!! YMMV for the animated short:
* AudienceAlienatingPremise: "The whole short is just six minutes of watching a dog eat human food? Well... At least we get to see [[Disney/BigHero6 a cool superhero movie]] after it."
* HypeBacklash: As with ''WesternAnimation/PaperMan'' before it, expect to see a lot of vitriol from people who don't like it and arguments that the short should have been all hand drawn instead of CG that ''appears'' hand-drawn.[[note]]One behind-the-scenes video showed some pencil-and-paper animation being done as visual development, with several viewers and industry professionals exclaiming "You've got it! Don't do anything else to it!"[[/note]]
* NauseaFuel: Seeing how and what Winston eats can be rather stomach churning.
* TearJerker: Seeing Winston's owner [[spoiler:sadly deal with him breaking up with his girlfriend.]]