YMMV / Mr. Meaty

  • Broken Base: Season two focused less on bizarre comedy and Mr. Meaty and started focusing more on growing up and Josh and Parker's lives outside of the mall. Needless to say, fans were not pleased.
  • Crosses the Line Twice: For a kid's show, it's got a pretty ballsy theme song.
  • Fanon Discontinuity: Many fans consider season two the worst of the series and prefer the shorts and season one. They usually stop right after "Geezers", which is considered the true series finale.
  • Idiot Plot: Several. In "Noseferateens", Ashley fully buys Josh's nonsense about having a cream that can cure her acne, and continues to rely on them for help even after their concoction causes her nose to fall off.
  • Nightmare Fuel: See here.
  • Squick: The tapeworm episode. Oy coloy.
  • So Okay, It's Average: Some people honestly had no problem with the show, being an average gross-out comedy.
  • They Changed It, Now It Sucks!: Season two.
  • Uncanny Valley: Almost every character. Even the non-human puppets come off as creepy. But none are as nightmarish as Chip 2.6, a robot assigned to work at the Mr. Meaty at Scaunchboro Mall in the episode "Model Employee"
  • Uncertain Audience: Probably playing a factor in its cancellation, the show manages to look very kiddie and absolutely creepy at the same time. Although it was probably aimed primarily at a tween audience, its ready supply of surreal imagery and humor mixed with more typical fare makes it a unique outlier in the Nicktoon lineup.