YMMV / Gotham Girls

  • Broken Base: Some fans prefer the funny episodes from season 1 and 2 or the serious story arc from season 3.
  • Les Yay:
    • Harley and Ivy, obviously.
    • There is also the episode where Batgirl, having been turned into a cat, finds herself on Catwoman's lap and enjoys being petted. Les Yay level briefly shoots through the roof when she regains her normal form.
    • In that same episode (Episode 2: Lap Bat), after you interact with the mouse, you'll hear this:
      Batgirl: [thinking] She's never this nice to me. Most of the time - ooooh. Oooooooohh yeeeah, right behind the ear. Scratch behind the ear. Behind the ear, woman!
    • Harley even says, "you're goin' legit, huh?" when she asks why Ivy's holding flowers and she says, "Batgirl."
  • Fridge Logic: Mr. Freeze is a man. Ignoring the fact that it doesn't even fit his ice theme, why would he make a gun that only got rid of men?
  • They Wasted a Perfectly Good Character: Sadly, they created Ms. Freeze just in time for the show to stop. However, considering she has the voice actress and pretty much the same features as Killer Frost in her Justice League appearances, it is easy to Wild Mass Guess it as the Start of Darkness for a fan favorite DCAU character that would not otherwise have an origin.