These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
YMMV: My Babysitter's a Vampire
Complete Monster: Stern. At first he's played as a simple sadist teacher, but we find out he's a genocidal wizard bent on killing all vampires in Whitechapple. Yeah, the idea is done to death, but the catch is, he isn't a Knight Templar who believes all vampires are evil - he knows some are good and hates them anyway. He is even willing to kill non vampires who stand in his way.
Moral Event Horizon: Jesse crossed it when he bites Ethan to force Sarah to give up her last chance of humanity. Although he claims to have done much worse.
Nightmare Fuel - The first episode gave us the zombie animals...especially the dog
The episode Guys and Dolls has that doll that's turned into a 30 year+ woman obsessing (ala pedophilia) over the main character's little sister. Not to mention her falling apart and getting damaged and draining the life force out of humans (and vampires) and turning them into dolls.
Later at the end of the episode when Debbie Dazzle has been turned back into a doll, while all the characters are dancing, she turns her head and winks.
Possessed Rory in "Die Pod" (the special effects worked a little too well), and possessed Sarah in "Three Geeks and a Demon".
Evil Sarah in "Independence Daze", on a psychological rather than visual level. The idea of sweet, lovable Sarah turning evil is terrifying.
So Bad, It's Good: Mainly because it tries too hard to be dark, leading to a lot of Narm. That, and the Windows Movie Maker quality special effects.
Shifting towards just plain good in season 2, with some genuinely witty dialogue, subtle characterization, much improved acting across the board, and an even more post-modern, satirical sense of humor. There's still Narm, but it works and adds to the fun.