troperville

tools

toys


main index

Narrative

Genre

Media

Topical Tropes

Other Categories

TV Tropes Org
random
YMMV: Fiddler on the Roof
  • Black and Grey Morality: While the barbaric cossacks and corrupt officials responsible for the pogroms are unquestionably evil, the musical, and especially the film version, casts a much more skeptical eye on Tevye, the other people of Anatevka and their ways than did the books they were based on, showing that the bigotry and xenophobia that characterized their relations with the gentiles was coming from both sides, and by contrast, that they could also get along if given the chance. This probably has something to do with being made around the time the festival of amorality that is the Arab-Israeli Conflict was going into full swing and many Jews began to question their frequent portrayals as blameless victims.
    • Alternatively, the unease with which the Russians put the Jews forestall any meaningful interaction between the two of them, given that, as Tevye alludes to, it's more a question of when instead of if there will be a pogrom
  • Crowning Music of Awesome: A lot of it. Particularly worth mentioning, in the film adaptation the overture includes a long, virtuosic violin cadenza performed by Isaac Stern.
    • "Sunrise, Sunset" is still performed at weddings to this day.
  • Crowning Moment of Heartwarming: "Do You Love Me".
  • Ear Worm: "Tradition" (especially the fiddle solo), "L'Chaim", "If I Were a Rich Man", and "Matchmaker, Matchmaker" are probably the worst.
  • Fridge Horror: At the end of the play there's a sad undercurrent, becajse Hodel and Perchik will apparently remain in deepest Siberia instead of escaping to Krakow like Chava and Fyedka. Then you remember that this takes place about 35 years before the Holocaust, and realize that Chava and her children will likely end up gassed in Auschwitz while Hodel and Perchik may very well survive.
    • Possibly, but you forget that Siberia was not left untouched by persecution either: in the Civil War, it would be fought over by both the Red Army under Trotsky (who, contrary to popular belief, would casually endorse a pogrom or two once in a while to help "purify" the "counterrevolutionary influences"), and the White army under Kolchak (who, if anything, was even worse in that regard). While it is quite possible that they would escape notice by not being near the railroad, they aren't likely to enjoy themselves either.
    • Just to complete the picure, if Anatevka existed, there's a good chance it's within the radius of territory rendered uninhabitable by Chernobyl.
      • Anatevka's confirmed to be in Ukraine. Holy cow.
      • To drive the screw just that little bit more, even if they DO survive the bloodshed and pogroms of World War One, Red October, the Polish-Soviet War, and World War II, they will all be living on the wrong side of the Iron Curtain come the Cold War.
      • Still, thirty years is plenty of time for the others to end up following Tzeitel's parents to America at some point (and hopefully Chava and Fyedka, who go to Krakow, would make the same decision, as Chava and their children would still be considered Jewish under the Nuremberg Laws). Poland had issues with anti-Semitism even before the Nazi invasion, and so perhaps they would have found another reason to pack up and leave.
    • .....You know, let's just draw the line here, and agree that any way you cut it, someone's gonna lose a finger. Fortunately, in the original stories, they pack up and move to Palestine.
  • "Funny Aneurysm" Moment: Not exactly funny, per se, but Perchik participating in the October Revolution definitely counts.
  • Germans Love David Hasselhoff: The play was a surprise hit in Japan, where the theme of crumbling tradition resonated heavily with the elderly generation.
  • Nightmare Fuel: The movie version of Fruma Sarah's solo in "The Dream".
  • One-Scene Wonder: Fruma Sarah. It's also a theatre role where hamming it up is required, along with a harness (or a cast member with a sturdy set of shoulders).
  • Protagonist Title Fallacy: Teyve is not the fiddler on the roof; however, the fiddler represents the inhabitants of Anatevka: trying to play a pleasant old tune in perilous circumstances.
  • TearJerker: And how.
  • Values Dissonance: The original Tevye the Dairyman stories by Sholem Aleykhem, on which the musical is based, portrayed Tevye's decision to disown Chava after she marries Fyedka in a more positive light. It was what any good Jewish father of the time would do if his child chose to marry a Gentile (and to really hammer this home, Sholem Aleykhem has Chava abandon Fyedka and return to Judaism at the end). People today who see the musical (which doesn't really take a side), though, usually come away from it thinking Tevye's actions toward her are excessive and cruel.
    • Though the movie does show that the father feels trapped by his traditions at this point, but also that she was kinda stupid to run off and expect everything to be hunky dory. Still, it is easy to see it as a Kick the Dog moment for Tevye.
    • And it's important to remember that it's not just culture, it's religion. By accepting Chava's marriage he would be rejecting his faith, and he wasn't willing to do that. In fact, to him his daughter rejecting their faith to marry a Christian is worse than her dying, as he believes it has eternal consequences.
    • He does unbend a little bit at the very end when the family is having to leave their land and Chava comes to say goodbye. Specifically, he gives her a quiet "God be with you" and subtly endorses his wife and other daughter's reaching out to her.

random
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy
9397
25