These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
No, really. This trope is invoked and the tree is actively cultivated by the characters themselves. Summed up nicely by one of the final scenes, where Tylor clumsy tosses a dart behind his back, only to have it hit a dead bullseye.
By the end it seems like it has to be a little bit of both. Even if he were a genius, Tylor stumbles onto situations powered by sheer blind luck while enough hints are dropped that it's hard to buy into him just being a lucky idiot.
Badass Decay: Yamamoto. In the second episode he's the leader of the forces assigned to the hostage situation, firmly in control of himself. Things go Tylor's way during the hostage situation, ridiculing him. As such he gets assigned to the Soyokaze and thus becomes rather pathetic in his efforts to control Tylor.
Yet, he also Took a Level in Badass when he took command after Tylor got captured by the Raalgon, deciding to just warp directly in front of the Raalgon flagship and start blasting.
Crazy Awesome: Tylor is one of the trope's best examples. No one's clear on whether he's a lucky fool masquerading as a genius, a genius using people's opinions of him as a fool to become a Chess Master, A Magnificent Bastard, or a lunatic whose irrational approach manages to somehow always work.
The William Tell Overture plays during the most epic game of chicken ever in episode 23.
Suppe's Charge of the Light Cavalry during Operation: Rescue Yuriko in the final episode.
Family Unfriendly Aesop: Ignore all your responsibilities and do whatever you want all the time and things will turn out for the best. Still, just like Tylor himself, there may be more depth to this philosophy than there initially seems.
Specifically, one interpretation is that Tylor deliberately let them do what they want, get in over their heads, and only be saved by his apparent foolishness by giving a time bomb in a box to the Raalgons they had surrendered to.
It's worth noting that "Do what you want" was the one order the crew wasn't capable of disobeying.
Considering he's in the side of the heroes, I'd say he's a Guile Hero. Still magnificent.
Periphery Demographic: John Ringo apparently loved the series so much as to writenote Together with one Victor Mitchell an even more insane parody of it, a short story "A Ship Named Francis", for the Honor Harrington anthology In the Service of the Sword. On the other hand it was a much crazier and less adjusted ship this time.