YMMV: Judd Winick
- "Readers will see Shado, Connor Hawke?s mother in the series soon. Winick said that he likes the complicating dynamic that she brings to the title, that is, adding a mother to the father and son relationship of Ollie and Connor."
- Anvilicious: Winick found critical success with Pedro And Me - an autobiographical comic that told the story of how he and his Real World co-star (the late HIV-positive gay-rights activist Pedro Zamora) became best friends. Since then, Winick has gone on to introduce gay and/or HIV Positive characters into most of the comics he writes, usually in Very Special Issues.
- My Real Daddy: Although Jason "the dead Robin" Todd was created by Gerry Conway, Judd Winick set his status quo as the Red Hood and defined his character for the new millennium.
- He's considered this for Jason so much so that even Grant Morrison himself couldn't quite pull off a Red Hood story in the eyes of most fans.
- Also counts as the real dad of Batwing, the Batman of Africa, who was originally a background character in a couple issues of Batman Incorporated before being given his very own ongoing written by Winick as part of the New 52 relaunch.
- Rescued from the Scrappy Heap: It is generally agreed that despite his screw-ups, Winick's writing has been improving over the years, in such places as the Batman books and Justice League: Generation Lost.
- Also, many didn't particularly care for his "Under the Hood" story in the comics, but the film Under the Red Hood which adapted the story and changed some of the sillier elements won many over to the story as well as to Jason Todd, who before then had been more of a Scrappy.
- They Just Didn't Care: Given the complexity of modern comic-book continuity, fans might have been willing to forgive him for Critical Research Failure, if he did not appear to actively ignore other writers offering advice on how to handle the characters they created.