girlfriend, leaving Tuomas as the only single guy (until he, too, married Johanna Kurkela in 2015).
  • Fandom Rivalry: Tarja fans, Anette fans and Floor!NW fans are constantly at each other's throats. A lot of the time it's not pretty.
  • Fanon Discontinuity:
    • Some fans discard Dark Passion Play, because of the lack of Tarja.
    • Some others discard everything before Dark Passion Play.
    • Rarer, but not unheard of, is the belief that nothing before Marco joined the band, and that a few notable tracks such as "Wishmaster" or "Sleeping Sun" were demos.
    • And even on the flip side is the belief that Tuomas went through with ending the band after Wishmaster. This belief isn't out of a hatred for Marco, but more of a distaste in the band's music shift beginning with Century Child.
  • Foe Yay: There's an interpretation that "Master Passion Greed" is partially about Tuomas having been secretly in love with Tarja and wishing he'd done something about it.
  • Harsher in Hindsight: The last concert with Tarja was released on DVD as End of an Era.
  • Ho Yay: Extremely subtle, most of the time, but sometimes it's obvious.
  • Hype Backlash: A smaller variation: Some newcommers will be put off with the glorification of the Tarja era of Nightwish, especially considering how most fans seem to dismiss later newcomers Anette and Floor. And that's all that should be said
  • Internet Backdraft:
    • The news that Richard Dawkins would be doing narration for Endless Forms Most Beautiful caused a stir among Christian fans who were worried the album would become an Author Tract for Dawkins' "religious" views - which did not happen.
    • Beforehand, the band got some immense backlash for posting a screenshot of a Mexican Facebook fan sharing the Endless Forms Most Beautiful single "Élan" on Google Drive and calling the user out. The result was the fan getting attacks from Nightwish fans and forcing him to change his account name; he blamed the band for the drama. The fact the group basically put itself against internet leaking being a crime against a band's all out campaign didn't help matters either.
    • Tarja's removal. That's all that needs to be said.
  • Launcher of a Thousand Ships: The most common version is the Real-Person Fic, and in that case, the launcher is Tuomas. In all fairness, he does make a really cute and pretty Uke.
  • Memetic Mutation:
  • Memetic Troll: according to a meme on the band's forum, Troy Donockley is none other than Turunen's husband in disguise, plotting to stab the entire band in the back at the first occasion; occasionally other people are conjectured to be Donockley in disguise as well.
  • Misattributed Song: Let's just say that they tend to fall victim to this in regards to similar-sounding musicians.
  • Mr. Fanservice: Tuomas.
  • Mondegreen: Numerous examples, several of which have been made into YouTube videos. A few of the more infamous examples, however, are...
    • "Wishmaster," which holds the title of most misunderstood Nightwish song ever, thanks to its rapid-fire stream of fantasy phrases, like "Heartborn" / "Hard Porn" and "Seventh Seeker" / "Steven Seagal."
    • One from "The Crow, the Owl and The Dove," courtesy of Gratuitous Foreign Language: "Gar tuht river, Ger te rheged" is often misheard as "Got to grieve her. Got to wreck it." It's actually Cumbric, and translates as "go to the river, you will find the fairy land."
    • For the song "Elvenpath", it sounds like, "And the bath under my bare feet, the Elvenbath".
  • Narm / Narm Charm: Nightwish's fondness for the overdramatic, combined with Tarja's limited proficiency in English and Tuomas' liberal use of Truck Driver's Gear Changes, will have one of two effects: It might make their music fall flat for you, or you might simply enjoy it as part of their signature style. Examples:
    • "End of All Hope," which sounds like a dance metal version of a military march.
    • "I Want My Tears Back" takes it to meta-levels.
    • Their first video with Floor (Élan) is this in a nutshell, featuring the band performing in front of elderly people (including a shirtless man performing odd swimming exercises in an empty pool), and then magically teleporting them all to where Floor is performing in an empty bar. They then proceed to dance in the most ridiculous fashion - including one woman who just flails her arms around while her companion is trying to waltz with her. Then there's this woman.
    • "Sagan", which is dedicated to Carl Sagan and features such masterful lyrics as "Listening to Sagan, dreaming Carl Sagan, unseen streams".
  • One True Pairing: An example of Real Life Shipping where some fans swear that Tarja and Tuomas belong together.
  • Painful Rhyme: Inverted in "Elvenpath" — "It's the honesty of these worlds / Ruled by magic and mighty swords" actually works because Tarja mispronounces "swords."
  • Retroactive Recognition: Guest vocalist Tapio Wilskanote  later joined Finntroll.
  • Surprisingly Improved Sequel: Imaginaerum, the second (and final) album with Anette (seventh overall), is a vastly different album than the first go-round with her, Dark Passion Play.
  • Suspiciously Similar Song:
    • "Forever Yours" sounds a lot like CÚline Dion's "My Heart Will Go On." The flute after the first chorus seals the deal.
    • "Where Were You Last Night" may not be an original Nightwish song, but it deserves a mention for its similarities to Bon Jovi's song "You Give Love a Bad Name" and Belinda Carlisle's "Heaven is a Place on Earth."
    • The middle section of Scaretale suddenly transforms the song into a riff on Grim Grinning Ghosts
    • The main hook to "The Greatest Show on Earth" sounds a suspicious lot like "I See You" by Leona Lewis.
  • They Changed It, Now It Sucks!: Tarja fans have been stockpiling flamethrowers for the coming arockalypse since Tarja's dismissal. So have Anette fans since her dismissal.
  • Wangst: Century Child was all about this, and Once and Dark Passion Play also had a lot of it. On other albums, however, the band's lyrics are mostly wangst-free.
  • Yoko Oh No:
    • Don't mention the idea of Tuomas having a girlfriend to his more insane fangirls.
    • In his open letter to Tarja, Tuomas stated that he thought her husband had made her a greedy and selfish person.