Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / InDesertAndWilderness

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It took all the way to 2024, over a century after the book entered curriculum, to reduce its presence to "only" fragments, while said fragments are still nearly half of the whole thing. And the reason cited was about ValuesDissonance (hence trimming it down to more neutral fragments), rather than the quality of the book itself.

to:

** It took all the way to 2024, over a century after the book entered curriculum, to reduce its presence to "only" fragments, while said fragments are still nearly half of the whole thing. And the reason cited was about ValuesDissonance (hence trimming it down to more neutral fragments), bits), rather than the quality of the book itself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It took all the way to 2024, over a century after the book entered curriculum, to reduce its presence to "only" fragments, while said fragments are still nearly half of the whole thing. And the reason cited was about ValuesDissonance (hence trimming it down to more neutral fragments), rather than the quality of the book itself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Indeed, the book made Saba quite popular dog name in Poland and almost all dog who bear the name are female.

to:

** Indeed, the book made Saba quite popular dog name in Poland and almost all dog most dogs who bear the name are female.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Actually, in polish forms of verb and adjective indicate the gender of a subject, so it's pretty clear that Saba is male in almost every sentence that mentions him. The confusion probably applies to the people who didn't actually read the book.

to:

** Actually, in polish Polish forms of verb and adjective indicate the gender of a subject, so it's pretty clear that Saba is male in almost every sentence that mentions him. The confusion probably applies to the people who didn't actually read the book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Actually, in polish forms of verb and adjective indicate the gender of a subject, so it's pretty clear that Saba is male in almost every sentence that mentions him. The confusion probably applies to the people who didn't actually read the book.

Added: 111

Changed: 33

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CriticalDissonance: It is continously an obligatory book to read in Polish education, keeping that status for generations, meaning it is considered by a whole lot of people at high places to be good and worth reading. Ask readers what they think and it will easily get listed among the most boring books they had to read in their lives, with routine complains about flat characters.

to:

* CriticalDissonance: It is continously an obligatory book to read in Polish education, keeping that status for generations, meaning it is considered by a whole lot of people at high places to be good and worth reading. Ask readers what they think and it some will easily get listed list it among the most boring books they had to read in their lives, with routine complains about flat characters.



* ViewerGenderConfusion: Due to the way how grammatical gender and names[[note]]With a few exceptions, names ending in -a are girl names[[/note]] work in Polish, most people take Saba to be a bitch. It's mentioned ''once'' as a male mastiff.

to:

* ViewerGenderConfusion: Due to the way how grammatical gender and names[[note]]With a few exceptions, names ending in -a are girl names[[/note]] work in Polish, most people take Saba to be a bitch. female. It's mentioned ''once'' as a male mastiff.mastiff.
** Indeed, the book made Saba quite popular dog name in Poland and almost all dog who bear the name are female.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ViewerGenderConfusion: Due to the way how grammatical gender works in Polish, most people take Saba to be a bitch. It's mentioned ''once'' as a male mastiff.

to:

* ViewerGenderConfusion: Due to the way how grammatical gender works and names[[note]]With a few exceptions, names ending in -a are girl names[[/note]] work in Polish, most people take Saba to be a bitch. It's mentioned ''once'' as a male mastiff.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ViewerGenderConfusion: Due to the way how grammatical gender works in Polish, most people take Saba to be a bitch. It's mentioned ''once'' as a male mastiff.

to:

* ViewerGenderConfusion: Due to the way how grammatical gender works in Polish, most people take Saba to be a bitch. It's mentioned ''once'' as a male mastiff.mastiff.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Less confusion this way


* ViewerGenderConfusion: Due to the way how grammatical gender works in Polish, most people take Saba to be a bitch. It's mentioned ''once'' as a male dogo.

to:

* ViewerGenderConfusion: Due to the way how grammatical gender works in Polish, most people take Saba to be a bitch. It's mentioned ''once'' as a male dogo.mastiff.

Added: 147

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SugarWiki/FunnyMoments: Kali provides quite a few but probably the most iconic is morality.

to:

* SugarWiki/FunnyMoments: Kali provides quite a few but probably the most iconic is his morality.


Added DiffLines:

** Made twice funny by the fact that Kali takes a short while to think over his first answer but drops the second one without slightest hesitation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SugarWiki/FunnyMoments: Kali provides quite a few but probably the most iconic is morality.
-->'''Stas:''' Tell me, Kali, what is a bad deed?
-->'''Kali:''' [[YouNoTakeCandle When somebody steal cow from]] [[ThirdPersonPerson Kali]].
-->'''Stas:''' Correct. Now what is a ''good deed?''
-->'''Kali:''' When Kali steal cow from somebody.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CriticalDissonance: It is continously an obligatory book to read in Polish education, keeping that status for generations, meaning it is considered by a whole lot of people at high places to be good and worth reading. Ask readers what they think and it will easily get listed among the most boring books they had to read in their lives, with routine complains about flat characters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ViewerGenderConfusion: Due to the way how grammatical gender works in Polish, most people take Saba to be a bitch. It's a male dogo.

to:

* ViewerGenderConfusion: Due to the way how grammatical gender works in Polish, most people take Saba to be a bitch. It's mentioned ''once'' as a male dogo.

Added: 134

Changed: -4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MemeticMutation: In Polish culture, a moral DoubleStandard is known as "Kali's morality". It comes from a scene in which Staś attempts to teach Kali about Christian morality (with some WhiteMansBurden and InsaneTrollLogic along the way): bad is when somebody steals from Kali, says Kali. And good, asks Staś? Good, Kali answers, is when Kali steals from somebody.

to:

* MemeticMutation: In Polish culture, a moral DoubleStandard is known as "Kali's morality". It comes from a scene in which Staś attempts to teach Kali about Christian morality (with some WhiteMansBurden and InsaneTrollLogic along the way): bad is when somebody steals from Kali, says Kali. And good, asks Staś? Good, Kali answers, is when Kali steals from somebody.somebody.
* ViewerGenderConfusion: Due to the way how grammatical gender works in Polish, most people take Saba to be a bitch. It's a male dogo.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed "Marty Stu", since it's now a Flame Bait example that should not be allowed; see "Flame Bait" page for more details.


* MartyStu: Staś; [[{{Omniglot}} speaks Polish, English, French, Arabian, Swahili and a couple of other African languages]]. Swims like a fish, hits anything he shoots, the only people who don't like him are villains (he has one SourSupporter, who berates Staś for what he deems a HonourBeforeReason stunt). His only [[GoodFlawsBadFlaws flaw is a tendency to boast]], which he [[HumblePie loses]] early in the book. He is [[ImprobableAge fourteen]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** To give credit where it is due, Sienkiewicz does bring up this point: there is a scene where Mr Tarkowski is stated to be quite troubled by that, but stays silent out of a sense of courtesy towards Mr Rawlinson. But since it's mentioned about nowhere else in the book, you would be forgiven for missing it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Sienkiewicz was born and living in the part of Poland annexed by Russia.


* {{Irony}}: Sienkiewicz is (in)famous for writing [[Literature/SienkiewiczTrilogy The Trilogy]] to "lift up hearts". He was living long after [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partitions_of_Poland Poland was divided and ruled by foreign powers]] and removed from maps, as a citizen of Austria-Hungary. Yet in this book he has zero remorse toward [[OccupiersOutOfOurCountry partiotic uprising and opposing foreign invasion]][[note]]the very theme of ''The Deluge''[[/note]], treats rebels as scum of the Earth, while colonial powers and their imperialism is glorified to no end. Since both ''In Desert And Wilderness'' and ''The Trilogy'' are obligatory books in Polish curriculum, try to imagine the mental gymnastics required to handle this in school.

to:

* {{Irony}}: Sienkiewicz is (in)famous for writing [[Literature/SienkiewiczTrilogy The Trilogy]] to "lift up hearts". He was living long after [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partitions_of_Poland Poland was divided and ruled by foreign powers]] and removed from maps, as a citizen of Austria-Hungary.Russia. Yet in this book he has zero remorse toward [[OccupiersOutOfOurCountry partiotic uprising and opposing foreign invasion]][[note]]the very theme of ''The Deluge''[[/note]], treats rebels as scum of the Earth, while colonial powers and their imperialism is glorified to no end. Since both ''In Desert And Wilderness'' and ''The Trilogy'' are obligatory books in Polish curriculum, try to imagine the mental gymnastics required to handle this in school.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CultClassic: The first film adaptation is still foundly remembered. The second, for contrast, is almost forgotten.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Irony}}: Sienkiewicz is (in)famous for writing [[Literature/SienkiewiczTrilogy The Trilogy]] to "lift up hearts". He was living long after [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partitions_of_Poland Poland was divided and ruled by foreign powers]] and removed from maps, as a citizen of Austria-Hungary. Yet in this book he has zero remorse toward partiotic uprising and opposing foreign invasion[[note]]the very theme of ''The Deluge''[[/note]], treats rebels as scum of the Earth, while colonial powers and their imperialism is glorified to no end. Since both ''In Desert And Wilderness'' and ''The Trilogy'' are obligatory books in Polish curriculum, try to imagine the mental gymnastics required to handle this in school.

to:

* {{Irony}}: Sienkiewicz is (in)famous for writing [[Literature/SienkiewiczTrilogy The Trilogy]] to "lift up hearts". He was living long after [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partitions_of_Poland Poland was divided and ruled by foreign powers]] and removed from maps, as a citizen of Austria-Hungary. Yet in this book he has zero remorse toward [[OccupiersOutOfOurCountry partiotic uprising and opposing foreign invasion[[note]]the invasion]][[note]]the very theme of ''The Deluge''[[/note]], treats rebels as scum of the Earth, while colonial powers and their imperialism is glorified to no end. Since both ''In Desert And Wilderness'' and ''The Trilogy'' are obligatory books in Polish curriculum, try to imagine the mental gymnastics required to handle this in school.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Irony}}: Sienkiewicz is (in)famous for writing [[Literature/SienkiewiczTrilogy The Trilogy]] to "lift up hearts". He was living long after [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partitions_of_Poland Poland was divided and ruled by foreign powers]] and removed from maps, as a citizen of Austria-Hungary. Yet in this book he has zero remorse toward partiotic uprising and opposing foreign invasion, treats rebels as scum of the Earth, while colonial powers and their imperialism is glorified to no end. Since both ''In Desert And Wilderness'' and ''The Trilogy'' are obligatory books in Polish curriculum, try to imagine the mental gymnastics required to handle this in school.

to:

* {{Irony}}: Sienkiewicz is (in)famous for writing [[Literature/SienkiewiczTrilogy The Trilogy]] to "lift up hearts". He was living long after [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partitions_of_Poland Poland was divided and ruled by foreign powers]] and removed from maps, as a citizen of Austria-Hungary. Yet in this book he has zero remorse toward partiotic uprising and opposing foreign invasion, invasion[[note]]the very theme of ''The Deluge''[[/note]], treats rebels as scum of the Earth, while colonial powers and their imperialism is glorified to no end. Since both ''In Desert And Wilderness'' and ''The Trilogy'' are obligatory books in Polish curriculum, try to imagine the mental gymnastics required to handle this in school.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Irony}}: Sienkiewicz is (in)famous for writing [[Literature/SienkiewiczTrilogy The Trilogy]] to "lift up hearts". He was living in times when [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partitions_of_Poland Poland was divided and ruled by foreign powers]] and removed from maps. Yet in this book he has zero remorse toward partiotic uprising and opposing foreign invasion, treats rebels as scum of the Earth, while colonial powers and their imperialism is glorified to no end. Since both ''In Desert And Wilderness'' and ''The Trilogy'' are obligatory books in Polish curriculum, try to imagine the mental gymnastics required to handle this in school.

to:

* {{Irony}}: Sienkiewicz is (in)famous for writing [[Literature/SienkiewiczTrilogy The Trilogy]] to "lift up hearts". He was living in times when long after [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partitions_of_Poland Poland was divided and ruled by foreign powers]] and removed from maps.maps, as a citizen of Austria-Hungary. Yet in this book he has zero remorse toward partiotic uprising and opposing foreign invasion, treats rebels as scum of the Earth, while colonial powers and their imperialism is glorified to no end. Since both ''In Desert And Wilderness'' and ''The Trilogy'' are obligatory books in Polish curriculum, try to imagine the mental gymnastics required to handle this in school.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Irony}}: Sienkiewicz is (in)famous for writing [[Literature/SienkiewiczTrilogy The Trilogy]] to "lift up hearts". He was living in times when [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partitions_of_Poland Poland was divided and ruled by foreign powers]] and removed from maps. Yet in this book he has zero remorse toward partiotic uprising and opposing foreign invasion, treats rebels as scum of the Earth, while colonial powers and their imperialism is glorified to no end. Since both ''In Desert And Wilderness'' and ''The Trilogy'' are obligatory books in Polish curriculum, try to imagine the mental gymnastics required to handle this.

to:

* {{Irony}}: Sienkiewicz is (in)famous for writing [[Literature/SienkiewiczTrilogy The Trilogy]] to "lift up hearts". He was living in times when [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partitions_of_Poland Poland was divided and ruled by foreign powers]] and removed from maps. Yet in this book he has zero remorse toward partiotic uprising and opposing foreign invasion, treats rebels as scum of the Earth, while colonial powers and their imperialism is glorified to no end. Since both ''In Desert And Wilderness'' and ''The Trilogy'' are obligatory books in Polish curriculum, try to imagine the mental gymnastics required to handle this.this in school.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Irony}}: Sienkiewicz is (in)famous for writing [[Literature/SienkiewiczTrilogy The Trilogy]] to "lift up hearts". He was living in times when [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partitions_of_Poland Poland was divided and ruled by foreign powers]] and removed from maps. Yet in this book he has zero remorse toward partiotic uprising and opposing foreign invasion, treats rebels as scum of the Earth, while colonial powers and their imperialism is glorified to no end. Since both ''In Desert And Wilderness'' and ''The Trilogy'' are obligatory books in Polish curriculum, try to imagine the mental gymnastics required to handle this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FairForItsDay: The book aged really badly when it comes to characters' morality and portray of non-white people (or [[DarkestAfrica Africa as a whole]]), while it was a standard fare adventure book when it came out. One can only wonder how Sienkiewicz, coming from a place with no colonies and ruled by foreign overlords, could write a book glorifying colonialism and imperialism.

Added: 365

Changed: -4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MartyStu: Staś; [[{{Omniglot}} speaks Polish, English, French, Arabian, Swahili and a couple of other African languages]]. Swims like a fish, hits anything he shoots, the only people who don't like him are villains (he has one SourSupporter, who berates Staś for what he deems a HonourBeforeReason stunt). His only [[GoodFlawsBadFlaws flaw is a tendency to boast]], which he [[HumblePie loses]] early in the book. He is [[ImprobableAge fourteen]].

to:

* MartyStu: Staś; [[{{Omniglot}} speaks Polish, English, French, Arabian, Swahili and a couple of other African languages]]. Swims like a fish, hits anything he shoots, the only people who don't like him are villains (he has one SourSupporter, who berates Staś for what he deems a HonourBeforeReason stunt). His only [[GoodFlawsBadFlaws flaw is a tendency to boast]], which he [[HumblePie loses]] early in the book. He is [[ImprobableAge fourteen]].fourteen]].
* MemeticMutation: In Polish culture, a moral DoubleStandard is known as "Kali's morality". It comes from a scene in which Staś attempts to teach Kali about Christian morality (with some WhiteMansBurden and InsaneTrollLogic along the way): bad is when somebody steals from Kali, says Kali. And good, asks Staś? Good, Kali answers, is when Kali steals from somebody.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
moved from main page

Added DiffLines:

* MartyStu: Staś; [[{{Omniglot}} speaks Polish, English, French, Arabian, Swahili and a couple of other African languages]]. Swims like a fish, hits anything he shoots, the only people who don't like him are villains (he has one SourSupporter, who berates Staś for what he deems a HonourBeforeReason stunt). His only [[GoodFlawsBadFlaws flaw is a tendency to boast]], which he [[HumblePie loses]] early in the book. He is [[ImprobableAge fourteen]].

Top