YMMV: Jason Aldean

  • Broken Base: Aldean's heavy rock influences and strange singing voice have earned him a lot of fans and detractors, but even the apologists thought that "1994" (a silly novelty song that name-drops Joe Diffie but otherwise is just another song about partying with a hot girl in the country) was his nadir.
    • "Burnin' It Down", an electropop Intercourse with You song, got his fans throwing their arms in the air.
  • Covered Up: Most of his songs, surprisingly, were recorded by others first. "Why", "Amarillo Sky" and "Johnny Cash" were previously recorded by Shannon Brown (another Big & Rich protégé), McBride & the Ride, and Tracy Byrd, respectively. Of these, only McBride & the Ride's version of "Amarillo Sky" was a single before Jason got to it. Also, "The Truth" was originally recorded by Trent Willmon, "My Kinda Party" recorded by country-rocker Brantley Gilbert, and "Dirt Road Anthem" recorded by Colt Ford (with Gilbert also co-writing the latter and singing on it).
  • Ear Worm: "I can take you for a ride on my big green tractor / We can go slow or make it go faster…"
  • First Installment Wins: His Self-Titled Album is often considered to usually be his best.
  • Squick: Plenty of music reviewers find the base-breaking "Burnin' It Down" to not be sexy at all.
  • Sophomore Slump: Relentless is his lowest-selling album, and the only one not to produce a top 5 hit. But he rebounded with the third album and hasn't looked back.
  • Tear Jerker: "Laughed Until We Cried", particularly the verse about his grandpa and then the next verse about their newborn baby that they tried so long to have.