YMMV / New World Order

  • Arc Fatigue: The nWo concept lasted at least a full year longer than it should have. By the time it was "Black & White" versus "nWo Wolfpac", it was already getting tired. The group ended up being revamped twice more before WCW's ultimate demise.
  • Awesome Music: Both Rockhouse and the Wolfpac theme go without saying.
  • Darkness-Induced Audience Apathy: The nWo Souled Out PPVs, especially the first one. The commentary team was an nWo provided team who buried all the faces, all the matches were refereed by the nWo's corrupt referee Nick Patrick, and it was so obviously a predetermined victory for the nWo that the fans didn't react much one way or the other. In an nWo documentary made years later, Kevin Nash said, in hindsight, the first Souled Out was the beginning of the end, as that made it clear that things had gotten out of control.
  • Deader Than Disco: The nWo Wolfpac sold so much merchandise and were so popular that they were turned into a babyface stable. Their popularity arguably exceeded that of the original nWo. At least a quarter of the audience was covered in Wolfpac merch and signs and they were popular enough that during the Nash/Goldberg match, the commentators had to no-sell very audible "Goldberg sucks" chants from Wolfpac fans. The bookers hadn't even planned to make the Wolfpac face, it was the massive positive reactions they got that turned them face. They lost any and all popularity they had after the Fingerpoke Of Doom and in the retellings, they're usually said to be stale and a ratings drain.
  • I Knew It!: Given all the time Bobby "The Brain" Heenan had been feuding with Hulk Hogan, he wasn't about to let his Face–Heel Turn pass without comment...
    Heenan: "I've been telling you people what a scumbag this man is for the past 15 years, and did any of you listen? NO!"
  • Older Than They Think: Not everybody remembers that the Wolfpac was the trio of ex-Kliq members Nash, Hall, and Waltman within the unified nWo before it was the black-and-red splinter group led by Nash with the rap theme done by C-Murder.
  • Rescued from the Scrappy Heap: Several wrestlers whose popularity had been waning got this treatment by either feuding with or joining the nWo, not the least of which was Hogan himself.
  • Rooting for the Empire: At that point in time, Hogan had been wrestling non-stop for 20 years and knew all the right buttons to push to gets pops — heel or no heel.
    • Hogan being cheered, fine, but Savage? Nothing like your women-hating, monster heel getting a face pop.
    • As discussed by Brad Hamilton, the nWo fundamentally changed how heels were depicted forever. Led by the swaggering and charismatic Hogan, Hall, and Nash, the nWo made the non-affiliated heels look like boobs. They made the babyfaces look like outdated clowns. They made the entire show pre-Bischoff look passe by literally running roughshod over WCW's history in their motorcycles. They were tailor-made to appeal to kids, which has always been pro wrestling's core demo anyway. Even McMahon has called it "the best money angle in history", and that man has a terminal case of Munchausen's anchored by his own stupendous ego.
    • In fact, the angle made so much money (at least for a while), there's perennial talk of re-re-re-re-re-reviving it in some form or another. (NEVER a good idea; it's safer to incorporate the booking ethos of the nWo "antiheroes" than to actually dig up the nWo.)
  • Seinfeld Is Unfunny: Seeing that every heel faction that has appeared in wrestling since has ripped off the nWo in some form or fashion, it can be difficult for modern wrestling fans to see why the black and white clad street thugs who trashed the environment, beat up their adversaries and spray-painted their bodies became so popular. The pro wrestling product from the mid-1980s to the mid-1990s was very cheesy and featured cartoon-like supermen fighting against equally cartoonish villains. As wrestling fans got older and peoples' tastes began to change, the nWo was revolutionary because it felt very fresh, realistic and edgy. So realistic that a few people called 911 during one of their beat downs because they believed it was a real assault!
  • Suspiciously Similar Song:
    • "Rockhouse" of assorted Jimi Hendrix songs, most obviously "Hey Joe".
    • The "Wolfpac Theme" of "Burn" by a little-known rap group called Militia.
  • Villain Decay:
    • The nWo didn't crash so much as slowly sink, with too many stragglers trying to climb aboard. By the end they were giving away memberships on box tops.
    Uproxx: Want to know why the NWO became the most trite gimmick in wrestling in the 90s? Because Stevie Ray and Vincent were feuding for leadership of NWO Black & White.
    • Nash agreed to return to wrestling so long as TNA made Immortal look like a legitimately dominating force (so the Main Event Mafia would be on near-equal ground and the feud would mean something). The week before Nash left the company, TNA filmed an angle where Crimson planted "Janice" (Abyss's nail-enhanced 2×4) into the back of Abyss (then serving as Immortal's muscle). Nash saw no point in returning when Immortal looked weaker and weaker with each passing week. After that, it just became an excuse for Garett Bischoff to turn face and feud with his old man.
  • Viral Marketing: The random emergence of The Outsiders led many fans (and even a few industry pundits) to believe Hall and Nash were actually sent by Vince McMahon to "invade" WCW—a belief which made people interested in WCW's product.