YMMV: I Don't Want to Kill You
- Crowning Moment of Awesome: John talking the Handyman into killing himself.
- Crowning Moment of Heartwarming - Definitely a case of YMMV, but when John talks to Marci's body at the end while embalming her
- Though whether it squicks you out too much for the heartwarming or not, this is definitely a Tear Jerker.
- Paranoia Fuel: Nobody, full stop.
- X Meets Y: Dexter meets Supernatural.
- Too Cool to Live: When a chick shows up who's hot, smart, funny, compassionate and seems to like John for who he is, you pretty much know her days are numbered.