YMMV / New York Undercover

  • Awesome Music: The theme song.
  • Hilarious in Hindsight: Fans of Law & Order: Special Victims Unit will find it to be a shock that Ice-T, who plays the heroic badass Detective Odafin "Fin" Tutuola, playing such a ruthless killer here.
  • Magnificent Bastard: Drug dealer-turned-rival of J.C. Williams' Danny Cort, AKA Danny-Up.
  • Replacement Scrappy: Malcolm Barker, Nell Dellaney and Alec Stone in season 4. Not even the former being portrayed by Thomas Mikal Ford (of Martin fame) could cause fans of the well-liked Lt. Cooper to warm up to him. The other two were generic detectives that were brought in to still try to bring in a White demographic who replaced the beloved late Det. Eddie Torres and the widely despised Det. McNamara (see below).
  • The Scrappy: Tommy McNamara was a character brought in due to Executive Meddling that didn't fit in with fans or the cast.
  • They Changed It, Now It Sucks!: Season four.
  • The Un-Twist: An episode in which a young girl was raped had the prime suspect being a recently paroled sex offender. The man repeatedly insisted that he was innocent, angrily reminding the detectives that he had served his time and was now trying to get his life back together and lamenting the fact that he couldn't because of what he'd done, seemed genuinely sickened by his previous actions, and was devastated when his mother was killed in a vigilante attack directed at him. At the episode's end, the little girl, who until now had been rendered catatonic by the trauma, was shown pictures of potential suspects and asked if she could identify her assailant. The next scene showed the cops breaking down the door of none other than the convicted rapist who had been declaring his innocence.