YMMV / Marillion

  • Broken Base: Fish-era fans vs. Hogarth-era fans. Even though, as mentioned on the main page, both singers approve of each other's work with the band.
  • Crowning Moment of Awesome: The first time they pulled off the pre-order gambit. Doubles as a Take That! to the music industry.
  • Crowning Music of Awesome: Any Rothery solo spot.
    • "Grendel." I don't care what anyone says.
    • "This Strange Engine."
    • "Chelsea Monday" and "The Last Straw".
    • This list should be a lot longer. "Gaza", "Ocean Cloud", "Goodbye to All That", "The Invisible Man", "Neverland", pretty much all of Misplaced Childhood, list goes on and on.
      • With "The New Kings" soon to be added.
  • Dork Age: The 1997 - 1999 era is usually considered this. Whether 2001's Anoraknophobia ended or continued it is a point of debate.
  • Face of the Band: Both Fish and Steve Hogarth are powerful stage presences.
  • Germans Love David Hasselhoff: They get little attention in the UK, but they are quite popular in Holland.
  • Ho Yay: Between Steve Hogarth and Porcupine Tree's Richard Barbieri. Behold.
  • Narm: "Grendel", also known as The Song Which Must Not Be Named. See Purple Prose.
  • Signature Song: Debatable, but either of the following: Script For A Jester's Tear, Kayleigh, Easter or Neverland.
  • Some Anvils Need to Be Dropped: Misplaced Childhood gets pretty Anvilicious about the devastation caused by war towards the end of the album, but considering how many people still blindly support whatever wars their government wants them to support, it's a message that apparently needs to be hammered home again and again. Brave has its own anvils about things like the horrible effects of abuse, and again, they're still completely necessary.
    • "Forgotten Sons" may seem like yet another song about The Troubles, but keep in mind that the Script for a Jester's Tear album came out in March of '83, and that in December that year, an IRA cell detonated a car bomb outside Harrod's.
    • "Gaza". Probably their most Anvilicious song to date, and accused of having a Captain Obvious Aesop... to which the song itself simply replies with "it just ain't right!"
  • True Art Is Angsty: Lampshaded by Hogarth.
    "The first half will be quiet, slow, depressing music. The second half will still be depressing, but a bit louder."
  • The Woobie: Steve Hogarth. Being "the new singer since 1989" is hard enough without all the misery that's happened to him, and it shows.
  • Tear Jerker: "The Great Escape". Dear God, The Great Escape...
    • There is no song out there that hammers home the horror of The Troubles quite like "Forgotten Sons". Especially the last section, after the line "Approach... friend".
    • "Holloway Girl" becomes this if you know what it is about:
    Steve Hogarth: "Years ago when I was part of 'The Europeans' we sometimes rehearsed around the corner from Holloway Women's Prison. I think prisons are fascinating places, like all alternative societies, and I used to stare up at the walls and watch the gate police. Years later I saw a documentary on TV. A camera crew had been allowed to film inside. A lot of tough girls for sure, but among them, there were women who should have been in mental hospitals - not prison. Victims of an 'underfunded' society which would lock up the desperate rather than tend to their troubled minds."
    • "Estonia", named for the ferry that went down in the Baltic Sea in 1994, is both incredibly sad and uplifting.
  • What Do You Mean, It Wasn't Made on Drugs?: Bits of Brave and, especially, Marbles. Drilling Holes stands out. Justified as it's a Beatles homage.
    • The Fish albums were obviously made on booze.
    • Word of God says that the lyrics to Misplaced Childhood was largely written on acid.